RMO No. 39-2009 requires SGV-represented BIR cases needing the Commissioner’s final decision to undergo Special Review Committee evaluation.

Taxpayers whose BIR cases are represented by Sycip, Gorres, Velayo & Co. and require the final decision of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue should expect those cases to be routed through a Special Review Committee before final action. RMO No. 39-2009 changes the internal handling of these cases by requiring referral to a collegial review body created under Revenue Special Order No. 600-2009, in order to address any perception of conflict of interest.

What RMO No. 39-2009 Changed

RMO No. 39-2009 created a specific internal review mechanism for all cases represented by Sycip, Gorres, Velayo & Co. that require the final decision of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. Instead of proceeding directly through the usual route for final action by the Commissioner, these cases must be referred to a Special Review Committee.

The stated purpose of the order is to dispel any perception of conflict of interest. The rule is therefore not a new tax rate, not a new filing requirement, and not a new tax assessment procedure imposed on ordinary taxpayers. Its importance lies in how certain represented cases are reviewed inside the Bureau of Internal Revenue before reaching final decision.

The Special Review Committee was created under Revenue Special Order No. 600-2009. RMO No. 39-2009 directs that the relevant cases be referred to that committee, which must evaluate and deliberate on the merits of the cases. The committee must also review, approve, and sign the relevant documents as a collegial body.

Who Is Affected by RMO No. 39-2009

The most directly affected taxpayers are those with BIR cases represented by Sycip, Gorres, Velayo & Co. where the matter requires the final decision of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. This may include taxpayers involved in administrative tax disputes, requests, or other BIR matters that are elevated for final action by the Commissioner, provided they fall within the scope of the order.

The order is also relevant to corporate taxpayers, CFOs, in-house counsel, tax managers, and external tax advisers who monitor how BIR cases are handled when a matter is awaiting the Commissioner’s final decision. A business searching for terms such as RMO 39-2009 SGV cases, BIR Special Review Committee, BIR cases represented by SGV, conflict of interest BIR Commissioner, or Revenue Special Order No. 600-2009 is likely looking for this rule and its practical effect.

All internal revenue officers, employees, and other concerned persons are also covered, because the order is addressed to them and governs the internal routing and review of covered cases. For BIR personnel, the operational instruction is clear: covered cases must be referred to the Special Review Committee.

Key Compliance Requirement and Effective Date

The key requirement under RMO No. 39-2009 is referral. All cases represented by Sycip, Gorres, Velayo & Co. requiring the final decision of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue must be referred to the Special Review Committee created under Revenue Special Order No. 600-2009.

The order further requires the Special Review Committee to act as a collegial body. It must evaluate and deliberate on the merits of the covered cases. It must also review, approve, and sign the relevant documents as a collegial body. This is significant because the order emphasizes institutional review rather than action by a single official acting alone.

RMO No. 39-2009 takes effect immediately. The document is dated December 3, 2009. For covered cases pending at or after its effectivity, the practical consequence is that parties should account for the Special Review Committee’s role in the timing, handling, and documentation of final BIR action.

Does RMO No. 39-2009 Create New Taxes, Rates, or Filing Deadlines?

No. RMO No. 39-2009 does not impose a new tax, increase a tax rate, create a new withholding obligation, prescribe a new return, or set a taxpayer filing deadline. It is an internal administrative measure governing how a defined class of cases should be reviewed when they require the final decision of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.

For taxpayers, the practical point is not the payment of a new amount but the route of review. If the case falls within the order, the taxpayer and counsel should expect review by the Special Review Committee, including evaluation and deliberation on the merits and collegial approval and signing of documents.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

RMO No. 39-2009 does not state a specific taxpayer penalty for non-compliance. It does not prescribe surcharges, interest, compromise penalties, administrative fines, or criminal sanctions. The order is directed principally to BIR officers, employees, and other concerned persons for the internal handling of covered cases.

However, businesses should not treat the absence of a penalty clause as meaning that the order has no practical effect. Where a case is covered, failure to recognize the required referral mechanism may affect expectations on processing, routing, signatures, and final action. For taxpayers and representatives, the safest approach is to confirm whether the matter is within the scope of RMO No. 39-2009 and to prepare submissions that can withstand committee-level review on the merits.

Practical Steps for Taxpayers, CFOs, and In-House Counsel

First, determine whether the BIR matter requires the final decision of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. RMO No. 39-2009 applies only to cases represented by Sycip, Gorres, Velayo & Co. that require that level of final decision.

Second, identify whether the case is being handled in a way that triggers referral to the Special Review Committee. Because the order is aimed at dispelling any perception of conflict of interest, documentation and transparency become especially important. Taxpayers should keep a clean record of submissions, receipts, position papers, supporting documents, and communications with the BIR.

Third, prepare for merits-based review. The Special Review Committee is tasked to evaluate and deliberate on the merits of covered cases. Businesses should avoid relying solely on procedural follow-up and should ensure that the factual and legal bases of their position are organized, cited, and supported by evidence.

Fourth, account for collegial approval and signing. Because the committee must review, approve, and sign documents as a collegial body, internal timelines may differ from ordinary expectations. CFOs and tax managers should build this into dispute management calendars, settlement planning, financial reporting, and tax exposure assessments.

Why RMO No. 39-2009 Still Matters for BIR Case Management

RMO No. 39-2009 is a narrow but important governance issuance. It shows that the BIR may establish special internal controls for cases where the public perception of impartiality must be protected. For businesses involved in high-value or sensitive BIR matters, the order is a reminder that tax controversy strategy must account not only for substantive tax law but also for the administrative route through which decisions are reviewed and signed.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporations, accounting teams, and in-house counsel in managing BIR audits, assessments, administrative remedies, tax controversy documentation, and compliance strategy. For assistance with BIR case handling, tax assessments, administrative protests, or tax compliance risk review, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *