RMO No. 36-2008 centralizes approval and escalation rules for 2006 BIR Letter Notices, PAN/FAN protests, and installment payment requests.
Taxpayers with unresolved 2006 Letter Notices face a more centralized and higher-level BIR review process: dockets may now move to the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group for issue-based Letters of Authority, Preliminary Assessment Notices, and Final Assessment Notices, while installment payment requests outside the prescribed scheme require approval by senior BIR officials depending on the amount involved.
What RMO No. 36-2008 Changed
RMO No. 36-2008 amended portions of Revenue Memorandum Order No. 32-2007 governing the handling of 2006 Letter Notices generated through the Reconciliation of Listing for Enforcement System, or RELIEF, particularly Summary List of Sales and Purchases matching, and the Third Party Matching-Bureau of Customs data program, or TPM-BOC.
The practical effect is that the BIR strengthened centralized control over 2006 Letter Notice cases. Instead of leaving certain approvals and document-signing functions at lower levels, RMO No. 36-2008 directs key processes, communications, reports, dockets, protests, installment deviations, and cancellation or closure actions through the National Office Letter Notice Task Force, the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, and relevant information systems.
For businesses, the most important change is procedural but highly consequential. A Letter Notice discrepancy is not merely an informal query. If not resolved, the related docket may be endorsed for issuance of an issue-based Letter of Authority, Preliminary Assessment Notice, and Final Assessment Notice, as the case may be. This means that RELIEF SLSP mismatches and Bureau of Customs third-party matching issues may progress into formal assessment proceedings.
Who Is Affected
RMO No. 36-2008 principally affects taxpayers who were issued 2006 Letter Notices based on RELIEF-SLSP data matching and TPM-BOC data matching. These are typically VAT-registered businesses, corporations, importers, taxpayers with reported purchases or sales appearing in third-party records, and businesses whose importation data, sales listings, or purchase listings may not reconcile with BIR records.
The issuance also directly affects BIR officers handling Letter Notice cases, including the National Office Letter Notice Task Force, the Office of the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group, regional offices, AITEID, and the Systems Operations Division. However, the business impact falls most heavily on taxpayers with unresolved discrepancies from the 2006 taxable year, especially those with possible underdeclaration of sales, overstatement of purchases, unmatched import data, or other third-party information inconsistencies.
Common search issues for affected taxpayers include BIR Letter Notice RELIEF mismatch, SLSP discrepancy assessment, BIR third party matching Bureau of Customs, Letter Notice installment payment BIR, and PAN FAN after Letter Notice.
Key Compliance Requirements and Approval Rules
RMO No. 36-2008 provides that all processes, communications, and reports in the handling of Letter Notices by the National Office Letter Notice Task Force, after review and evaluation by the Letter Notice Task Force Head, must be approved by the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group.
All dockets relating to the covered 2006 Letter Notices must be endorsed by the Letter Notice Task Force to the Office of the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group for issuance of an issue-based Letter of Authority, Preliminary Assessment Notice, or Final Assessment Notice, as the case may be. This is a critical compliance point because it confirms that unresolved Letter Notice discrepancies may be escalated into the formal assessment process.
If a taxpayer protests a PAN or FAN and requests reinvestigation or reconsideration, the Letter Notice Task Force must evaluate the protest. The resulting report must then be forwarded to the Office of the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group for appropriate action. Taxpayers should therefore ensure that any protest or request for reinvestigation is complete, supported by reconciliations and documentary evidence, and filed within the applicable assessment rules.
RMO No. 36-2008 also revises the approval authority for requests for installment payment of tax liabilities when the requested installment arrangement deviates from the payment scheme prescribed under RMO No. 32-2007. For liabilities over P500,000.00 up to P10,000,000.00, approval is required from the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group. For liabilities over P10,000,000.00, approval is required from the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.
This amount-based approval rule is especially important for CFOs, accountants, and business owners negotiating payment terms with the BIR. A taxpayer cannot assume that a revenue officer or lower office may approve a non-standard installment arrangement. If the proposed payment plan deviates from the prescribed scheme and the tax liability exceeds the relevant threshold, the request must reach the proper approving authority.
Monitoring, Duplicate Letter Notices, and Cancellation or Closure
RMO No. 36-2008 requires the activities and accomplishments of the Letter Notice Task Force to be monitored online through the Information Delivery Portal by the Office of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Office of the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group, Office of the Regional Director, and AITEID. Monitoring is conducted under the e-Correspondence Monitoring System and Letter Notice Monitoring System, based on access rights and privileges granted to the relevant offices.
The issuance also addresses cases where a taxpayer has two Letter Notices, specifically a RELIEF Letter Notice and a TRS Letter Notice. In that situation, both Letter Notice dockets must be forwarded to the Office of the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group for proper disposition. For taxpayers, this matters because multiple Letter Notices should not be handled in isolation if they relate to the same taxpayer. A consolidated strategy may be necessary to prevent inconsistent explanations, duplicated submissions, or avoidable escalation.
For cancellation or closure, the List of Approved Letter Notices for cancellation or closure by the Letter Notice Task Force must be transmitted to AITEID, which will then forward the list to the Systems Operations Division for cancellation or closure in the Letter Notice Monitoring System. Taxpayers who have settled or successfully explained discrepancies should confirm that the case is not only substantively resolved but also properly reflected as cancelled or closed in the BIR monitoring system.
Effective Date and Deadlines
RMO No. 36-2008 is dated December 8, 2008 and takes effect immediately. The issuance does not create a new taxpayer filing deadline in the text, but it immediately changes the internal approval and routing rules for covered 2006 Letter Notice cases.
Because the order applies to the handling of 2006 Letter Notices generated under RELIEF-SLSP and TPM-BOC data matching, taxpayers receiving communications on these cases should treat them as assessment-sensitive matters. The immediate concern is not merely responding to a discrepancy notice, but preventing escalation to an issue-based Letter of Authority, PAN, or FAN where possible.
Penalties and Consequences for Non-Compliance
RMO No. 36-2008 does not prescribe new tax rates, surcharge rates, interest rates, or compromise penalty amounts. Its focus is on authority, routing, approval, monitoring, and escalation of covered Letter Notice cases.
The consequence of non-compliance is procedural escalation. If a taxpayer fails to properly address the Letter Notice discrepancy, the docket may be endorsed for issuance of a Letter of Authority, Preliminary Assessment Notice, and Final Assessment Notice, as appropriate. Once a PAN or FAN is issued, the matter moves into the formal assessment and protest framework, where missed deadlines or unsupported protests can materially prejudice the taxpayer.
Businesses should therefore avoid treating Letter Notices as routine correspondence. RELIEF and TPM-BOC matching cases are based on third-party data, and discrepancies may involve reported sales, purchases, imports, or mismatched declarations. The taxpayer’s response must be supported by accounting records, tax returns, import documents, invoices, official receipts, SLSP submissions, and reconciliation schedules.
Practical Steps for Taxpayers
First, identify whether the Letter Notice arose from RELIEF-SLSP matching, TPM-BOC matching, TRS matching, or more than one source. The response strategy should be built around the exact data source because sales, purchases, and importation discrepancies require different documentary support.
Second, prepare a reconciliation of the BIR-noted discrepancy against the taxpayer’s VAT returns, income tax returns, summary lists, books of accounts, import entries, supplier records, customer records, and audited financial statements. The reconciliation should explain whether the difference is due to timing, classification, duplicate reporting, cancelled transactions, exempt or zero-rated transactions, import documentation issues, or actual underdeclaration.
Third, if an assessment notice has already been issued, determine whether the taxpayer is responding to a PAN, a FAN, or another communication. A protest, request for reinvestigation, or request for reconsideration must be prepared with procedural deadlines in mind and should include all available supporting evidence.
Fourth, if the taxpayer intends to request installment payment and the proposed terms deviate from the RMO No. 32-2007 payment scheme, determine the total liability. Requests involving over P500,000.00 up to P10,000,000.00 require approval by the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group. Requests involving over P10,000,000.00 require approval by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.
Fifth, after settlement, cancellation, or closure, taxpayers should request confirmation that the Letter Notice has been properly reflected in the Letter Notice Monitoring System. A resolved case that remains open in the system may still cause follow-up correspondence, internal monitoring issues, or complications in future BIR dealings.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMO No. 36-2008 shows why BIR Letter Notices should be handled with the same discipline as tax assessments. A discrepancy generated by RELIEF, SLSP, TPM-BOC, or other third-party matching programs can quickly become a formal assessment matter if the taxpayer’s explanation is incomplete, unsupported, or procedurally late.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, importers, accountants, and in-house counsel in responding to BIR Letter Notices, preparing reconciliations, handling PAN and FAN protests, negotiating installment payment requests, and managing tax assessment risk. For businesses dealing with BIR Letter Notice discrepancies or assessment exposure, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult a Philippine tax and business law team based in Makati City.