A corporation may be bound by its president’s contract despite no board approval if it allowed apparent authority and accepted the benefits.
A corporation cannot easily escape a contract merely by saying its president lacked written board authority, especially when the company allowed the president to act for it, accepted the benefits of the transaction, and later behaved as if the agreement was valid. For businesses, consultants, suppliers, and service providers, the lesson is practical and important: corporate authority is not judged only by a board resolution. It may also arise from the corporation’s conduct, past practice, and ratification.
Why This Case Matters to Businesses and Service Providers
Many commercial disputes begin with a familiar defense: the company received the service or benefit, but later refuses full payment because the officer who signed the agreement allegedly had no authority. This ruling warns corporations that courts will look beyond formal paperwork when the facts show that the corporation knowingly allowed its officer to deal with third parties and later accepted the transaction’s benefits.
For consultants, contractors, suppliers, brokers, and professional service providers, the case is equally significant. It recognizes that third parties dealing in good faith with a corporate president are not automatically defeated by an internal corporate defect, particularly where the president’s position, conduct, and the corporation’s own acts reasonably created the appearance of authority.
Background: A Warehousing Company, a Consultant, and a Disputed Contract
People’s Aircargo and Warehousing Co. Inc. was a domestic corporation organized to operate a customs bonded warehouse at the Manila International Airport in Pasay City. To obtain the necessary license from the Bureau of Customs, its president, Antonio Punsalan Jr., dealt with consultant Stefani Sao for professional engineering and consultancy services.
Sao first submitted a letter-proposal for a feasibility study, which Punsalan accepted. Although a major stockholder objected and a different company later submitted a lower proposal, People’s Aircargo paid Sao and used his feasibility study in connection with its license application. Later, Sao sent another proposal covering an operations manual and a seminar-workshop for employees. The letter bore the conformity of Punsalan as president.
The company later disputed the second proposal. It argued that the contract was unenforceable because Punsalan had no board authority to bind the corporation. It also argued, in the alternative, that the first contract had been simulated or tainted with circumstances suggesting irregularity. The dispute reached the Supreme Court in People’s Aircargo and Warehousing Co. Inc. v. Court of Appeals (G.R. No. 117847, October 7, 1998).
The Supreme Court’s Ruling: Corporate Conduct Can Create Binding Authority
The Supreme Court denied the petition and affirmed the corporation’s liability. The Court held that although a corporation generally acts through its board of directors, corporate officers or agents may bind the corporation when they are authorized by law, by corporate bylaws, by board action, or by the corporation’s own conduct.
The Court emphasized that apparent authority is not created by the officer’s title alone. It arises when the corporation knowingly permits its officer or agent to act within the scope of an apparent authority, or holds the officer out to the public as possessing such authority. A third person dealing with the officer may rely on that appearance when the corporation’s own acts made the reliance reasonable.
In this case, Punsalan was not merely an ordinary employee. He was the president of the corporation. More importantly, the company had previously allowed him to enter into the first contract with Sao without specific board approval. That first contract was performed, paid, and used for the company’s business purpose. The company’s own vice president even recognized that Punsalan could eventually cause the company to pay Sao because, as president, he often got his way.
Ratification: Accepting the Benefit Can Cure the Lack of Prior Authority
The ruling is especially important because the Court treated the corporation’s later conduct as ratification. Even assuming that Punsalan lacked prior express authority, People’s Aircargo accepted the benefits of the consultant’s work. Sao prepared the operations manual and conducted the seminar for the company’s employees. The corporation accepted those services and used them in relation to its bonded warehouse operations.
Under civil law principles, a contract entered into without authority may be ratified. Once ratified, the corporation cannot treat the contract as void or unenforceable merely because formal authority was missing at the beginning. Ratification may be shown not only by express approval but also by conduct, such as accepting benefits, failing to object in a timely manner, allowing performance to proceed, or using the work delivered.
This is the core doctrine of the case: when a corporation allows its president to appear authorized, accepts the benefits of the transaction, and acts consistently with the contract’s existence, it may be bound despite the absence of a prior board resolution.
The Court Rejected the Claim That the First Contract Was Simulated
The company also tried to reduce its liability by arguing that the first contract was simulated or unenforceable. It pointed to alleged signs of fraud, including the manner of payment, the delay in filing the collection suit, and the fact that the same consultant remained connected with the company in some capacity even after the disputed transaction.
The Supreme Court was not persuaded. It agreed with the appellate court that these circumstances did not establish simulation. A fictitious or simulated contract requires proof that the parties did not intend to be bound at all. The Court found that the first contract had been performed: Sao prepared the feasibility study, the company used it, and the company paid for it. Those facts were inconsistent with a purely simulated transaction.
Practical Impact: Board Resolutions Still Matter, But Conduct Matters Too
For corporations, this ruling is a compliance warning. If a company wants to limit who may sign contracts, those limits must be clear, consistently enforced, and communicated in practice. A corporation that allows its president or senior officers to transact freely, then accepts the resulting benefits, may later be prevented from denying the officer’s authority.
For businesses dealing with corporations, the ruling provides protection but not a license for carelessness. Service providers should still request secretary’s certificates, board resolutions, written authority, purchase orders, or other documents confirming the signatory’s power. However, where the corporation’s own pattern of conduct reasonably shows that the officer has authority, and the corporation accepts the work or benefit, the service provider may have a strong claim for payment.
The case is also useful in collection suits. A defendant corporation cannot rely solely on an internal lack of approval if the plaintiff can show apparent authority, prior similar transactions, acceptance of benefits, or subsequent ratification. The evidence should focus on what the corporation permitted, what it received, what it used, and how it acted after performance.
What This Means for Contract Drafting and Corporate Litigation
Companies should maintain signing authority policies, require board approvals for material contracts, and avoid accepting performance under disputed agreements unless the company is prepared to treat the contract as binding. Silence, acceptance, or use of delivered work can become powerful evidence of ratification.
On the other hand, consultants and contractors should preserve signed proposals, delivery records, email confirmations, receipts, meeting notes, and proof that the company used the deliverables. In litigation, these documents may establish both apparent authority and ratification, even where the company later argues that the signatory lacked internal authorization.
Need Help With Corporate Contract Disputes?
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, business owners, suppliers, consultants, and service providers in contract enforcement, collection cases, corporate authority disputes, and litigation involving unauthorized or disputed corporate transactions. If your company is facing a payment dispute, or if another party is denying a contract after accepting its benefits, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our litigation and corporate law team.