RMO No. 27-99 updates BIR procedures for disposing unserviceable property through Disposal Committees, inspection, appraisal, and minimum selling price setting.
BIR offices disposing of unserviceable property must now use a formal Disposal Committee structure, including inspection and appraisal steps before disposal. For businesses, suppliers, bidders, and service providers dealing with government surplus assets, the key compliance point is practical: the minimum selling price for unserviceable BIR property must be supported by an appraisal made by the proper committee after inspecting the property’s actual physical and operational condition.
What Changed Under RMO No. 27-99
RMO No. 27-99, issued on March 29, 1999, updates the guidelines and procedures on the disposal of unserviceable property. The most important change is the establishment of a formal Disposal Committee mechanism for the National Office and Regional Offices. The order does not merely identify property for disposal; it creates the responsible body that must inspect the property, evaluate its condition, assess its marketability, and compute its appraised value for purposes of setting the minimum selling price.
This matters because the disposal of unserviceable property is not treated as a simple administrative clean-up. The process requires a documented evaluation by officials designated for that function. The order specifically requires the members of the Disposal Committee to conduct an inspection of the property to be disposed of so they can obtain a first-hand observation of its physical condition, operational condition, marketability, and ability to attract prospective buyers.
For accountants, administrative officers, procurement personnel, government asset managers, and companies interested in bidding on government-disposed property, the searchable phrases are: BIR disposal of unserviceable property, RMO 27-99 Disposal Committee, BIR minimum selling price appraisal, government unserviceable property Philippines, and BIR property disposal procedures.
Who Is Affected by RMO No. 27-99
The most directly affected offices are the BIR National Office and the BIR Regional Offices that handle property, supplies, equipment, vehicles, and other assets that may become unserviceable. The order identifies who sits in the Disposal Committee at both levels.
At the National Office, the Disposal Committee is composed of the Head Revenue Executive Assistant of the Financial and Administrative Service as Chairman, with the Chief of the General Services Division and the Chief of the Automotive and Equipment Maintenance Section of the General Services Division as members.
At the Regional Office level, the Disposal Committee is composed of the Assistant Regional Director as Chairman, with the Chief of the Administrative Division and the Chief of the Property and Supplies Section of the Administrative Division as members.
The order is also relevant to prospective buyers of unserviceable BIR property because the minimum selling price is not arbitrary. It must be based on an appraisal computed by the Disposal Committee, guided by pertinent rules promulgated by fiscal authorities. This affects bidders who may wish to evaluate whether the minimum selling price reflects the item’s marketability and actual operating condition.
Key Compliance Requirements and Procedures
The compliance structure under RMO No. 27-99 has three concrete parts. First, the proper Disposal Committee must be constituted depending on whether the property is under the National Office or a Regional Office. Second, the committee members must inspect the property proposed for disposal. Third, the committee must compute the appraised value of the property to set the minimum selling price.
The inspection requirement is specific. The members must obtain a first-hand observation of the property. The order identifies the matters to be observed: the physical condition of the property, the operational condition of the property, its marketability, and its ability to attract prospective buyers. These are practical criteria. A property that is physically damaged, non-operational, difficult to sell, or unattractive to prospective buyers may require a different appraisal outcome from property that is still marketable despite being unserviceable for the BIR’s purposes.
The appraisal requirement is also specific. The Disposal Committee computes the appraised value of the property for the purpose of setting the minimum selling price. The order does not state a fixed formula, percentage, rate, or depreciation table. Instead, it states that the committee must be guided in the appraisal of unserviceable property by pertinent rules promulgated by fiscal authorities. Accordingly, businesses and bidders should not assume that every item will be valued using a single flat rate or discount. The process depends on inspection, marketability, operational condition, and applicable fiscal rules.
Effective Date and Deadlines
The issuance date stated for RMO No. 27-99 is March 29, 1999. The available text does not state a separate effectivity date, transition period, filing deadline, taxpayer submission deadline, or compliance cut-off date. It also does not impose a tax return filing obligation, withholding obligation, payment deadline, registration requirement, or documentary submission requirement on private taxpayers.
The practical deadline is therefore procedural rather than tax-payment based. Before unserviceable BIR property is disposed of, the proper Disposal Committee should already have inspected the property and computed the appraised value that will serve as the basis for the minimum selling price.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
RMO No. 27-99, based on the stated text, does not specify penalties, surcharges, interest, fines, or criminal consequences for non-compliance. It also does not prescribe taxpayer penalties because the subject is the internal disposal procedure for unserviceable property.
That said, the absence of a stated penalty does not make the procedure optional for the offices covered by the order. The order identifies the committee composition and the functions required before disposal. For government offices, failure to follow the proper disposal process may create audit, administrative, valuation, or accountability issues, particularly if property is sold below a properly supported minimum selling price or without adequate inspection.
Practical Steps for Businesses, Bidders, and Administrative Officers
Businesses interested in acquiring unserviceable BIR property should check whether the minimum selling price was based on an appraisal by the proper Disposal Committee. They should also evaluate whether the property’s physical and operational condition matches the valuation assumptions. Because the order requires assessment of marketability and ability to attract prospective buyers, bidders should prepare their own commercial review of the asset before relying on the minimum selling price as a full measure of value.
Administrative officers handling government property should ensure that the proper committee is constituted before disposal activities proceed. For the National Office, the chairman and members must correspond to the Financial and Administrative Service, General Services Division, and Automotive and Equipment Maintenance Section positions identified in the order. For Regional Offices, the chairman and members must correspond to the Assistant Regional Director, Administrative Division, and Property and Supplies Section positions identified in the order.
Internal documentation should reflect the inspection findings. At minimum, the record should show the property inspected, the physical condition observed, the operational condition observed, the assessment of marketability, the expected ability to attract prospective buyers, the appraised value computed, and the minimum selling price derived from that appraisal. These are the facts that matter under RMO No. 27-99.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMO No. 27-99 is a reminder that BIR issuances are not limited to tax rates and return deadlines. They also regulate government procedures that affect procurement, disposal, valuation, audit risk, and transactions with private parties. For businesses dealing with government assets, participating in public disposals, or reviewing BIR and government-property compliance issues, the valuation and documentation trail can be as important as the purchase price.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, property owners, suppliers, bidders, and corporate officers on BIR compliance, tax risk, government transactions, documentation, and dispute prevention. For assistance with BIR issuances, tax compliance, government procurement and disposal concerns, or related business law issues, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.