Directors may be personally liable for bad-faith illegal dismissal when board action violates labor due process and exceeds lawful corporate authority.
Corporate directors cannot hide behind the corporation when they use board resolutions to remove an employee in bad faith, without lawful cause, and without due process. When directors act beyond lawful authority, especially to retaliate against an officer attempting to address financial irregularities, they may be held personally and solidarily liable for the employeeâs monetary awards, and the corporation may recover from them whatever it is forced to pay.
Why This Case Matters to Employers, Directors, and Employees
The ruling is important because it clarifies a practical question that often arises in labor disputes: when an employee is illegally dismissed by a corporation, are only corporate funds answerable, or can the individual directors who caused the dismissal be made personally liable? The Court answered that directors and officers are generally protected when they act in good faith, within the lawful scope of their authority, and for the corporation. But that protection disappears when they willfully approve unlawful acts, act in gross negligence or bad faith, or use corporate power to violate legal rights.
For employees, this means that an illegal dismissal case may not always be limited to the corporate employerâs assets. For board members, cooperative directors, and company officers, the case is a warning that the corporate veil is not a shield for retaliatory, lawless, or bad-faith employment decisions.
Background: A General Manager Tried to Address Audit Findings
Peter Cosalan was the General Manager of Benguet Electric Cooperative, Inc., or Beneco. After Commission on Audit memoranda and a later audit report flagged financial irregularities, cash advance issues, and possible mismanagement, Cosalan began implementing remedial measures recommended by the audit authorities. The case, Benguet Electric Cooperative, Inc. v. National Labor Relations Commission (G.R. No. 89070), arose after the Beneco Board responded by passing resolutions that reduced or removed Cosalanâs benefits, stripped him of certain authority, suspended him, withheld his compensation, and eventually caused his ouster as General Manager.
Cosalan filed a labor complaint challenging the legality of the suspension and termination and seeking payment of salaries and allowances. The Labor Arbiter ruled in his favor, ordered his reinstatement, awarded backwages and allowances, and held Beneco and the individual board members jointly and severally liable. The NLRC later modified the ruling by placing liability only on Beneco and releasing the individual board members from personal liability. Beneco, under a new set of directors, then questioned that modification before the Supreme Court.
The Courtâs Ruling: Bad Faith Takes Directors Outside Corporate Protection
The Court reinstated the Labor Arbiterâs decision in full. It held that the board membersâ appeal to the NLRC should not have been entertained because it was filed out of time. The Court emphasized that the ten-day period to appeal in labor cases was mandatory and jurisdictional. The board members could not treat delivery to a private letter carrier as the equivalent of timely filing; where pleadings are sent through a private carrier rather than the Philippine Post Office, the filing date is the date of actual receipt by the tribunal.
Even apart from the late appeal, the Court found that the appeal lacked merit. Cosalanâs suspension had continued beyond the maximum lawful period for preventive suspension. He was not informed of the charges against him. He was not given an opportunity to answer. No lawful cause for suspension or dismissal was shown. The required National Electrification Administration approval was also not obtained. In the Courtâs view, Cosalan was denied both procedural due process and substantive due process.
The Doctrine: The Bad-Faith Director Liability Rule
The central doctrine may be stated this way: directors, trustees, and officers are generally not personally liable for corporate acts done in good faith and within lawful authority, but they become personally liable when they vote for patently unlawful acts, act with gross negligence or bad faith, or direct corporate affairs in a manner that violates the law and the rights of others.
The Court applied Section 31 of the Corporation Code, which imposes joint and several liability on directors or trustees who knowingly assent to unlawful corporate acts or who are guilty of gross negligence or bad faith in directing corporate affairs. Importantly, the Court held that this rule applied to Beneco and similarly situated electric cooperatives because the Corporation Code applies suppletorily to corporations with special charters, so long as its provisions are not inconsistent with the special law. Electric cooperatives under the governing decree were treated as corporate entities for this purpose.
Why the Board Members Were Personally Liable
The Court saw more than a mistaken employment decision. It found strong indications that the board members acted against Cosalan because he was trying to address the financial irregularities and regulatory violations identified in the COA audit findings. The board first removed benefits and authority connected with his office, then suspended and dismissed him without lawful cause and without due process. The Court characterized the dismissal of an officer or employee in bad faith, without lawful cause, and without procedural due process as an act contrary to law.
That mattered because corporate authority does not include the authority to violate express legal mandates or destroy the legal rights of employees. A board resolution does not sanitize an unlawful dismissal. Directors cannot make an illegal act lawful merely by passing it in corporate form.
Corporate Liability and Reimbursement from Directors
The Court held that Beneco and the individual board members were properly solidarily liable for the awards made by the Labor Arbiter. But the ruling went further. Because the unlawful acts were personal and individual acts of the board members, done in bad faith and beyond lawful authority, Beneco had the right to be reimbursed for any amounts it might be compelled to pay Cosalan.
This part of the ruling is especially significant for corporations, cooperatives, associations, and their members. Innocent members or shareholders should not ultimately bear the cost of directorsâ bad-faith acts. Where the liability arises from directorsâ unlawful and ultra vires conduct, the corporation may have recourse against those directors.
Practical Impact for Philippine Labor and Corporate Disputes
For employers, the ruling reinforces the need to document lawful cause, observe due process, and ensure that board or management action stays within legal authority. Preventive suspension must not be used as an indefinite punishment. Termination cannot be imposed first and justified later. If approvals from regulators, parent entities, or governing instruments are required, those approvals must be secured.
For directors and officers, the lesson is direct: personal liability is a real risk when employment decisions are made in bad faith, in retaliation, or in disregard of mandatory procedure. The fact that an act was embodied in a board resolution does not automatically make it a protected corporate act.
For employees, especially managers, executives, and officers removed after raising compliance concerns, audit issues, financial irregularities, or regulatory violations, the ruling provides a framework for arguing that responsible directors should be held personally liable, not merely the corporate employer.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employers, directors, cooperatives, executives, and employees in labor disputes involving illegal dismissal, preventive suspension, board liability, and corporate governance issues. If your company is facing an NLRC case, if you are a director concerned about personal exposure, or if you were removed after raising compliance or audit concerns, our litigation and labor law team can help assess your remedies, defenses, and litigation strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our lawyers in Makati City.