Corporate land sales require authority from the owning corporation’s board; brokers, affiliates, or parent-company representatives cannot bind the owner by appearance alone.

Buyers of corporate land cannot force a sale merely because a broker, executive, parent-company representative, or related company appeared to negotiate on the corporation’s behalf. When the asset belongs to a corporation, authority to sell must be traced to the corporation’s own board or to a duly authorized agent; otherwise, the supposed deal may fail even after negotiations, counteroffers, deposits, and months of apparent progress.

Why This Case Matters to Buyers, Brokers, and Corporate Sellers

Real estate transactions involving corporations often move through layers of representatives: brokers, general managers, parent companies, foreign affiliates, regional officers, and lawyers preparing documents. For a buyer, those outward signs can look like a binding deal. For a corporation, however, the law treats corporate property differently from personal property. A corporation acts through its board of directors, and the disposition of corporate assets cannot be assumed simply because someone connected to the corporation spoke or negotiated.

The dispute in Litonjua v. Eternit arose from negotiations for the sale of several parcels of land and improvements owned by Eternit Corporation, later Eterton Multi-Resources Corporation (G.R. No. 144805). Eduardo and Antonio Litonjua alleged that they accepted an offer to buy the properties for US$1,000,000.00, deposited the peso equivalent with an escrow agent, and relied on representations made through individuals connected with Eternit and its foreign parent or affiliate. When the sale did not push through, the buyers sued for specific performance and damages.

The Court’s Core Holding: Apparent Authority Is Not Enough for Corporate Land

The Supreme Court refused to compel the sale. It held that the buyers failed to prove that the persons who negotiated with them had authority from Eternit Corporation itself to sell the subject properties. The Court emphasized that a corporation has a legal personality separate and distinct from its shareholders, parent company, officers, and affiliates. Even if a parent or controlling shareholder owns a majority of the corporation’s shares, that ownership does not make the parent the owner of the subsidiary’s assets.

That principle was decisive. The properties belonged to Eternit Corporation. Therefore, the authority to sell had to come from Eternit’s own board of directors or from someone duly authorized by that board. The Court found no board resolution, written authority, or corporate act showing that the relevant persons were empowered to bind Eternit to the sale. Without that authority, there was no perfected contract of sale enforceable against the corporation.

Corporate Separateness Protects Corporate Assets

The ruling is a strong reminder that shares and assets are not the same thing. A shareholder may own shares in a corporation, but the corporation owns its own property. A parent company may control a subsidiary, appoint directors, or influence business decisions, but it does not automatically acquire the legal power to sell the subsidiary’s land. The board of the corporation that owns the property remains the controlling body for corporate acts.

This matters in acquisitions, asset sales, property purchases, joint ventures, and intra-group restructuring. A buyer dealing with a corporate group should not assume that an affiliate, foreign headquarters, or controlling shareholder can dispose of local corporate assets. The proper question is not merely who controls the group in a practical sense, but whether the selling corporation itself validly authorized the transaction.

When a Broker Negotiates, the Authority to Find a Buyer Is Not the Authority to Sell

The Court also drew an important distinction for real estate brokers. A broker is generally engaged to find a buyer willing to purchase on terms acceptable to the owner. That is not the same as being authorized to sign, approve, or bind the owner to a contract of sale. The Court held that the authority to sell real property does not include the authority merely to negotiate or locate prospective purchasers.

For buyers, this distinction can be costly. A broker’s statements, a counteroffer, a draft escrow agreement, or the preparation of closing documents may show negotiation, but they do not necessarily prove that the corporate owner has agreed to sell. Specific performance requires proof of a clear, certain, and enforceable contract. Where the alleged contract was made through an agent, the agent’s authority must be established by competent evidence.

Agency by Estoppel Requires Reliance on the Principal’s Conduct

The buyers also argued, in substance, that Eternit should be bound because its representatives appeared to have authority. The Court rejected that argument. For agency by estoppel to exist, the principal must have made representations or knowingly allowed the supposed agent to appear authorized, and the third party must have relied on those representations to his prejudice. Estoppel cannot rest on the agent’s own statements alone.

The Court found that the petitioners failed to prove the required representations from Eternit itself. The records did not show that Eternit’s board ratified the negotiations or formally approved the sale. Nor did the later conduct of the parties amount to ratification. The Court therefore held that the corporation was not bound by the alleged acts of persons who lacked proven authority to sell its property.

Practical Lessons for Corporate Property Transactions

For buyers, the practical lesson is due diligence. Before paying deposits, accepting a counteroffer, or preparing closing documents, a buyer should require a board resolution or secretary’s certificate specifically authorizing the sale, identifying the property, naming the authorized signatory, and approving the material terms. If the seller is part of a corporate group, the authority must come from the corporation that owns the asset, not merely from a parent company or affiliate.

For corporations, the case underscores the need for disciplined transaction documentation. If management does not intend to authorize a sale, communications with brokers and prospective buyers should be carefully worded. If the corporation does intend to sell, the board authority should be clear, written, and complete. Ambiguous negotiations invite litigation, but ambiguity will not necessarily create a binding sale where corporate authority is legally absent.

For brokers and intermediaries, the ruling warns against overstating authority. A broker may facilitate, introduce, negotiate, and transmit offers, but unless expressly authorized in the legally required form, the broker cannot bind the owner to sell corporate real property. The safer practice is to disclose the limited nature of the mandate and ensure that final approval remains subject to the seller’s board.

What This Means for Litigation Strategy

A party suing for specific performance of a corporate asset sale must prove more than commercial expectation. It must prove a perfected contract and the authority of the person who supposedly bound the corporation. The absence of a board resolution, written authority, or ratifying corporate act can defeat the claim even if the buyer believed the negotiations were already final.

On the defense side, a corporation resisting enforcement should focus on corporate ownership, board authority, agency limits, and the absence of ratification. This case provides a framework for showing that negotiations did not mature into an enforceable sale because the alleged representatives lacked authority to bind the corporation.

Legal Help for Corporate Property Disputes and Failed Transactions

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises clients on corporate property sales, failed asset transactions, broker disputes, specific performance cases, and litigation involving corporate authority. If you are buying corporate land, defending against a claimed sale, or assessing whether a transaction was validly authorized, our Makati-based litigation and corporate lawyers can help review the documents, identify the controlling authority issues, and plan the next legal step. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *