A private road built on public land may be exempt from real property tax if ownership belongs to the government, not the company that built and used it.
A company that spends its own money to build a road on public land does not automatically become the taxable owner of that road. When the improvement legally belongs to the government by accession, it may be treated as government-owned property exempt from real property tax, even if the private company built it, uses it, and benefits from it.
The Practical Issue: Who Pays Real Property Tax on Improvements Built on Public Land?
Real property tax disputes often begin with a simple assumption: if a business built something and uses it for its operations, the local assessor may tax it as that businessâs property. This case shows why that assumption can be wrong when the improvement is built on public land and ownership legally vests in the government.
Samar Mining Company, Inc., a domestic corporation engaged in mining, constructed a gravel road connecting its mine site in Buug, Zamboanga del Sur to a pier area at Pamintayan. The road was approximately 42 kilometers long. Samar Mining sought and later obtained permission to occupy and use public lands for the road right-of-way. Although the road was completed in 1959, the formal applications for road right-of-way were approved only on October 7, 1965.
The Provincial Assessor assessed the road for real property tax purposes at an assessed value of P1,117,900. Samar Mining challenged the assessment before the provincial Board of Assessment Appeals. The Board sustained the assessment. Samar Mining then appealed to the Court of Tax Appeals, which held that the road was exempt from real property tax. The assessors brought the dispute to the Supreme Court in Board of Assessment Appeals of Zamboanga del Sur v. Samar Mining Company, Inc. (G.R. No. L-28034).
The Supreme Courtâs Ruling: The Road Was Not Taxable to Samar Mining
The Supreme Court affirmed the Court of Tax Appeals and held that Samar Mining was exempt from paying real property tax on the assessed value of the road. The Court reasoned that although the road was constructed by Samar Mining at its own expense and for its mining operations, it was built on public land. Under the law on accession, improvements constructed on land generally belong to the owner of the land. Since the land belonged to the government, the road was treated as an improvement owned by the government.
This mattered because the Assessment Law imposed real property tax on land, buildings, machinery, and improvements not otherwise exempt. At the same time, the law exempted property owned by the government. The Court emphasized that the statutory exemption for government-owned property did not distinguish between improvements originally constructed by the government and improvements constructed by a private party but legally belonging to the government.
In practical terms, the Court refused to treat physical construction and operational use as conclusive proof of taxable ownership. The decisive question was not merely who paid for the road or who used it, but who owned the improvement under property law.
The Public-Land Accession Doctrine
The core doctrine may be called the Public-Land Accession Doctrine: an improvement built by a private party on public land may be exempt from real property tax when, by operation of law, ownership of that improvement belongs to the government.
The Court relied on the Civil Code principle that the owner of the land generally owns what is built, planted, or sown on it. Because the road traversed public land and was constructed under a government right-of-way arrangement, the Court treated the road as property that belonged to the State, notwithstanding Samar Miningâs substantial investment and business benefit.
The Court also recognized the broader public character of the road. While Samar Mining used it to haul iron ore from its mine to the pier, the road also formed part of the road system that the government had long sought to improve. The Court noted that the government had been trying to provide road access in the area for many years and that the road could serve public and governmental interests in addition to Samar Miningâs private operations.
Why Use and Benefit Did Not Make the Road Taxable
The assessors argued that the road should be taxable because Samar Mining constructed it, used it, and benefited from it. The Supreme Court rejected that reasoning. Benefit alone does not create taxable ownership. A lessee, concessionaire, or permit holder may enjoy the use of an improvement without owning it for real property tax purposes.
This distinction is important for mining companies, infrastructure operators, utilities, port users, logistics businesses, and other entities that build or maintain improvements on public land. Local governments may be tempted to assess the user of the improvement because the user is visible, solvent, and operationally connected to the property. But the Court made clear that the legal character of the property must still be examined.
The ruling does not mean that every improvement built by a private party on public land is automatically tax-exempt. It means that assessors and taxpayers must determine whether, under the governing property arrangement and applicable law, the improvement belongs to the government or to the private entity. If the private party owns the improvement, taxation may still be proper. If ownership belongs to the government, the government-property exemption may apply.
The Court of Tax Appeals Could Review the Assessment Even Without Prior Payment Under Protest
The case also resolved a procedural issue important to real property tax litigation. The assessors argued that Samar Mining could not appeal to the Court of Tax Appeals because it had not first paid the tax under protest. The Supreme Court disagreed.
The Court distinguished between ordinary disputes over the amount or reasonableness of an assessment and cases questioning the legality or validity of the tax itself. Samar Mining was not merely arguing that the valuation was too high. It was arguing that the road was not taxable to it at all. For that kind of legal challenge, requiring payment before appeal would unfairly force a taxpayer to pay a tax that may be void or unauthorized before a court could review the issue.
The Court also treated the Court of Tax Appealsâ statutory appellate jurisdiction as controlling. Appeals from decisions of provincial or city boards of assessment appeals could be brought to the Court of Tax Appeals within the period provided by law. To the extent an older payment-under-protest rule conflicted with that appellate jurisdiction, the Court considered it displaced.
What This Means for Property Owners and Businesses
For businesses using public land, this ruling is a reminder that real property tax exposure depends on ownership, legal classification, and statutory exemptionsânot simply on who constructed the improvement. A private company that builds access roads, utility facilities, drainage works, piers, or similar structures on public land should carefully review the underlying permit, lease, concession, right-of-way, or government authorization.
For local assessors, the ruling warns against shortcut assessments based only on private use. Before imposing real property tax on improvements located on public land, the assessor should determine whether the improvement is privately owned or whether it belongs to the government by accession or by the terms of the governing instrument.
For taxpayers, the ruling provides a potential defense against real property tax assessments involving improvements on public property. The defense is strongest where the taxpayer can show that the land is public, that the improvement legally belongs to the government, and that the taxpayer merely has a right to use or occupy the area under a permit, lease, concession, or similar authority.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Real property tax assessments can create large liabilities for businesses, land users, and infrastructure operators, especially when local governments assess roads, buildings, machinery, or improvements connected to regulated operations. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in evaluating assessments, preparing protests and appeals, reviewing title and public-land issues, and litigating tax disputes before the proper administrative bodies and courts.
For legal assistance involving real property tax assessments, local tax disputes, public-land improvements, or Court of Tax Appeals remedies, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.