RMO No. 64-99 set the 1999 BIR audit program for top large taxpayers, monitored industries, policy cases, and taxable year 1998 liabilities.

Large taxpayers, banks, insurance companies, stock brokers, selected conglomerates, and companies in the chemical, food, and beverage sectors should treat taxable year 1998 as a priority audit-risk year under RMO No. 64-99. The Order prescribes the policies, guidelines, and standards for implementing the 1999 Audit Program on Large Taxpayers and Policy Cases, covering Income Tax, Value-Added Tax, Percentage Tax, Withholding Tax, and other tax returns and liabilities.

What RMO No. 64-99 Changed

RMO No. 64-99 established the 1999 Audit Program on Large Taxpayers and Policy Cases. Its practical effect was to identify the taxpayers and industries that would be placed under focused BIR audit review for taxable year 1998. For business owners, CFOs, corporate accountants, and tax managers, the key point is that the BIR was not conducting a random or general audit program. It expressly targeted large taxpayers, certain financial-sector businesses, and selected industries for coordinated examination.

The Order covered taxable year 1998 and applied to Income Tax, Value-Added Tax, Percentage Tax, Withholding Tax, and other tax returns and liabilities. It also clarified that taxable year 1998 included corporations with fiscal years ending on or before June 30, 1999. This is important for corporations using fiscal years instead of calendar years, because the audit coverage was not limited to companies whose taxable year ended on December 31, 1998.

For search purposes, the most relevant phrases are BIR 1999 audit program, RMO 64-99 large taxpayers audit, BIR policy cases audit, ERAP Program audit exemption, taxable year 1998 BIR audit, and Specially Monitored Industries BIR audit.

Who Is Affected by the 1999 Audit Program

The Order identified two broad audit categories: regular audit of large taxpayers and policy cases. For regular audit of large taxpayers, the covered taxpayers were the top 500 large taxpayers and banks, insurance companies, and stock brokers classified as “Specially Monitored Industries.” These are businesses expected to have significant tax exposure, extensive transactions, and complex compliance obligations.

The second category consisted of policy cases. These included chemical and chemical products, food and beverage, and follow-up audit on selected conglomerates. The inclusion of these sectors means the BIR was not merely reviewing individual taxpayers in isolation. It was also using audits to examine industry practices, develop procedures, and promote uniform audit treatment across similarly situated taxpayers.

For corporations in the listed industries, RMO No. 64-99 matters because it signaled that the BIR could look beyond one taxpayer’s return and compare treatment across an industry. In practical terms, companies in chemicals, food and beverage, and conglomerate structures needed consistent documentation, defensible tax positions, and clear explanations for income reporting, VAT treatment, withholding tax compliance, percentage tax exposure, and other tax liabilities.

Taxes and Liabilities Covered

The audit program covered Income Tax, Value-Added Tax, Percentage Tax, Withholding Tax, and other tax returns and liabilities for taxable year 1998. This scope is broad. It is not confined to income tax deficiency assessments. It includes transaction taxes, withholding obligations, and other tax liabilities that may arise from the taxpayer’s filed returns or from the taxpayer’s failure to file or correctly remit taxes.

For large taxpayers, this meant the BIR could examine income recognition, deductibility of expenses, VAT output and input tax reporting, percentage tax liabilities where applicable, withholding tax remittances, and related return positions. For banks, insurance companies, and stock brokers, the risk was heightened because they were expressly named as “Specially Monitored Industries.” For policy-case industries, the BIR’s concern included industry-wide audit procedures and standards, not only taxpayer-specific issues.

ERAP Program Participants: Audit Exclusion but Not Complete Immunity

One of the most important limitations in RMO No. 64-99 concerns taxpayers that availed of the ERAP Program under Revenue Regulations No. 2-99 and Revenue Memorandum Order No. 10-98. The Order states that covered taxpayers who availed of the ERAP Program will not be audited, except with respect to tax liabilities not covered by the ERAP return, such as Withholding Taxes and Documentary Stamp Taxes.

This distinction is critical. A taxpayer’s participation in the ERAP Program may remove certain covered liabilities from audit, but it does not automatically protect the taxpayer from audit on matters outside the ERAP return. In particular, withholding taxes and documentary stamp taxes remained audit-sensitive examples under the Order. Businesses that relied on ERAP Program participation still needed to confirm which taxes were actually covered and which liabilities remained open to examination.

For CFOs and accountants, the practical question is not simply whether the company joined the ERAP Program. The better question is: Which specific tax liabilities were covered by the ERAP return, and which liabilities, such as withholding tax or documentary stamp tax, remained outside that coverage?

Key Deadlines and Audit Period Covered

RMO No. 64-99 was issued on August 13, 1999. The audit program covered taxable year 1998. The Order further provides that taxable year 1998 includes all corporations with fiscal years ending on or before June 30, 1999. This date is the key cut-off for fiscal-year corporations.

Accordingly, a corporation whose fiscal year ended on or before June 30, 1999 fell within the taxable year 1998 coverage for purposes of the audit program. This is a practical issue because corporate taxpayers often assume that a reference to taxable year 1998 refers only to calendar-year filings. RMO No. 64-99 expressly expanded the relevant coverage to include covered fiscal-year taxpayers up to the June 30, 1999 fiscal-year ending date.

Industry Audits and Coordinated BIR Action

RMO No. 64-99 also addressed audits undertaken to develop industry procedures, guidelines, and standards. The Order provides that such audits will be treated or audited as an industry rather than as individual taxpayers. A joint and coordinated audit will be undertaken to ensure uniformity of action.

This is highly relevant to companies in the policy-case sectors. A coordinated industry audit can result in more consistent BIR positions across taxpayers, but it can also increase the risk that one taxpayer’s practice will be tested against broader industry assumptions. Companies should therefore be prepared not only to explain their own tax treatment, but also to show why their method is legally and factually supportable even when compared with industry practice.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

RMO No. 64-99 does not prescribe a special penalty schedule, special surcharge rate, or separate interest rate. Its function is to prescribe the audit program, coverage, policies, guidelines, and standards. However, because the audit program covers Income Tax, VAT, Percentage Tax, Withholding Tax, and other tax returns and liabilities, any deficiency found during audit may expose the taxpayer to the applicable consequences under the tax laws then in force.

Taxpayers should therefore avoid treating the absence of a special penalty table in the Order as an absence of risk. The risk arises from the underlying tax liabilities being audited. In particular, withholding taxes and documentary stamp taxes remained expressly relevant for ERAP Program participants where those liabilities were not covered by the ERAP return.

Practical Steps for Taxpayers

Covered taxpayers should first determine whether they fall within the top 500 large taxpayers, banks, insurance companies, stock brokers classified as “Specially Monitored Industries,” chemical and chemical products, food and beverage, or selected conglomerates subject to follow-up audit. This classification determines whether the company was within the priority audit coverage of RMO No. 64-99.

Second, companies should identify the taxable year involved. For calendar-year corporations, the relevant year is taxable year 1998. For fiscal-year corporations, management should check whether the fiscal year ended on or before June 30, 1999. If so, the corporation falls within the express taxable-year coverage stated in the Order.

Third, companies that availed of the ERAP Program under Revenue Regulations No. 2-99 and Revenue Memorandum Order No. 10-98 should review the actual ERAP return and confirm which liabilities were covered. The company should separately review withholding tax and documentary stamp tax exposure because the Order expressly identifies these as examples of liabilities not covered by the ERAP return and therefore still open to audit.

Fourth, policy-case taxpayers should prepare for an industry-based approach. Documentation should be organized not only by return type, but also by recurring industry issues, revenue streams, tax treatments, exemptions or exclusions claimed, withholding practices, VAT treatment, and documentary support for material transactions.

Finally, large taxpayers should treat RMO No. 64-99 as a reminder that audit preparation is not limited to responding after receipt of a notice. The better approach is to conduct an internal tax compliance review, reconcile returns against books and supporting documents, identify exposure areas, and prepare a defensible audit file before issues are raised by the BIR.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMO No. 64-99 remains a useful reference point for understanding how the BIR structures audit programs involving large taxpayers, industry-focused reviews, and policy cases. For companies facing BIR audits, historical tax exposure, withholding tax issues, documentary stamp tax questions, VAT assessments, or industry-based audit concerns, the key is to respond with legal precision and complete documentation.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, business owners, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in BIR audit defense, tax compliance review, assessment response, protest strategy, documentation preparation, and settlement evaluation. For assistance with BIR audit exposure, large taxpayer compliance, or tax assessment defense in the Philippines, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *