Old charter tax exemptions of GOCCs may be withdrawn by the Local Government Code; MCIAA’s airport properties were held taxable by Cebu.
Government-owned or controlled corporations cannot assume that an old charter exemption will protect their real properties from local real property tax. When the Local Government Code took effect, prior tax exemptions were withdrawn unless the property falls within the specific exemptions preserved by law.
Why This Case Matters to Taxpayers and Local Governments
The ruling is important because it answers a recurring tax question: when a government-created corporation owns or operates property, may the city or municipality tax it? For businesses, contractors, airport operators, port-related companies, and local governments, the decision shows that public purpose alone does not automatically mean tax immunity. The legal character of the owner, the nature and use of the property, and the wording of the exemption all matter.
Mactan-Cebu International Airport Authority argued that its properties were exempt from real property tax because its charter exempted it from paying realty taxes imposed by the National Government or any of its political subdivisions, agencies, and instrumentalities. The City of Cebu, through its treasurer, demanded payment of real property taxes on several parcels of land. MCIAA then sought declaratory relief, but the trial court dismissed the petition, leading to Supreme Court review in Mactan-Cebu International Airport Authority v. Marcos (G.R. No. 120082).
The Doctrine: Charter Tax Exemptions Yield to the Local Government Code
The Supreme Court held that MCIAA could no longer rely on the general exemption in its charter after the effectivity of the Local Government Code of 1991. Section 193 of the Code withdrew tax exemptions previously enjoyed by all persons, natural or juridical, including government-owned or controlled corporations, except those expressly preserved. Section 234 likewise withdrew exemptions from real property tax previously granted to such entities, except for specifically listed categories.
For the Court, the issue was not whether MCIAA performed a public function. The more specific question was whether its properties fell within the statutory list of real property tax exemptions. The Court found that they did not. The parcels were not real property owned by the Republic of the Philippines or its political subdivisions in the sense protected by Section 234. Nor were they shown to fall under the other protected categories, such as charitable, religious, or educational use, registered cooperatives, water or electric utility equipment, or pollution-control equipment.
Why Being a Government Instrumentality Was Not Enough
MCIAA also invoked the Local Government Code provision prohibiting local governments from imposing taxes, fees, or charges of any kind on the National Government, its agencies and instrumentalities, and local government units. The Court rejected this defense. It distinguished the National Government from government-owned or controlled corporations. A GOCC may be created for public purposes, but it is still treated differently from the National Government itself for purposes of local taxation.
The Court emphasized that the Constitution gives local government units the power to create their own sources of revenue and to levy taxes, fees, and charges subject to congressional guidelines. The Local Government Code was enacted to make decentralization real by giving LGUs more authority, responsibility, and resources. Reading MCIAA’s old charter exemption as still controlling would undermine that policy.
Tax Exemptions Are Strictly Construed
The Court repeated a foundational rule in tax law: taxes are the lifeblood of government, and exemptions are never presumed. A party claiming exemption must point to clear and unmistakable language. When doubt exists, the doubt is resolved against the taxpayer and in favor of the taxing authority.
This rule applied with particular force because MCIAA was not a private party that had received an exemption as part of a contractual bargain. Its exemption came from statute. Statutory tax exemptions, especially those granted to government entities and government corporations, may be withdrawn by Congress. The Court therefore treated the Local Government Code as a valid withdrawal of MCIAA’s earlier exemption.
The Real Property Tax Result
The Supreme Court denied MCIAA’s petition and affirmed the trial court. The practical result was that MCIAA’s properties in Cebu were subject to real property tax unless MCIAA could show that the specific parcels fell within one of the exemptions expressly listed in the Local Government Code. Its general charter exemption was no longer enough.
The Court also rejected the argument that MCIAA was not a taxable person. The law governing MCIAA transferred existing airport facilities, runways, lands, buildings, and other properties to the authority. The Court treated this transfer as sufficient to place the properties within the real property tax system, subject only to the specific statutory exemptions that remained after the Local Government Code.
What This Means for Property Owners and Public-Private Projects
For government corporations and public authorities, the decision is a warning: do not rely solely on old charter language when assessing local tax exposure. A tax exemption granted before the Local Government Code may have been withdrawn. The safer analysis is to examine the present statute, the title or ownership structure, the beneficial use of the property, and whether the property is expressly covered by an exemption.
For local governments, the ruling confirms that real property tax can be an important tool for fiscal autonomy. Cities and municipalities are not automatically barred from taxing properties merely because those properties are connected with a national public function, such as airport operations. If the property is held by a GOCC or similar entity and does not fall within the statutory exemptions, local taxation may apply.
For private businesses dealing with government assets, including airport concessionaires, lessees, infrastructure contractors, and real estate developers, the case highlights a practical due diligence point. Before pricing a bid, lease, concession, or development arrangement, parties should determine who bears local real property tax, whether the property is exempt, and whether any assumed exemption remains legally effective.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Local tax disputes often turn on careful statutory interpretation, property classification, ownership records, and the exact wording of exemptions. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists property owners, government contractors, corporations, and local taxpayers in evaluating real property tax assessments, contesting local tax demands, and structuring transactions involving public or regulated assets. For legal assistance on real property tax, local taxation, or disputes with LGUs, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.