RMO No. 24-2008 sets BIR RATE rules for tax evasion cases, including fraud investigations, prosecution procedures, P1M thresholds, and 50% civil fraud surcharge.

Taxpayers facing suspected fraud, willful non-filing, false returns, or other criminal tax violations may now be investigated and prosecuted under a more formal Run After Tax Evaders framework even without prior service of an assessment notice. RMO No. 24-2008 makes clear that the BIR’s RATE Program is not merely a collection tool; it is a criminal enforcement program designed to pursue cases with strong deterrent value, especially where the basic tax deficiency reaches at least P1,000,000 per year and per tax type, with priority for cases involving P50,000,000 or more in aggregate basic tax deficiencies per year.

What RMO No. 24-2008 Changed

RMO No. 24-2008 provides the policies and guidelines for the development, investigation, and prosecution of cases under the BIR’s Run After Tax Evaders Program, more commonly known as the RATE Program. Its most important practical effect is that criminal tax cases are treated as a separate and serious enforcement track, not as matters that automatically disappear once deficiency taxes are paid.

The Order explains that before the RATE Program, tax enforcement policy focused heavily on assessment and collection. The criminal aspect of violations of internal revenue laws was often not pursued once the taxpayer paid the assessed taxes. RMO No. 24-2008 changes that enforcement posture by emphasizing criminal investigation and prosecution to create deterrence, enhance voluntary compliance, and promote public confidence in the tax system.

For business owners, CFOs, corporate accountants, and in-house counsel, the critical takeaway is this: settlement or payment of deficiency taxes should not be assumed to eliminate criminal exposure where the BIR believes the facts show fraud or criminal violations of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997.

Criminal Tax Prosecution May Proceed Without an Assessment Notice

RMO No. 24-2008 expressly states that, in the prosecution of criminal cases for violation of internal revenue laws, service of an Assessment Notice to the taxpayer is not a requirement. The Order cites the Supreme Court rulings in Ungab v. Cusi and Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Pascor Realty & Development Corporation as the basis for this rule.

However, the Order also recognizes the effect of Republic Act No. 9282, which expanded the jurisdiction of the Court of Tax Appeals. Since the criminal action and the corresponding civil action for recovery of taxes and penalties are simultaneously instituted and jointly determined before the CTA, the filing of the criminal action is deemed to carry with it the filing of the civil action. For this reason, RATE cases filed with the Court of Tax Appeals must, as much as possible, be accompanied by an initial assessment.

This is an important distinction for taxpayers searching for guidance on BIR criminal tax case assessment notice, tax evasion Philippines, RATE case BIR, and CTA tax fraud prosecution. A taxpayer cannot rely solely on the absence of a formal assessment notice as a defense against criminal prosecution.

Who Is Most Affected by RMO No. 24-2008

The Order is most relevant to taxpayers that may be considered high-profile, well-known within their community, industry, or sector, or involved in transactions where the BIR believes there is prima facie evidence of fraud. It also affects taxpayers whose cases involve violations under Sections 254, 255, 257, and 258 of the NIRC of 1997, including one-time transactions.

The affected taxpayers may include corporations, business owners, professionals, withholding agents, taxpayers involved in one-time taxable transactions, and companies flagged through third-party information. The Order specifically allows RATE cases to be developed from findings of infractions under the Third Party Information Program.

The monetary threshold is also significant. To qualify under the RATE Program, the estimated basic tax deficiency must be at least P1,000,000 per year and per tax type. Priority is given to cases where aggregate basic tax deficiencies for all tax types per year amount to P50,000,000 or more.

Key RATE Case Criteria Under RMO No. 24-2008

A case may qualify under the RATE Program if it involves violations under Sections 254, 255, 257, or 258 of the NIRC of 1997, including one-time transactions. Section 254 generally concerns attempted tax evasion or defeat of tax. Section 255 concerns failure to file returns, supply correct and accurate information, pay tax, withhold tax, or remit tax. Sections 257 and 258 concern unlawful pursuit of business and other offenses involving tax-related violations under the Tax Code.

RMO No. 24-2008 also requires that the taxpayer be high-profile or well-known within the relevant community, industry, or sector. The Order further requires an estimated basic tax deficiency of at least P1,000,000 per year and per tax type, with priority for cases involving P50,000,000 or more in aggregate basic tax deficiencies for all tax types per year.

For taxpayers, this means RATE exposure is not limited to the largest corporations. A mid-sized business or individual taxpayer may fall within the program if the P1,000,000 per tax type and per year threshold is met and the case has facts that support criminal tax allegations.

Letters of Authority and RATE Investigations

RMO No. 24-2008 provides specific rules on Letters of Authority for RATE cases. For RATE cases investigated by the National Investigation Division or Policy Cases Division, the Letter of Authority is signed by the Deputy Commissioner for Legal and Inspection Group. For RATE cases in the Regional Offices, the Letter of Authority is signed by the Regional Director.

The issuance of a Letter of Authority for a RATE case covers only the taxable years where prima facie evidence of fraud or violation of the Tax Code has been established. However, prior or subsequent years may also be investigated when necessary to trace continuing transactions, transactions that began in prior years and concluded in the covered year, or where the same scheme appears to have been used in prior or subsequent years.

The Order also allows the National Investigation Division, Policy Cases Division, and Special Investigation Division to conduct a second examination or inspection of the taxpayer’s books of accounts and accounting records in RATE cases, even if a regular audit examination had already been conducted, subject to Section 235 of the Tax Code of 1997. Any payment of deficiency tax or amount assessed in the first investigation must be credited against the assessment in the second case if the same findings or issues are included.

Mandatory LAMS Verification and Deadline for TAMP Lists

To avoid duplicate Letters of Authority and simultaneous investigations of the same taxpayer for the current taxable year, RMO No. 24-2008 makes verification through the Letter of Authority Monitoring System mandatory for the National Investigation Division, Policy Cases Division, and Special Investigation Division.

The Order also requires each district office to submit to the Regional Director, Deputy Commissioner for Legal and Inspection Group, and Office of the Commissioner a list certified by the Revenue District Officer or Assistant Revenue District Officer. The list must enumerate all taxpayers in the district included in the Taxpayer Account Management Program. This list must be submitted on or before January 31 of each year. For the current year covered by the Order, the deadline was July 5, 2008.

The provisions of the Letter of Authority Monitoring System on encoding and status updating of Letters of Authority under RMO No. 8-2006 are strictly enforced. Any violation is treated as subject to administrative sanctions.

Preliminary Investigation Comes Before Formal RATE Investigation

RMO No. 24-2008 requires a Preliminary Investigation to establish the prima facie existence of fraud before a RATE case proceeds to Formal Investigation. The Preliminary Investigation includes verification and determination of the schemes and extent of fraud allegedly committed by the taxpayer.

The Formal Investigation, which may include examination of the taxpayer’s books of accounts, accounting records, and third-party records through Letters of Authority and access letters, is conducted only after prima facie evidence of fraud has been established.

This requirement matters because a taxpayer should expect that RATE cases will be document-intensive. The BIR will not only look at the taxpayer’s own books and returns; the Order specifically contemplates third-party records and referrals from other investigating units.

How RATE Cases Are Referred and Prosecuted

For cases handled by the National Investigation Division, Policy Cases Division, or Large Taxpayer Service, the RATE Legal Writing and Appearance Group or Special Prosecution Division evaluates whether the RATE criteria are present, whether the case is winnable, whether the documents are complete, whether all elements of the crime are present, and whether other considerations promote the objectives of the Order.

If the case is sufficient in form and substance, the Complaint Affidavit and Referral Letter are prepared and elevated for review and signature by the Deputy Commissioner for Legal and Inspection Group and the Office of the Commissioner. The case is then filed before the Department of Justice. If filed before the Court of Tax Appeals, the BIR prosecution unit cooperates with the DOJ Prosecutor in prosecuting the case, unless otherwise deputized to directly handle it.

For regional cases, the Special Investigation Division or Revenue District Office may refer cases to the Legal Division of the Revenue Region or, depending on the amount and jurisdiction, to the Deputy Commissioner for Legal and Inspection Group and the RATE Legal Writing and Appearance Group or Special Prosecution Division.

Civil Fraud and the 50% Surcharge

RMO No. 24-2008 also addresses situations where the evidence may not be enough for criminal prosecution beyond reasonable doubt, but there is clear and convincing evidence that fraud has been committed. In that case, the taxpayer may still face the corresponding 50% surcharge for civil fraud.

This rule is important because a taxpayer may avoid criminal prosecution only to still face serious civil tax consequences. The evidentiary standards differ. Criminal prosecution requires proof beyond reasonable doubt, while civil fraud under the Order may proceed where there is clear and convincing evidence of fraud.

Penalties for Non-Compliance with RMO No. 24-2008

The Penal Clause of RMO No. 24-2008 is directed at BIR officials and employees implementing the Order. It requires strict compliance and provides that any violation shall be treated as an administrative infraction, with the corresponding penalty under the Updated Code of Conduct.

For taxpayers, the more practical exposure lies in the underlying Tax Code violations, criminal prosecution before the DOJ and the Court of Tax Appeals, civil liability for taxes and penalties, possible 50% civil fraud surcharge, and reputational impact of being pursued under the Run After Tax Evaders Program.

Effective Date

RMO No. 24-2008 took effect immediately. The Order is dated May 9, 2008 and was issued under the signature of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.

Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Tax Teams

Businesses should treat RMO No. 24-2008 as a reminder that tax compliance is not merely a matter of paying assessments after an audit. Where the BIR believes the facts show willful evasion, false returns, failure to file, failure to remit, or other criminal conduct, the case may proceed under the RATE Program.

Companies should immediately review high-risk tax positions, especially those involving large recurring discrepancies, unreported sales, unsupported deductions, withholding tax failures, one-time transactions, related-party arrangements, and issues that may be discovered through third-party information. CFOs and corporate accountants should preserve supporting documents, reconcile tax returns with audited financial statements and books of accounts, and ensure that withholding taxes and remittances are properly documented.

Where a taxpayer receives a Letter of Authority, access request, notice, or inquiry suggesting fraud or RATE review, management should involve tax counsel early. The response should be coordinated, factual, document-based, and consistent across accounting, legal, and operational teams. A poorly handled explanation can aggravate the risk of a civil fraud surcharge or criminal referral.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, officers, accountants, and taxpayers in handling BIR audits, fraud investigations, RATE-related exposure, tax assessments, compromise strategy, document review, and representation in tax controversy matters. Our Makati-based tax and business law practice helps clients assess risk early, prepare defensible responses, and coordinate legal strategy before tax issues escalate into criminal proceedings.

If your company is facing a BIR audit, Letter of Authority, suspected tax fraud issue, RATE Program concern, or possible referral for criminal tax prosecution, consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *