A company that ratifies employee gratuity pay through conduct and partial payment cannot later avoid liability through corporate technicalities.
Employers that approve gratuity or retirement-style benefits for employees may remain bound even if they later claim defects in board notice, stockholder approval, or corporate authority, especially when the company has already begun paying the benefit and the obligation concerns employee welfare. The practical lesson is direct: a company cannot treat employee gratuity pay as valid when convenient, pay some installments, and then avoid the balance by invoking internal corporate irregularities that its own officers tolerated or ratified.
Why This Case Matters to Employers and Employees
Lopez Realty, Inc. involved a dispute between long-serving employees and a family-controlled corporation engaged in real estate. Several employees claimed payment of gratuity pay after the company had adopted board resolutions granting benefits to employees who would be laid off or retained during a corporate reorganization. The controversy later reached the labor tribunals and the Supreme Court because the company resisted payment by attacking the validity of the very resolutions that created the gratuity obligation.
The case is important because many Philippine businesses, particularly closely held corporations, make employment-related decisions through informal or family-driven corporate action. When those decisions affect employees, the company may not easily escape liability by saying later that the proper internal steps were not followed. In this second decision in Lopez Realty, Inc. v. Fontecha (G.R. No. 76801, August 11, 1995), the Court dealt with the legal consequences of board resolutions granting gratuity pay and the limits of using corporate law defenses in labor disputes.
The Background: A Corporate Reorganization and a Promise of Gratuity Pay
The dispute began after Lopez Realty considered a proposal involving the sale of company assets and the transfer of assets to major shareholders, while some assets would remain with the company and continue to be used in operations. The proposal recognized that certain employees might be affected by the changes and included a provision for gratuity pay.
The company later approved resolutions granting gratuity pay to employees. Under the arrangements described in the decision, laid-off employees were to receive the full amount of gratuity pay, while retained employees were to receive the benefit in installments. Some employees received the first installments. Others continued to demand payment of the remaining amounts. When the company refused, the employees pursued their claims before the labor arbiter and the National Labor Relations Commission.
The labor arbiter ruled for the employees, and the NLRC affirmed. The company then argued that the resolutions granting gratuity pay were invalid because one director, Asuncion Lopez Gonzales, allegedly had no notice of the special board meetings; that the resolutions were not ratified by the stockholders; and that the company had supposedly committed a mistake by paying gratuity to employees who were not yet retiring.
The Courtâs Core Doctrine: Ratified Employee Benefits Cannot Be Undone by Internal Corporate Objections
The controlling doctrine may be called the corporate ratification and employee gratuity rule. A corporation generally acts through its board of directors, and directors must act as a body in a properly called meeting. But an action of the board that may be defective because of lack of notice can still be ratified, either expressly through later corporate action or impliedly through conduct.
In Lopez Realty, the company did not issue any resolution revoking or nullifying the board resolutions granting gratuity pay. Instead, it partially paid the gratuity pay to some employees. The Court considered that conduct significant. The companyâs payment of the first installments showed that it had treated the gratuity resolutions as valid. Asuncion Lopez Gonzales herself also signed cash vouchers for installment payments, which supported the conclusion that she knew of the obligation and acquiesced in it.
Because of these circumstances, the company could not later invoke lack of notice as a reason to deny the employeesâ claims. The Court treated the companyâs conduct as ratification. In practical terms, the employer had already acted as if the benefit was binding. It could not reverse course only when employees sought the balance.
Why the Ultra Vires Defense Failed
The company also argued that the gratuity resolutions were ultra vires, or beyond the corporationâs powers. The Court rejected that position. Gratuity pay and retirement-related benefits fall within matters concerning employee welfare. Under corporate law, a corporation may establish pension, retirement, and similar plans for the benefit of its directors, trustees, officers, and employees. The resolutions granting gratuity pay therefore concerned a subject within the corporationâs express or incidental powers.
This is especially important for employers. A company cannot characterize an employee benefit as unauthorized merely because it later regrets the financial burden. If the benefit relates to employee welfare and the corporation has the legal capacity to adopt such a plan, the company will have difficulty avoiding liability by calling the act ultra vires.
Why Stockholder Approval Was Not Required
The company further argued that the gratuity resolutions needed stockholder approval because they supposedly involved the sale or disposition of corporate assets. The Court was not persuaded. The statutory provision requiring stockholder approval for sale or disposition of substantially all corporate assets did not apply because the gratuity issue was not itself a sale, lease, exchange, mortgage, pledge, or disposition of all or substantially all corporate property.
Even more practically, except for Arturo Lopez, the stockholders were also members of the board of directors. Under the circumstances, requiring separate stockholder approval would have been illogical and superfluous. The absence of a separate stockholder vote did not release the company from its obligation to pay the employeesâ gratuity benefits.
The Procedural Lesson: Raise All Defenses Early or Lose Them
The decision also reinforces an important litigation rule. A party cannot raise new issues for the first time on appeal or in later stages of a case after failing to present them before the labor arbiter. The companyâs objections based on lack of notice and corporate mistake were not raised at the earliest opportunity. The Court held that basic fair play prevented the company from withholding those arguments and then deploying them only after losing before the labor tribunals.
For employers, this means that defenses in labor cases must be complete, timely, and supported from the start. For employees, it means that an employerâs late technical objections may not defeat a claim if those objections were not properly raised and proven in the proceedings below.
Practical Impact for Philippine Employers
Lopez Realty is a warning to corporations that employment benefits approved through board action should be handled with care. If a company approves gratuity pay, retirement benefits, separation packages, or similar employee welfare benefits, then partially pays or otherwise recognizes those benefits, it may become legally bound. Later claims of internal irregularity may fail if the companyâs conduct shows ratification or acquiescence.
Employers should therefore ensure that board resolutions on employee benefits are properly noticed, clearly drafted, entered into corporate records, and aligned with labor obligations. If a company believes a resolution is erroneous, unauthorized, or financially unsustainable, it should address the issue through formal corporate action immediately, not after employees have relied on it or after partial payments have been made.
Practical Impact for Employees Claiming Gratuity or Retirement Benefits
Employees who were promised gratuity pay or retirement-style benefits should preserve proof of corporate approval, payment vouchers, payroll records, memoranda, minutes, and prior installments. The strongest evidence is often not merely the written resolution but the employerâs conduct: payment of some installments, acknowledgment of the benefit, or treatment of similarly situated employees as entitled to the same benefit.
The ruling also helps employees facing the common defense that management made a mistake or that an internal corporate formality was missing. When the benefit concerns employee welfare and the company has already acted on it, those defenses may not be enough to defeat the claim.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Gratuity pay, retirement benefits, separation packages, board approvals, and NLRC claims often sit at the intersection of labor law and corporate governance. A poorly drafted board resolution or an informal benefit promise can become a costly dispute if not handled correctly.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employers, executives, and employees on labor disputes, corporate approvals, retirement and gratuity claims, and NLRC proceedings. For guidance on enforcing or defending employee benefit claims in the Philippines, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our litigation and labor law team.