Credit cooperatives need not withhold 20% final tax on members’ deposit interest, confirming preferential tax treatment for cooperative member transactions.

Credit cooperatives are not required to withhold 20% final tax on interest earned by their members from savings and time deposits maintained with the cooperative. For cooperative members, the ruling confirms a powerful tax protection: member transactions with a duly registered cooperative must be read through the State’s constitutional policy of promoting cooperatives, not merely through the general language of passive income taxation.

Why This Case Matters to Cooperatives and Their Members

The dispute arose from a common tax question facing credit cooperatives: when a cooperative accepts savings and time deposits from its own members, must it treat the interest on those deposits like ordinary bank deposit interest and withhold 20% final tax?

Dumaguete Cathedral Credit Cooperative, a credit cooperative registered with and regulated by the Cooperative Development Authority, was assessed deficiency withholding taxes for taxable years 1999 and 2000. The assessments included taxes on interest paid to members on their savings and time deposits. The cooperative accepted liability for certain withholding taxes on items such as honoraria, per diems, security and janitorial services, commissions, and professional fees, but contested the assessment relating to interest on members’ deposits.

The Court of Tax Appeals agreed with the Commissioner of Internal Revenue and held that the cooperative should have withheld the 20% final tax. The CTA treated the cooperative’s deposit arrangements as falling within the phrase


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *