RMO No. 7-2015 revised BIR compromise penalties for non-fraud NIRC violations and clarified when unpaid or fraudulent cases proceed to criminal action.
Taxpayers facing non-fraud criminal violations of the National Internal Revenue Code must now be assessed using the BIR’s revised consolidated schedule of compromise penalties, with revenue officers required to apply the prescribed amounts uniformly and without deviation unless duly approved by authorized BIR officials. RMO No. 7-2015 matters immediately because compromise penalties are the BIR’s suggested settlement amounts in lieu of criminal prosecution, while cases involving fraud must be referred for criminal action rather than handled as ordinary compromise-penalty matters.
What RMO No. 7-2015 Changed
RMO No. 7-2015 adopted and implemented a revised consolidated Schedule of Compromise Penalties for violations of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended. The Order updated the compromise penalty schedule previously specified under RMO No. 19-2007 and directed internal revenue officers to apply the revised schedule uniformly.
The central compliance change is not a new tax rate, but a stricter and more uniform framework for the compromise penalties suggested for criminal violations of the Tax Code that do not involve fraudulent acts. In practical terms, where a taxpayer commits a covered non-fraud violation, the BIR officer handling the matter should not invent, negotiate, or vary the suggested compromise penalty amount outside the prescribed schedule, except where proper approval is obtained from the Commissioner, the concerned Deputy Commissioner, or, in proper cases, the Regional Director.
RMO No. 7-2015 also expressly removes certain acts or violations from the coverage of the compromise penalty schedule where those acts are commonly resorted to by taxpayers as means of tax evasion and have met the requirements of fraudulent acts. This is critical for business owners, CFOs, accountants, and tax managers because fraud cases are not merely administrative settlement matters. They must be referred to the concerned division having jurisdiction for the institution of the corresponding criminal action.
Who Is Most Affected by the Revised Schedule of Compromise Penalties
The Order affects taxpayers and withholding agents who may be exposed to criminal violations of the NIRC that do not involve fraud, including corporations, SMEs, sole proprietors, professionals, employers with withholding obligations, and other registered taxpayers subject to BIR compliance requirements. It also affects corporate accountants and tax compliance teams because compromise penalties are often encountered during audits, investigations, registration compliance reviews, return filing issues, withholding tax compliance, and other tax enforcement situations.
Large corporations and heavily regulated businesses should pay particular attention because the Order requires compromise penalties to be itemized separately and handled under a uniform schedule. A taxpayer receiving an assessment notice or demand letter should distinguish between deficiency basic tax, surcharge, interest, and the separate compromise penalty amount suggested to settle possible criminal liability.
For SMEs and closely held corporations, the more important point is criminal exposure. RMO No. 7-2015 makes clear that compromise penalties apply only to criminal violations not involving fraud. Once the BIR treats the act as fraudulent, the matter may proceed toward criminal action instead of ordinary compromise settlement.
Key Compliance Requirements Under RMO No. 7-2015
Revenue officers are directed to apply the Revised Schedule of Compromise Penalties embodied in Annex A of RMO No. 7-2015 to ensure uniformity of action. The Order states that in all cases of criminal violations of the NIRC not involving fraudulent acts, the compromise penalties to be imposed shall strictly follow the amounts in the revised schedule.
The Order further states that in no case shall the compromise penalty differ from the amount specified in the schedule, except when duly approved by the Commissioner, the concerned Deputy Commissioner, or, in proper cases, the Regional Directors. This means a taxpayer should not assume that a frontline officer has unrestricted discretion to reduce, increase, waive, or informally adjust a compromise penalty. If the suggested amount is lower than the prescribed amount, the acceptance of that lower compromise offer requires approval by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, the concerned Deputy Commissioner, Assistant Commissioner, or Regional Director.
At the same time, RMO No. 7-2015 does not prevent the Commissioner or his duly authorized representative from accepting a compromise amount higher than what is provided in the schedule. This is important for taxpayers negotiating resolution of enforcement matters because the prescribed schedule functions as the uniform baseline for compromise penalties, but it does not operate as an absolute ceiling where the BIR accepts a higher compromise amount.
Assessment Notices, Demand Letters, and Separate Treatment of Compromise Penalties
One of the most practical instructions in RMO No. 7-2015 concerns how compromise penalties should appear in BIR notices. The Order states that all amounts of compromise penalties incident to violations shall be itemized in the assessment notice and/or demand letter. However, the compromise penalty should not form part of the assessment notice that reflects deficiency basic tax, surcharge, and interest.
Instead, the compromise penalty should appear in a separate assessment notice or demand letter as the amount suggested to the taxpayer to pay in lieu of criminal prosecution. This distinction matters because deficiency tax, surcharge, and interest are assessed tax liabilities, while compromise penalties are suggested settlement amounts for potential criminal liability.
For CFOs and corporate accountants searching for BIR compromise penalties, revised schedule of compromise penalties, NIRC violations compromise penalty, BIR criminal tax violation settlement, or RMO 7-2015 compromise penalty schedule, the operational takeaway is straightforward: review any BIR demand carefully and separate the tax assessment components from the compromise penalty component. The compromise penalty should not be blindly treated as part of the deficiency tax computation.
Effectivity and Deadlines
RMO No. 7-2015 took effect immediately. The Order was dated January 22, 2015 and was signed by Commissioner Kim S. Jacinto-Henares. It does not prescribe a future compliance deadline, transition period, or grace period. Because the effectivity clause states that the Order shall take effect immediately, taxpayers dealing with covered NIRC violations from that point should expect the revised consolidated schedule and the related procedural instructions to govern BIR handling of compromise penalties.
Penalties and Criminal Consequences for Non-Compliance
RMO No. 7-2015 must be understood in the context of criminal tax enforcement. The Order states that compromise penalties are only amounts suggested in settlement of criminal liability and may not therefore be imposed or exacted on the taxpayer. If the taxpayer refuses to pay the suggested compromise penalty, the violation shall be referred to the appropriate office for criminal action.
This means non-payment of a suggested compromise penalty is not treated merely as a civil collection issue. The BIR’s remedy, as stated in the Order, is referral for criminal action. For taxpayers, the decision whether to pay a suggested compromise penalty should therefore be made with legal advice, especially where the underlying violation could expose the taxpayer, responsible corporate officers, or withholding agents to criminal proceedings.
The fraud rule is even more serious. Cases involving fraud must be referred to the concerned division having jurisdiction over the case for the institution of the corresponding criminal action. The Order also confirms that certain acts or violations commonly used as means of tax evasion were deleted from the schedule because they met the requirements of fraudulent acts. Taxpayers should therefore not assume that every Tax Code violation can be settled through a compromise penalty.
Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Tax Teams
First, businesses should classify the alleged violation. The threshold question is whether the matter is a non-fraud criminal violation covered by the compromise penalty schedule, or whether the BIR may consider the act fraudulent. If fraud is alleged or reasonably implied, the exposure is substantially higher because the matter may be referred for criminal action.
Second, taxpayers should verify whether the compromise penalty amount follows the revised schedule. RMO No. 7-2015 requires strict adherence to the scheduled amounts, subject only to proper approval by authorized officials. Any variance should be documented and supported by the required approval.
Third, accounting teams should review BIR notices carefully. The deficiency basic tax, surcharge, and interest should be separated from the compromise penalty. The compromise penalty should appear as a separate suggested amount in lieu of criminal prosecution, not as part of the deficiency tax computation.
Fourth, businesses should document any decision to accept, reject, or negotiate the compromise penalty. Because refusal to pay may result in referral for criminal action, responsible officers should not treat the matter as a routine assessment issue. Board-level or management-level approval may be appropriate where the amount is material or where criminal exposure is possible.
Finally, taxpayers should strengthen internal tax controls. The best response to RMO No. 7-2015 is not merely to budget for compromise penalties, but to reduce the likelihood of violations that may trigger BIR enforcement. This includes timely filing, proper registration, accurate withholding, complete books and records, and careful review of tax positions that may be characterized as evasion or fraud.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMO No. 7-2015 gives taxpayers a clearer framework for BIR compromise penalties, but it also highlights the risk that unresolved or fraud-related tax violations may proceed to criminal action. Businesses should not treat a compromise penalty notice as a simple billing statement. It should be reviewed for legal basis, proper classification, correct computation under the applicable schedule, and potential criminal exposure.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, SMEs, business owners, accountants, and in-house legal teams on BIR assessments, compromise penalties, tax audits, withholding tax compliance, and tax enforcement risk. For assistance in reviewing a BIR assessment notice, compromise penalty demand, or possible criminal tax exposure, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.