A tax-exempt employees’ trust may recover withholding tax when it proves beneficial ownership of property titled in another company’s name.

A tax-exempt employees’ retirement trust does not lose its exemption, or its right to a refund, merely because the real property it beneficially owns is registered and sold in another company’s name. When co-owners agree that title will be placed in one name for the benefit of all, the law can recognize a trust, and the Bureau of Internal Revenue must look beyond the certificate of title when the evidence proves beneficial ownership.

Why This Case Matters to Employers, Retirement Funds, and Property Investors

Many Philippine businesses administer retirement or pension funds through separate foundations, trustees, or investment managers. Those funds often invest in bank products, loans, securities, or real property. In practice, however, title to real estate may sometimes be placed in the name of an affiliate, parent company, or related corporation for convenience. This creates a serious tax question: if the property is sold and withholding tax is paid under the name of the registered owner, can the retirement trust still claim that its share of the sale proceeds is tax-exempt?

The Court’s answer is important for tax planning and tax refund litigation. Registration is strong evidence of ownership, but it is not always conclusive. A taxpayer may prove that the registered owner was holding the property in trust for the true beneficial owner. For employee retirement trusts, that distinction can determine whether millions in withholding taxes were properly collected or must be refunded.

Background: A Pension Foundation Claimed a Refund on a Real Property Sale

Miguel J. Ossorio Pension Foundation, Incorporated was a non-stock, non-profit corporation organized to hold title to, control, invest, and administer pension funds for employees of Victorias Milling Company, Inc. The Foundation claimed that part of the employees’ trust fund was invested in a lot at Madrigal Business Park in Alabang, Muntinlupa. The title, however, was registered solely in the name of Victorias Milling Company.

The property was later sold to Metrobank. As withholding agent, Metrobank paid withholding tax on the sale. The Foundation claimed that 49.59% of the property belonged beneficially to the employees’ trust fund and that the corresponding tax of P3,037,500 should be refunded because income of the employees’ trust fund was exempt from income tax. The Court of Tax Appeals and the Court of Appeals rejected the claim, treating the Foundation’s documents as self-serving and relying heavily on the fact that the title, deed of sale, and tax remittance were all in Victorias Milling Company’s name. The case reached the Supreme Court in Miguel J. Ossorio Pension Foundation, Inc. v. Court of Appeals and Commissioner of Internal Revenue (G.R. No. 162175).

The Doctrine: Common Consent Can Create a Trust Despite Title in One Name

The Supreme Court applied Article 1452 of the Civil Code, which recognizes an implied trust when two or more persons agree to purchase property and, by common consent, legal title is taken in the name of one of them for the benefit of all. In that situation, the registered owner holds title as trustee for the others in proportion to their respective interests.

This is the central doctrine of the case: beneficial ownership can prevail over registered title for tax purposes when the taxpayer proves that title was placed in one name by common consent and for the benefit of the true co-owners. The BIR cannot simply point to the Torrens title and ignore an implied trust created by law. The Torrens system protects innocent purchasers and lienholders who rely on the title; it was not designed to prevent a trust beneficiary from proving ownership against the government when no innocent purchaser’s rights are being impaired.

Why the Foundation Was Not Estopped by the Torrens Title

The BIR argued that because Victorias Milling Company was the registered owner, the Foundation should be barred from claiming co-ownership. The Court rejected that position. The BIR was not a buyer of the property. It did not acquire any interest in the land by relying on the certificate of title. Therefore, it could not invoke the protection normally given to innocent purchasers for value.

The Court emphasized that registration under the Torrens system does not create ownership. It is evidence of title, but it is not itself a mode of acquiring ownership. A certificate of title in one person’s name does not foreclose proof that the property is co-owned by others or that the registered owner holds it in trust.

The Evidence Was Sufficient to Prove Beneficial Ownership

The Supreme Court disagreed with the lower courts’ characterization of the Foundation’s evidence as merely self-serving. The notarized memorandum of agreement identified the co-owners of the Madrigal Business Park property and stated that the Foundation owned 49.59%, Victorias Milling Company owned 32.23%, and Victorias Insurance Factors Corporation owned 18.18%. Because the memorandum was notarized, it was a public document entitled to the presumption of regularity. The BIR presented no clear and convincing evidence that the document was fictitious or legally ineffective.

The Court also gave weight to Citytrust’s Portfolio Mix Analysis, which showed that the Foundation invested P5,504,748.25 in the property from the employees’ trust fund. The Court noted that Citytrust was a reputable banking institution and that the BIR had not shown that its records were falsified or tampered with. Together, the notarized agreement, corporate records, and investment manager’s documents proved that the employees’ trust fund beneficially owned 49.59% of the property.

Income of the Employees’ Trust Fund Was Exempt from Income Tax

The Court also clarified that the exemption of the employees’ trust fund was not a new or unresolved question. The Foundation existed to administer a pension fund for the exclusive benefit of employees. Its trust arrangement had already been recognized in prior proceedings and rulings. Under the Tax Code provision on employees’ trusts forming part of a pension, stock bonus, or profit-sharing plan, the income of a qualifying employees’ trust is not subject to income tax, provided the trust is maintained for the exclusive benefit of employees and the corpus or income cannot be diverted to other purposes before all employee liabilities are satisfied.

Because the Foundation proved that the real property investment belonged to the employees’ trust fund, the income attributable to that investment retained its tax-exempt character. The withholding tax collected on the trust fund’s share of the sale proceeds was therefore erroneously paid.

The Practical Impact: Substance and Trust Evidence Can Defeat a Formal Title Objection

For retirement funds, corporate groups, and trustees, the ruling is a reminder that tax exemption claims require evidence, not merely labels. The taxpayer won because it had a notarized agreement, board records, and third-party investment documents showing the source of funds, the co-ownership arrangement, and the trust purpose. Without those records, the result could have been different.

For the BIR, the ruling limits a purely formalistic approach. The government may examine the title, deed of sale, and withholding return, but it cannot ignore competent proof that another party was the beneficial owner and that the registered owner merely held title in trust. When Article 1452 applies, the trust arises by operation of law, and the tax consequences must follow the real beneficial ownership of the property.

For business owners, the case teaches a practical lesson: if property is bought for one entity but titled in another, the arrangement should be documented contemporaneously, clearly, and formally. Board approvals, trust instruments, memoranda of agreement, accounting records, investment reports, and proof of fund source can become decisive in a future tax audit or refund case.

Outcome of the Case

The Supreme Court granted the Foundation’s petition, set aside the Court of Appeals’ ruling, and directed the Commissioner of Internal Revenue to refund P3,037,500 to Miguel J. Ossorio Pension Foundation, Incorporated, as trustee of the Employees’ Trust Fund. The amount represented income tax erroneously paid on the trust fund’s share in the sale of the Madrigal Business Park property.

Tax Refund and Retirement Trust Litigation Assistance

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, retirement funds, trustees, property owners, and business groups in tax refund claims, BIR disputes, trust documentation, and litigation involving beneficial ownership of assets. If your company is facing a withholding tax issue, a denied refund, or a dispute involving property held through a trustee or affiliate, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax and litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *