A seller of receivables remains liable when checks assigned with recourse bounce, and a corporate officer who signs as surety may be personally bound.

Businesses that sell receivables or postdated checks to a financing company may remain liable when those checks bounce if the assignment was made with recourse. The seller cannot avoid payment by arguing that the finance company should have chased the check drawers first, especially when the contract expressly makes the seller answerable upon dishonor.

Why This Case Matters to Businesses Using Discounting Lines

Receivables financing is a common liquidity tool. A business holding customer checks or accounts receivable may assign them to a financing company at a discount, receive immediate cash, and allow the finance company to collect later. The commercial appeal is obvious: the seller converts future collections into present working capital.

The risk, however, lies in the fine print. If the assignment is made without recourse, the finance company generally assumes the credit risk of nonpayment by the receivable debtor. If it is made with recourse, the assignor remains answerable if the receivable is not paid. Great Asian Sales Center Corporation v. Court of Appeals (G.R. No. 105774) clarifies the legal effect of that structure in Philippine law.

Background: A Discounting Line Secured by Postdated Checks

Great Asian Sales Center Corporation was engaged in buying and selling general merchandise, particularly household appliances. Its board authorized its treasurer and general manager, Arsenio Lim, Jr., to apply for and negotiate a loan accommodation or credit line with Bancasia Finance and Investment Corporation. A second board resolution authorized a discounting line with Bancasia and empowered Arsenio to sign and deliver documents, checks, and instruments needed for that facility.

Great Asian later entered into deeds of assignment in favor of Bancasia. Through these documents, Great Asian assigned several postdated checks payable to it by customers. The deeds stated that the assignment covered accounts receivable and was made with recourse. When many of the checks were dishonored, Bancasia demanded payment from Great Asian and from Tan Chong Lin, who had signed surety agreements in favor of Bancasia. Neither paid. Bancasia then sued for collection.

The Ruling: Board Authority Covered the Deeds of Assignment

The Supreme Court rejected Great Asian’s argument that Arsenio lacked authority to sign the deeds of assignment. Under the Corporation Code, corporate powers are generally exercised by the board of directors, but the board may authorize officers or agents to perform particular acts. Here, the board resolutions were broad enough to authorize the discounting arrangement and the signing of documents necessary to implement it.

The Court noted that the resolutions were not limited to a conventional loan. They expressly contemplated a loan accommodation, a credit line, and a discounting line with Bancasia. The deeds of assignment were the very documents by which the discounting line was carried out. Because Arsenio acted within the authority granted by the board, Great Asian was bound by the assignments.

The With-Recourse Doctrine: Selling Receivables Does Not Always Transfer the Risk

The central doctrine of the case is the enforceability of a with-recourse receivables assignment. The Court explained that the deeds of assignment created a conditional obligation: Great Asian would be liable to Bancasia if the drawers of the postdated checks failed to pay upon maturity.

That condition occurred when the checks were dishonored. Once dishonor happened, Bancasia could sue Great Asian for breach of the deeds of assignment. The Court treated this liability as contractual, separate from any claim Bancasia might have against the drawers of the checks under the Negotiable Instruments Law.

This distinction is important. Bancasia did not need to proceed only against the check drawers. Nor did Great Asian become immune merely because the instruments assigned were checks. The finance company’s claim against Great Asian arose from the assignment contract, not merely from the dishonored checks themselves.

Notice of Dishonor Was Not a Shield Against Contract Liability

Great Asian argued that Bancasia failed to comply with the rules on dishonored negotiable instruments. The Supreme Court was not persuaded. It held that Bancasia’s action was based on the deeds of assignment, where Great Asian expressly undertook liability if the checks were not paid. The contractual undertaking with recourse was enforceable even if the finance company chose not to pursue, or could not successfully pursue, every drawer of every dishonored check.

The Court also observed that Great Asian was already aware of the dishonor of the checks. The checks were dishonored for reasons such as closed accounts, insufficient funds, garnishment, payment stopped, or ordered stopped. Under the circumstances, the company could not fairly claim surprise or prejudice.

The Surety’s Liability: A President Who Signs Personally May Be Bound Personally

Tan Chong Lin, Great Asian’s president, signed surety agreements in favor of Bancasia. He argued that the warranties in the deeds of assignment expanded his obligations and that there was no notice to him of the dishonor or the alleged extension of debt.

The Supreme Court held him liable. His surety agreements were broad and made him solidarily liable with Great Asian for obligations, drafts, bills of exchange, overdrafts, and other liabilities of the principal. The Court found that he explicitly and unconditionally bound himself as surety. When Great Asian became liable under the deeds of assignment, Tan Chong Lin’s solidary liability also attached.

For business owners and corporate officers, this is one of the case’s most practical warnings. A person may sign one document as a corporate officer and another as a surety in a personal capacity. The latter can expose the individual to direct liability, even if the underlying debt arose from the corporation’s financing transaction.

Damages, Interest, and Attorney’s Fees

The Supreme Court affirmed Great Asian and Tan Chong Lin’s solidary liability for the unpaid value of the dishonored checks, subject to the modifications already made by the Court of Appeals. It also allowed legal interest on the principal amount from the filing of the complaint until full payment. Bancasia was further awarded attorney’s fees, but the Court limited the award to the principal debtor, Great Asian, not to Tan Chong Lin as surety.

Practical Impact for Companies, Lenders, and Corporate Officers

The decision is highly relevant to businesses using invoice discounting, receivables financing, postdated check arrangements, and credit lines secured by customer payments. A company that assigns receivables with recourse is not simply selling paper and walking away. It is promising that if the receivables do not pay, it will make the finance company whole.

For finance companies, the ruling confirms that with-recourse clauses are enforceable when clearly written. The assignee may rely on the contractual allocation of risk and sue the assignor when the receivables fail. This provides legal stability for discounting transactions, especially where financing is extended on the strength of customer checks or assigned accounts.

For corporate borrowers, the case underscores the importance of board resolutions. A broadly worded authority to obtain a credit line, discount receivables, sign documents, and deliver instruments may bind the corporation to substantial obligations. Corporate boards should review these resolutions carefully and ensure that internal authority matches the intended transaction limits.

For presidents, treasurers, directors, and shareholders who sign guarantees or surety agreements, the lesson is even sharper. Personal suretyship is not ceremonial. If the corporation defaults, the surety may be sued directly and solidarily. Before signing, officers should confirm whether they are signing only for the corporation or also binding themselves personally.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Receivables financing, postdated check disputes, surety agreements, and collection suits often turn on the exact wording of board resolutions, deeds of assignment, guarantees, and demand letters. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, finance companies, corporate officers, and litigants on contract enforcement, collection strategy, corporate authority, and personal liability risks arising from financing transactions.

If your company is facing a collection case, dishonored check dispute, receivables assignment issue, or personal surety claim, our litigation and corporate lawyers can help assess exposure, prepare defenses, negotiate settlement, or pursue recovery. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on business litigation and finance-related disputes.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *