RMO No. 20-2008 sets BIR benchmarking and pre-audit rules for 2007 income, VAT, and percentage tax returns, including LA and TVN thresholds.
Businesses and professionals with 2007 income tax, VAT, or percentage tax returns falling below the normal tax-to-sales ratio for their industry may be selected for audit, verification, or formal investigation. RMO No. 20-2008 requires BIR investigating offices to pre-audit 2007 tax returns, establish industry or profession benchmarks, and issue Letters of Authority or Tax Verification Notices depending on the taxpayer’s gross sales, revenues, or receipts. For CFOs, accountants, and business owners, the immediate concern is clear: 2007 tax compliance will not be reviewed only by checking whether returns were filed, but by comparing taxes paid against gross sales, revenues, or receipts within the taxpayer’s industry or profession.
What RMO No. 20-2008 Changed
RMO No. 20-2008, issued on May 23, 2008, prescribed the guidelines for the preliminary analysis and audit or verification of 2007 internal revenue tax returns and the corresponding tax payments of taxpayers under the Large Taxpayers Service, Revenue Regions, and Revenue District Offices.
The most important change is the use of benchmarking as an audit selection tool. The BIR directed investigating offices to classify taxpayers by industry or profession and determine the ratio of tax due against gross sales, revenues, or receipts. Once the BIR identifies the normal or common ratio for a particular industry or profession, taxpayers whose compliance falls below that benchmark may be selected for audit or verification.
This means the BIR’s review is not limited to isolated errors in returns. A taxpayer may be flagged because its income tax, VAT, or percentage tax payment appears low when measured against its declared sales or receipts and compared with similarly situated businesses or professionals.
Who Is Affected by RMO No. 20-2008
RMO No. 20-2008 affects corporations and individuals engaged in business or the practice of profession who filed 2007 income and business tax returns. This includes taxpayers under the Large Taxpayers Service, as well as taxpayers registered with Revenue Regions and Revenue District Offices.
The issuance is particularly important for businesses with significant gross sales, revenues, or receipts; VAT-registered taxpayers; percentage taxpayers; professionals whose tax payments may be compared with others in the same field; and taxpayers claiming deductions, tax credits, incentives, exemptions, or excess tax carry-overs. It also affects taxpayers that retired from business, transferred their principal place of business in taxable year 2007, filed estate tax returns, sought tax refunds or tax credit certificates, or underwent mergers, consolidations, split-ups, spin-offs, or other corporate reorganizations.
For large taxpayers, the rule is especially direct: Letters of Authority are to be issued for taxpayers whose tax compliance falls below the benchmark. For regional taxpayers, the issuance of a Letter of Authority or Tax Verification Notice depends on the gross sales, revenues, or receipts thresholds stated in the order.
How the BIR Will Measure Tax Compliance
For income tax, the ratio is computed by dividing the tax due per final income tax return by gross sales, revenues, or receipts, whichever is applicable depending on the taxpayer’s accounting method.
For VAT, the ratio is computed by dividing the total net VAT payable for the four quarters, using Line 25 of BIR Form No. 2550Q, by gross taxable sales, revenues, or receipts, using Line 15A of BIR Form No. 2550Q.
For percentage tax, the ratio is computed by dividing the total percentage tax due for the year, using Line 19 of BIR Form No. 2551M or 2551Q, by the total taxable amount or base, using Line 14C of BIR Form No. 2551Q.
RMO No. 20-2008 also states that where other taxable gross sales, revenues, or receipts and underdeclared income are determined through third-party information or other sources within and outside the BIR, those amounts must be included in gross sales, revenues, or receipts for purposes of computing the ratios. This is critical because the benchmark analysis may be affected not only by the figures declared in the return, but also by third-party data available to the BIR.
Industry and Profession Benchmarking
The BIR may classify taxpayers by industry or profession to determine the normal or common ratio of income tax and business tax. If needed, taxpayers may be sub-classified within an industry group, but the sub-classification must not exceed three categories within one industry or type of business. The order gives restaurants as an example, which may be classified into fine dining, fast food, and ordinary canteen.
This matters because a business will not necessarily be measured against all taxpayers in general. It may be compared against taxpayers that the BIR considers similarly situated within the same industry, profession, or sub-classification. For accountants and CFOs searching for 2007 BIR tax audit benchmarking, RMO No. 20-2008 tax compliance ratio, or BIR industry benchmark audit, this is the operative rule: a low tax-to-sales ratio may become the basis for audit selection.
Key Items the BIR Will Pre-Audit
The pre-audit under RMO No. 20-2008 focuses on several specific areas. First, the BIR will check the mathematical computation of the tax due and tax payment. Second, it will examine the correctness of the application of the minimum corporate income tax under Section 27(E) and Section 28(A)(2) of the 1997 National Internal Revenue Code, as implemented by Revenue Regulations No. 9-98, as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 12-2007, and clarified through revenue memorandum circulars.
Third, the BIR will review the validity of claims for income tax holiday, tax exemption, and other claimed tax incentives that resulted in non-payment or reduced payment of tax due. Fourth, it will examine the correctness and validity of deductions from gross income that are subject to limits under existing law and regulations, specifically interest expense, contributions, and representation expense.
Fifth, the BIR will check the completeness and accuracy of creditable withholding taxes claimed against tax due, including whether the claims are properly substantiated through certificates attached to the returns or submitted electronically. Sixth, it will verify the correct usage of Tax Credit Certificates, which must always be supported by an approved Tax Debit Memo issued by the authorized Revenue Official.
Finally, the pre-audit will review the correct application of excess income tax carry-over, excess input tax carry-over, and the correct application or offsetting of partial tax payments made before the due date of the tax.
When a Letter of Authority Will Be Issued
For taxpayers under Revenue Regions and Revenue District Offices, RMO No. 20-2008 provides specific gross sales, revenues, or receipts thresholds for the issuance of Letters of Authority. A Letter of Authority will be issued for income and business tax returns where gross sales, revenues, or receipts exceed P10,000,000.00 for Revenue Region Nos. 5, 6, 7, and 8, covering Valenzuela, Manila, Quezon City, and Makati, except RDO Nos. 35 Romblon, 36 Puerto Princesa, and 37 San Jose, Occidental Mindoro.
For all other regions, including RDO Nos. 35 Romblon, 36 Puerto Princesa, and 37 San Jose, Occidental Mindoro, a Letter of Authority will be issued where gross sales, revenues, or receipts exceed P5,000,000.00.
For taxpayers under the Large Taxpayers Service, Letters of Authority will be issued for taxpayers whose tax compliance falls below the benchmark. The Large Taxpayers Audit Divisions and Large Taxpayers District Offices must maintain their audit policies and reporting requirements under existing issuances until further amended.
When a Tax Verification Notice Will Be Issued
Tax Verification Notices apply to smaller cases under the thresholds provided in the issuance. For Revenue Region Nos. 5, 6, 7, and 8, covering Valenzuela, Manila, Quezon City, and Makati, a Tax Verification Notice will be issued for income and business tax returns where gross sales, revenues, or receipts amount to P10,000,000.00 and below, except for RDO Nos. 35 Romblon, 36 Puerto Princesa, and 37 San Jose, Occidental Mindoro.
For all other regions, including RDO Nos. 35 Romblon, 36 Puerto Princesa, and 37 San Jose, Occidental Mindoro, a Tax Verification Notice will be issued where gross sales, revenues, or receipts amount to P5,000,000.00 and below.
Businesses searching for BIR Letter of Authority threshold, BIR Tax Verification Notice 2007 returns, or RMO 20-2008 audit guidelines should note that the key dividing line is based on gross sales, revenues, or receipts and the taxpayer’s region or RDO coverage.
Mandatory Cases for LA or TVN
RMO No. 20-2008 also identifies mandatory cases where Revenue District Offices must issue Letters of Authority or Tax Verification Notices. These include claims for issuance of tax credit certificate and refund, including claims for tax credit or refund on erroneous or double payment of taxes; estate tax returns; taxpayers retiring from business; taxpayers undergoing merger, consolidation, split-up, spin-off, and other corporate reorganizations; protested cases; and taxpayers that transferred their principal place of business in taxable year 2007.
For claims for tax credit or refund, estate tax returns, retirement from business, corporate reorganizations, and protested cases, the thresholds under RMO No. 12-2007 remain the basis for the issuance of a Letter of Authority or Tax Verification Notice. For taxpayers that transferred their principal place of business in taxable year 2007, the applicable thresholds under RMO No. 20-2008 apply.
Effective Date and Penalties for Non-Compliance
RMO No. 20-2008 took effect immediately upon issuance. The order does not create a separate schedule of penalties. However, taxpayers selected for audit or verification may be exposed to the ordinary consequences of deficiency tax assessments if the BIR finds underdeclared income, improper deductions, unsupported tax credits, invalid incentives, incorrect carry-overs, or erroneous tax payments.
The practical risk is not limited to the issuance of a notice. Once a taxpayer is selected for audit or verification, the BIR may examine whether the tax return correctly reported income, applied MCIT, substantiated withholding tax credits, used Tax Credit Certificates properly, and supported deductions subject to statutory limits. Any deficiency findings may lead to assessment proceedings under the applicable tax rules.
Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Accountants
Taxpayers affected by RMO No. 20-2008 should begin by recomputing their 2007 income tax, VAT, and percentage tax ratios using the formulas in the order. The key figures are tax due per final income tax return, gross sales, revenues, or receipts, total net VAT payable for the four quarters, gross taxable sales, revenues, or receipts, total percentage tax due, and total taxable amount or base.
Businesses should then compare their tax-to-sales ratios with what may reasonably be expected for their industry or profession. While the BIR’s internal benchmark may not be publicly available, taxpayers can still identify audit risk by looking for unusually low tax payments relative to sales, large deductions, significant tax credit claims, repeated carry-overs, or reduced tax payments due to incentives or exemptions.
Taxpayers should also organize supporting documents for creditable withholding taxes, Tax Credit Certificates, Tax Debit Memos, MCIT computations, tax incentive approvals, interest expense, contributions, representation expenses, and proof of partial tax payments made before the due date. For taxpayers involved in mergers, consolidations, business retirement, refunds, estate tax filings, protested cases, or transfers of principal place of business in 2007, the documentation review should be treated as urgent because those cases are specifically identified as mandatory LA or TVN cases.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMO No. 20-2008 is a reminder that BIR audit exposure often begins before a formal assessment is issued. A taxpayer may be selected because its declared taxes appear low compared with gross sales, revenues, receipts, or industry benchmarks. For companies, professionals, and accounting teams, the best defense is a documented, return-by-return review before the BIR asks for explanations.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, corporate accountants, in-house counsel, and professionals in BIR audit preparation, tax verification responses, Letter of Authority strategy, tax refund and tax credit documentation, MCIT review, withholding tax substantiation, and assessment defense. For guidance on RMO No. 20-2008, BIR tax audit benchmarking, or Revenue District Office tax verification issues, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.