A corporation lacking board consent may avoid contract liability, but it cannot keep money received without legal basis; refund, interest, and damages may follow.

A company cannot avoid refund liability by saying it never approved a transaction, while also keeping money paid because of that same transaction. When corporate consent is absent, the supposed contract may fail; but if the corporation received and retained money without a valid legal basis, the law on unjust enrichment and estoppel may require it to return the amount, with interest, damages, attorney’s fees, and costs.

Why This Ruling Matters to Businesses and Investors

The ruling is important for business owners, investors, brokers, and companies that handle large settlement payments. It draws a sharp distinction between two questions that are often confused in commercial disputes: whether a corporation was validly bound by a contract, and whether it may keep money it received under circumstances that later proved legally defective.

For ordinary clients, the practical lesson is direct. A corporation may successfully argue that it was never a party to an agreement because there was no board resolution. But that argument does not automatically allow it to retain payments made in reliance on the transaction. If the company benefited from the money at another party’s expense, and there is no just or legal ground for keeping it, the paying party may sue for refund based on unjust enrichment.

Background: A Failed Trading Seat Transaction

The dispute arose from a proposed acquisition of majority equity in Trendline Securities, Inc.’s membership seat in the Philippine Stock Exchange. The Litonjua Group agreed with Trendline that it would acquire 85% of the value of the membership seat. As part of the arrangement, the Litonjua Group would pay PSE directly to settle Trendline’s outstanding obligations so that Trendline’s suspension could be lifted and the seat could resume normal trading operations.

PSE, through its Business Conduct and Ethics Committee, advised Trendline that P19,000,000.00 would be accepted as full and final settlement of Trendline’s outstanding obligations if paid by the stated deadline. The Litonjua Group then delivered three checks totaling P19,000,000.00 payable to PSE. PSE received the checks, and the receipt indicated that the payment was an advance payment for full settlement of Trendline’s outstanding obligation. The case later reached the Supreme Court in Philippine Stock Exchange, Inc. v. Litonjua (G.R. No. 204014, December 5, 2016).

The problem was that PSE never lifted the suspension or completed the contemplated transfer. When it became clear that specific performance of the transaction would no longer be possible, the Litonjua Group demanded reimbursement. PSE refused, arguing that it was not a party to the letter-agreement between Trendline and the Litonjua Group, and that the payment should be treated as Trendline’s settlement of its own obligation.

The Supreme Court’s Core Holding: No Board Consent, But No Right to Keep the Money

The Supreme Court agreed with PSE on one point: PSE was not a party to the letter-agreement. Under corporate law, a corporation acts through its board of directors. As a general rule, in the absence of authority from the board, no person, not even corporate officers, can validly bind the corporation. Since no PSE board resolution authorized PSE to be bound by the letter-agreement or to assume the obligations stated in it, there was no corporate consent to make PSE a contracting party.

That finding, however, did not end the case. The Court held that PSE could not use the absence of corporate consent as both a shield and a sword. It could not deny being bound by the transaction, yet keep the P19,000,000.00 paid in connection with that same transaction. Because PSE had no valid basis to retain the money after disavowing the agreement, the Court required PSE to return the amount to the Litonjua Group.

The Unjust Enrichment Rule in Commercial Payments

The controlling doctrine is unjust enrichment. Article 22 of the Civil Code provides that every person who, through an act of performance by another or by any other means, acquires or comes into possession of something at the expense of the latter without just or legal ground must return it.

The Court explained that unjust enrichment requires two conditions: first, that a person is benefited without a valid basis or justification; and second, that the benefit is derived at another’s expense. Both were present. PSE received and benefited from the P19,000,000.00 paid by the Litonjua Group. But once PSE insisted that it was not a party to the transaction and had never consented to the obligations contemplated in the letter-agreement, it lost the legal basis for retaining the payment as against the Litonjua Group.

This point is particularly relevant in business and tax-adjacent disputes involving refunds, advances, settlements, escrow-like payments, and third-party payments of corporate obligations. The law does not permit a party to retain funds simply because money has already changed hands. The recipient must still show a valid legal ground for keeping the benefit.

Estoppel: A Company Cannot Take Inconsistent Positions to Another’s Prejudice

The Court also applied estoppel. PSE’s actions led the Litonjua Group to believe that payment of P19,000,000.00 would settle Trendline’s obligations and enable the lifting of the suspension over the seat or membership. PSE had communicated a full and final settlement amount, received the checks, and issued a receipt reflecting the settlement purpose of the payment.

Because of those acts, PSE became an active participant in the transaction. It could not later say that it was a complete stranger to the arrangement while simultaneously claiming the right to retain the funds. The Court stated, in substance, that PSE had to choose a consistent position: either treat itself as a party to the agreement and assume the corresponding obligations, or disavow consent and return the money.

Why the Court Awarded Exemplary Damages

The Supreme Court affirmed the award of exemplary damages. In contracts and quasi-contracts, exemplary damages may be awarded when the defendant acted in a wanton, fraudulent, reckless, oppressive, or malevolent manner. The Court found no reason to disturb the lower courts’ conclusion that PSE’s continued refusal to return the money, despite having no legal right to keep it, justified exemplary damages.

The Court noted that the amount involved was substantial. PSE should have been more careful in its dealings with the Litonjua Group and should have avoided actions that sent the wrong signal about the effect of the payment. Its conduct was considered sufficiently reckless to warrant corrective damages.

Legal Interest: The Refund Was Not Just the Principal Amount

The Court also clarified the applicable legal interest. PSE was ordered to pay the P19,000,000.00 refund, with interest at 12% per annum from the date of demand on July 30, 2006 until June 30, 2013, and 6% per annum from July 1, 2013 until full satisfaction. This adjustment followed the change in the legal interest rate under Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas Monetary Board Circular No. 799.

For claimants, this aspect of the decision matters because delay can materially increase recovery. For companies resisting refund claims, it is a warning that refusing to return money without legal basis can convert a principal refund dispute into a much larger liability exposure.

Practical Takeaways for Companies, Investors, and Payors

First, board approval matters. If a transaction requires corporate action, parties should secure a clear board resolution or written authority before paying large sums. Reliance on officers, committees, receipts, or business communications may not be enough to prove corporate consent to a contract.

Second, payment documentation matters. The Court relied heavily on the letters, checks, and receipt annotations showing the purpose of the P19,000,000.00 payment. A party seeking refund must preserve documents showing why the payment was made, what conditions were attached, and how the recipient treated the funds.

Third, corporate recipients should not assume that a payment, once accepted, is theirs to keep. If the legal basis for the payment fails, the recipient may be treated as unjustly enriched. The safer course is to clarify the legal basis of receipt immediately and avoid inconsistent positions that may later support estoppel.

Finally, demand letters matter. The Court reckoned legal interest from the date of demand. In refund and collection cases, a properly drafted demand letter can affect not only settlement posture but also the computation of recoverable interest.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises clients in commercial litigation, refund claims, shareholder and securities-related disputes, corporate governance issues, and collection cases involving unjust enrichment, estoppel, legal interest, and damages. If your company paid money under a failed transaction, received a demand for refund, or faces a dispute over corporate authority and board approval, our litigation team can evaluate your documents, assess recoverable amounts, and design a practical strategy for negotiation or court action.

For assistance with commercial disputes, corporate litigation, and refund or collection claims in the Philippines, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *