RMO No. 36-2010 sets coordinated BIR audit rules for conglomerates, affiliates, and subsidiaries covering all internal revenue taxes for taxable year 2009.

Large corporate groups, parent companies, affiliates, and subsidiaries covered by the BIR’s Conglomerate Audit Program for taxable year 2009 must prepare for a coordinated, simultaneous audit of all internal revenue taxes, with Letters of Authority signed by the Commissioner and investigations required to be completed within six months from LA issuance. RMO No. 36-2010 matters now because it centralizes and intensifies the audit of interrelated companies, especially where related-party dealings, inter-company transactions, transfer pricing, cost-sharing, loans, advances, goods, services, agency arrangements, and resale arrangements may affect taxable income.

What RMO No. 36-2010 Changed

RMO No. 36-2010 prescribed the guidelines and procedures for the Conglomerate Audit Program for taxable year 2009. Its core change is the creation of a special audit and enforcement framework for interrelated companies, conglomerates, affiliates, and subsidiaries. The stated purpose is to address tax complexities in conglomerate operations and to establish rules for special investigation and enforcement activities involving related corporate groups.

The issuance amended portions of Revenue Memorandum Order No. 23-2009 insofar as they relate to the audit of interrelated companies and conglomerates. Instead of treating each corporation in isolation through ordinary audit channels, the program directs the Large Taxpayers Service and the Enforcement Service to identify conglomerates for audit, designate special audit teams, and conduct a simultaneous, joint, and coordinated examination of the books of taxpayers belonging to the same related group.

For purposes of the program, a conglomerate means a group of corporations with diversified business activities in varied industries, where the businesses are controlled and managed by the management of a parent corporate entity. An affiliate is an entity where one entity owns less than the majority of the voting stock of another, or when it is a subsidiary of another company. A subsidiary refers to an entity that is wholly or partially owned by a large corporation.

Who Is Most Affected

The most affected taxpayers are large corporate groups, conglomerates, parent companies, subsidiaries, affiliates, and businesses with inter-company transactions. This includes groups under the Large Taxpayers Service, whether LT-Regular or LT-Excise, and groups that may be selected by the Enforcement Service through the National Investigation Division.

The program is especially relevant to corporations with multiple related entities, shared management control, internal financing, shared services, inter-company purchases and sales, cost-sharing arrangements, transfer pricing exposure, agency or resale arrangements, and cross-company advances. A Philippine CFO, corporate accountant, or in-house counsel searching for RMO 36-2010, Conglomerate Audit Program Philippines, BIR audit of related parties, BIR transfer pricing audit 2009, or BIR audit parent company subsidiaries should understand that this issuance was designed precisely for corporate groups whose tax issues cannot be reviewed properly without seeing the larger group structure.

Selection of Conglomerates and Audit Teams

The Large Taxpayers Service and Enforcement Service are required to identify conglomerates consisting of interrelated companies, including the parent company, affiliates, and subsidiaries, that will be subject to audit under the program. The Assistant Commissioners for LT-Regular, LT-Excise, and Enforcement Service must submit to the Commissioner the list of four big and four small conglomerates.

The audit work is assigned to special audit teams. For the Large Taxpayers Service, examiners from the eight audit divisions under it may be assigned. For the Enforcement Service, the National Investigation Division handles the audit through designated groups. The audit teams are headed by their respective Assistant Commissioners, who report directly to the Commissioner.

For the Large Taxpayers Service, each audit division is assigned to audit one big conglomerate and one small conglomerate identified under the program. However, the Assistant Commissioner concerned, with the Commissioner’s approval, may assign the audit of a particular conglomerate to another audit division even if that division does not have jurisdiction over the principal parent company, when necessary to balance workload and promote operational efficiency.

Scope of the Audit: All Internal Revenue Taxes for Taxable Year 2009 Only

The investigation under RMO No. 36-2010 covers all internal revenue taxes for taxable year 2009 only. This is an important limitation. The program does not, by its own terms, create an open-ended audit of all years. However, within taxable year 2009, the coverage is broad: income tax, VAT, percentage tax, withholding tax, and other internal revenue taxes may be reviewed.

Revenue District Officers, through the Regional Directors, are required to transmit to the Office of the Commissioner all income, VAT, percentage, withholding, and other tax returns of the covered taxpayers within fifteen days from receipt of notification. This creates a centralized audit file for the selected conglomerate and allows the BIR to compare positions across related entities.

Letters of Authority and Change of Jurisdiction

Letters of Authority for taxpayers identified under the program must be signed by the Commissioner under the LA Monitoring System. The LAs are then issued and assigned to the designated audit teams in accordance with the procedures under RMO No. 36-2010.

A critical compliance consequence is that if a Regional Office has already issued an LA covering a taxpayer later identified under the Conglomerate Audit Program, the Regional Office LA is automatically invalidated. The investigating unit must forward the entire docket to the Large Taxpayers Service or Enforcement Service, as applicable, for consolidation.

For taxpayers not under the jurisdiction of the Large Taxpayers Service, and for taxpayers subject to investigation by the Enforcement Service, the LTS or ES must notify the affected taxpayers of the change of jurisdiction for the audit or investigation through a Notice of Change of Jurisdiction.

Related-Party Audit Procedures and CAATTs

RMO No. 36-2010 directs that verification generally follow the audit procedures prescribed in the Audit Manual, but it adds specific emphasis on related-party audit procedures and computer-assisted audit tools and techniques, or CAATTs.

For taxpayers with a computerized accounting system, the use of CAATTs is enjoined. The use of CAATTs is limited to data gathering, summarizing, and obtaining discrepancy reports involving voluminous business transactions. The resolution and final disposition of issues raised in the audit remain with the investigating division handling the case.

The issuance also directs the pursuit of special procedures peculiar to related-party audits where necessary to clearly reflect the true taxable income of controlled entities. The identified areas include tax avoidance schemes of related entities, inter-company transactions, transfer pricing, cost-sharing arrangements, inter-company loans and advances, provision of goods and services, agency arrangements, and resale arrangements.

Conference Letters, Assessment Notices, and Simultaneous Action

Before any Conference Letter is issued, all preliminary findings must be reviewed by the Assistant Commissioner or, in his absence, the Head Revenue Executive Assistant. The Conference Letter informs the taxpayer of the nature of the findings being assessed against it.

For interrelated taxpayers, conferences should be conducted simultaneously unless justifiable reasons exist to conduct them separately. This is significant for tax managers because positions taken by one company in the group may affect the findings against another company. In practice, finance and tax teams should coordinate explanations, reconcile inter-company accounts, and ensure that group-wide tax positions are consistent before conferences occur.

All Assessment Notices must be signed by the Commissioner. The issuance of Assessment Notices for interrelated taxpayers must likewise be conducted simultaneously unless there are justifiable reasons to do otherwise. Payment forms may be signed by the Assistant Commissioner concerned or, in his absence, by the Head Revenue Executive Assistant.

Deadlines and Reportorial Requirements

All investigations under the program must be completed, and the reports of investigation submitted, not later than six months from the issuance of the Letter of Authority. This six-month completion period is one of the most important compliance timelines under RMO No. 36-2010.

Each audit team, through its audit divisions, must submit a progress report to the Assistant Commissioner not later than the 5th day of every month until completion of the project. The Assistant Commissioners must consolidate and summarize the reports for inclusion in a monthly report to the Commissioner.

Within thirty days from completion, each audit team, through the Assistant Commissioners, must submit to the Commissioner recommended guidelines, standards, and procedures for the audit and tax treatment of related parties and inter-company transactions. These recommendations must include the identification of tax issues and tax planning schemes of related parties, tax treatment for controlled transactions, and audit procedures, rules, and regulations for related-party transactions.

Penalties and Collection Consequences

RMO No. 36-2010 does not prescribe a new penalty rate, surcharge, or interest rule. However, it provides a clear collection consequence after assessment. Final reports of investigation must be approved by the Commissioner, who issues the necessary Assessment Notices covering deficiency taxes wherever applicable.

All Assessment Notices remaining unpaid after the due date for payment specified in the Assessment Notice must be transmitted for collection to the collection units having jurisdiction over the taxpayers within fifteen days from the date of delinquency. For affected businesses, this means that once an Assessment Notice becomes delinquent, the matter may quickly move from audit to collection.

Practical Steps for Corporate Groups

Corporate groups potentially covered by RMO No. 36-2010 should immediately map all parent, affiliate, and subsidiary relationships for taxable year 2009. The group should identify which entities had transactions with each other, what tax returns were filed, what supporting documents exist, and whether the group’s positions are consistent across books, returns, contracts, invoices, loan documents, service agreements, and board approvals.

Finance teams should reconcile inter-company loans and advances, management fees, shared service charges, cost-sharing entries, sales or resale transactions, agency arrangements, and cross-charges for goods and services. Where computerized accounting systems were used, taxpayers should anticipate data requests and discrepancy reports generated through CAATTs.

In-house counsel and tax managers should also prepare for simultaneous conferences and simultaneous assessments. The group should avoid having each entity respond separately without coordination, because the program is specifically designed to examine the controlled group as a whole. A response for one entity may create admissions or inconsistencies affecting another related taxpayer.

Finally, taxpayers should track the six-month investigation period from LA issuance, the fifteen-day period for transmission of returns by Revenue District Officers after notification, the monthly progress reporting cycle within the BIR, the thirty-day post-completion period for recommended related-party audit guidelines, and the fifteen-day delinquency-to-collection transmission rule for unpaid Assessment Notices.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMO No. 36-2010 is a reminder that BIR audits of conglomerates are not ordinary single-entity audits. They require coordinated tax, accounting, corporate, and litigation strategy across the parent company, affiliates, and subsidiaries. The highest-risk areas are related-party transactions, transfer pricing, inter-company loans and advances, shared services, cost allocations, and inconsistencies across returns and books.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accounting teams, and in-house counsel in preparing for BIR audits, reviewing Letters of Authority and jurisdictional issues, organizing audit defenses, responding to Conference Letters, assessing deficiency tax exposure, and developing group-wide compliance strategies for related-party transactions. For legal assistance with BIR audit compliance, tax assessments, and corporate group tax risk, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *