Sellers bear sale execution and registration costs unless the deed clearly shifts them; good-faith officials may avoid refund liability.
The Written-Stipulation Sale Expenses Rule protects buyers, sellers, and government entities from after-the-fact claims that a property buyer agreed to pay taxes and transfer costs. If the deed of sale does not expressly shift those expenses to the buyer, the default rule under Philippine civil law applies: the seller bears the expenses of execution and registration. For property dispute SC ruling Philippines searches, this case is a practical warning that side letters, prior negotiations, and board or council resolutions may not save a transaction if the final contract omits the essential term.
Background: The Dispute
Koronadal City purchased land from the heirs of Plomillo for a proposed new city hall site. The sellers had earlier offered to lower the purchase price to P22,000,000.00 on the condition that the city shoulder transfer-related expenses, and the Sangguniang Panlungsod authorized the mayor to enter into the sale on terms reflecting that understanding.
When the Deed of Absolute Sale was signed, however, it stated only the P22,000,000.00 consideration and did not say that Koronadal City would pay capital gains tax, documentary stamp tax, estate tax, transfer tax, registration fees, or notarial fees. After audit, the Commission on Audit disallowed P2,398,403.02 in payments and held several officials and the vendors liable. Marites Domato-Togonon, a member of the Sangguniang Panlungsod, challenged the disallowance before the Supreme Court (G.R. No. 224516, July 6, 2021).
The Supreme Court’s Ruling
The Court partly granted the petition. It affirmed COA’s ruling that the payment of transfer-related taxes and expenses was properly disallowed, but modified the ruling by excusing Domato-Togonon from personally returning the disallowed amount.
The Court relied on Article 1487 of the Civil Code: expenses for the execution and registration of a sale are borne by the vendor unless there is a stipulation to the contrary. Because the Deed of Absolute Sale did not contain such a stipulation, the seller remained responsible for those costs. The Court also applied the parol evidence rule. Since the parties reduced their agreement into a written deed, earlier offers and resolutions could not be used to add a term that the deed itself omitted, absent a recognized exception such as ambiguity, mistake, or failure of the writing to express the parties’ true agreement.
Key Legal Principles Established
The case establishes the Written-Stipulation Sale Expenses Rule: a buyer’s obligation to shoulder sale execution and registration expenses must appear in the written contract itself. Negotiation history is not enough. A resolution authorizing a transaction is not a substitute for a clear contractual stipulation in the deed of sale.
The ruling also clarifies that a local government unit cannot indirectly assume tax burdens in a manner inconsistent with law. COA correctly treated the city’s payment of several transfer-related taxes as irregular, especially where the Local Government Code limits local taxing powers and the National Internal Revenue Code identifies the persons legally liable for specific taxes.
At the same time, the Court applied the modern COA liability framework. Public officers are not automatically required to refund disallowed amounts. Under the Administrative Code, there must be a clear showing of bad faith, malice, or gross negligence before an officer may be held civilly liable for acts performed in official functions. Here, the record did not show that Domato-Togonon acted in bad faith, maliciously, or with gross negligence.
What This Means for Businesses and Individuals
For real estate sellers and buyers, the lesson is direct: put tax and transfer-cost allocation in the deed itself. If the buyer is expected to pay capital gains tax, documentary stamp tax, estate tax, transfer tax, registration fees, or notarial expenses, the contract should say so clearly. A missing clause can shift millions of pesos in liability.
For LGUs, suppliers, and contractors dealing with government, the decision shows why government contracts require special care. Even if a transaction appears commercially favorable, COA may still disallow payments that violate statutory allocation rules, tax laws, procurement limitations, or audit regulations.
For public officials, the case is also significant. A COA disallowance does not always mean personal refund liability. Officials who acted in good faith, within their functions, and without gross negligence may invoke the good-faith protection recognized in COA disallowance jurisprudence.
Need a Philippine Property and Government Contracts Lawyer?
A missing tax-allocation clause in a deed of sale can trigger COA disallowance, seller-buyer disputes, refund demands, and personal liability issues for approving officers. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises clients on Philippine property transactions, government contracts, COA disallowance exposure, and civil litigation arising from defective sale documents.
If you are buying or selling land, dealing with an LGU transaction, or facing a COA-related property dispute, speak with a Makati property lawyer at Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com or our Makati office.