Public hospital properties used for public service are exempt from local real property tax levy, though private beneficial users may still be taxed.

Government hospitals and similar public instrumentalities may resist local real property tax assessments, levies, and auction sales when the property is held for public service; even where private lessees may owe tax for their beneficial use, the local government cannot simply sell the government hospital’s land to collect it.

Why This Real Property Tax Ruling Matters

For public hospitals, government instrumentalities, and private parties leasing space from them, the Philippine Heart Center ruling draws an important line. Local governments may tax real property only within the limits set by Congress. When the property belongs to the Republic or to a government instrumentality performing public functions, the Local Government Code protects it from ordinary real property tax collection measures such as levy and auction sale.

The case is especially important because the dispute did not involve a minor billing issue. Quezon City had assessed millions in real property taxes against the Philippine Heart Center, levied on eleven properties, and eventually bought those properties at public auction as the lone bidder. If that course of action had been sustained, a local government would have effectively acquired properties used by a national public health institution because of alleged local tax delinquency.

Background: Quezon City Assessed and Sold Philippine Heart Center Properties

The Philippine Heart Center was created as a specialty hospital to provide expert cardiovascular care to the public, especially the poor and less fortunate. Its charter authorized it to acquire property, enter into contracts, lease or dispose of property, and operate with corporate powers. The national government also provided the initial land, buildings, equipment, and facilities needed for its establishment.

Quezon City issued notices of delinquency for unpaid real property taxes on eleven Philippine Heart Center properties. The City later levied on the properties and, after publication, sold them at public auction, with the City itself as the lone bidder. The Philippine Heart Center challenged the assessment, levy, and sale, invoking its status as a government instrumentality, its public health mandate, and the tax exemptions recognized under the Local Government Code and related jurisprudence (G.R. No. 225409, March 11, 2020).

The Doctrine: Public Dominion Shields Government Health Facilities From Local Confiscation

The Court treated the Philippine Heart Center as a government instrumentality vested with corporate powers. That classification matters. An entity may possess corporate powers, sue and be sued, contract, lease property, and manage its own operations without becoming an ordinary taxable private corporation. If it performs governmental functions and enjoys operational autonomy under a public charter, it may remain part of the national government machinery.

The Heart Center’s functions were found to be predominantly governmental, not commercial. It was established to operate a specialty hospital, promote cardiovascular research, train medical personnel, assist health institutions, and extend medical and cardiological services to the public, especially those less fortunate in life. Those functions placed its properties within the concept of property of public dominion: property intended for public use or public service.

That conclusion was decisive. Properties of public dominion are outside the ordinary commerce of man. They cannot be treated as assets available for levy, foreclosure, encumbrance, or auction sale in the same manner as private property. The reason is practical as much as legal: essential public services could be impaired if local governments could confiscate national government facilities used for public health, transportation, ports, water systems, or similar public functions.

The Beneficial Use Exception Still Matters

The decision does not mean that every commercial use inside a government hospital is automatically tax-free. The Local Government Code exempts real property owned by the Republic, but it also recognizes an exception when beneficial use has been granted, for consideration or otherwise, to a taxable person.

Quezon City argued that some Philippine Heart Center properties were leased to commercial establishments, including private businesses. On that point, the Court acknowledged the general rule: portions of government property leased to taxable private entities may lose the real property tax exemption as to the beneficial use granted to those private entities.

But that did not save Quezon City’s assessment and sale. The local government had to do more than merely allege that portions of the property were leased to private parties. It had to identify the specific properties or portions leased, identify the lessees, state the lease periods, and show that assessments were validly served on the taxable persons with actual and beneficial use. Bare allegations were not enough.

Why the Levy and Auction Sale Were Void

The most consequential part of the ruling is the separation between taxability of a private lessee’s beneficial use and the drastic remedy of selling the government property itself. Even if a private lessee may be liable for real property tax on the beneficial use of a portion of the property, the proper remedy is not to levy and sell the public hospital’s land.

The Court explained that the taxable person with beneficial use is the party responsible for the tax. Collection should therefore be directed against that taxable person through an action in personam. The government instrumentality’s property does not lose its protection from levy merely because some private party may have used a portion of it under a lease or similar arrangement.

In practical terms, local treasurers and assessors must be careful. They cannot use a generalized claim of commercial leasing as a shortcut to auction off public dominion property. They must identify the taxable beneficial user and pursue the correct remedy against the correct party.

Procedural Lesson: Certiorari Can Challenge Grave Abuse in Local Tax Enforcement

The case also addressed the remedy used by the Philippine Heart Center. The Court held that certiorari could be used to challenge the assessment, levy, and sale where the local government allegedly acted with grave abuse of discretion. This was so even though tax assessment and collection acts are not, in the ordinary sense, judicial or quasi-judicial functions.

That holding matters for taxpayers facing extraordinary local tax enforcement. Where a local government’s act is alleged to be patently beyond its authority, and where the issue involves grave abuse affecting public property or fundamental legal limits on local taxation, courts may exercise the expanded power of judicial review.

Practical Impact for Hospitals, LGUs, and Private Lessees

For government hospitals and public instrumentalities, this decision provides a strong defense against local real property tax assessments that ignore public ownership, public use, and the statutory exemption for Republic-owned property. It also confirms that corporate powers do not automatically transform a public instrumentality into an ordinary taxable corporation.

For local governments, the ruling is a warning that real property tax enforcement must be precise. If the claim is based on private beneficial use, the assessment must be directed to the proper taxable person and supported by proof of the specific leased area, lease period, beneficial user, and valid service of assessment. A blanket assessment against the government instrumentality risks being void.

For private businesses leasing spaces in public hospitals, ports, transport facilities, water systems, and other government properties, the ruling is equally relevant. The public owner may be exempt, but the private beneficial user may still face real property tax exposure. Lease agreements with government entities should therefore address who bears real property tax risk, how assessments will be handled, and what documents must be maintained to support or contest an assessment.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises property owners, government contractors, lessees, hospitals, and businesses dealing with local tax assessments, warrants of levy, auction sales, and disputes with city or municipal treasurers and assessors. If your company received a real property tax assessment, notice of delinquency, warrant of levy, or auction sale notice, early legal review is critical because local tax remedies are deadline-sensitive and highly technical.

For assistance in contesting local real property tax assessments, structuring leases involving government property, or challenging void levy and auction proceedings, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *