Corporate officers cannot bind a corporation without board authority or ratification; courts also require competent proof before imposing counterclaim liability.
A corporation is not automatically bound by a loan, promissory note, or financial undertaking merely because its president, chairman, or other officer signed the document. The party seeking to enforce the obligation must prove that the officer had board authority, apparent authority, or that the corporation later ratified the act. At the same time, a corporation that counterclaims against an individual for alleged misappropriation must prove that claim with competent evidence, not suspicion, audit concerns, or procedural shortcuts.
The Core Doctrine: Corporate Authority Must Be Proven, Not Presumed
The Reyes ruling is a useful reminder of what may be called the Board Authority and Ratification Proof Doctrine. Under Philippine corporate law, a corporation acts through its board of directors or trustees. Officers may sign documents and transact business, but their acts bind the corporation only when they are authorized by the board, fall within authority validly delegated to them, or are later ratified by the corporation through conduct amounting to approval.
This matters in everyday business disputes. A lender, supplier, contractor, or consultant cannot safely rely on title alone. The fact that a person is called president, chairman, vice chairman, treasurer, or accounting officer does not necessarily mean that the corporation has agreed to be bound. Authority is a question of proof.
Background: A Loan Note Signed by Credit Union Officers
Natividad Reyes filed a collection case against RCPI Employees Credit Union, Inc., a credit cooperative organized under Philippine law. Her claim was based on a promissory note dated December 8, 1986, signed by the credit unionâs president and chairman, vice chairman, and accounting officer. The note stated that the credit union promised to pay Reyes the sum of P162,338.52, with interest and attorneyâs fees in case of default.
The credit union denied liability. It claimed that the officers who signed the promissory note were not authorized to borrow money on its behalf. It also asserted a counterclaim against Reyes, alleging that she had misappropriated over P1 million while serving as treasurer. The Regional Trial Court initially ruled in favor of Reyes on the promissory note and dismissed the counterclaim. The Court of Appeals reversed, dismissed her complaint, and held her liable on the counterclaim. The Supreme Court reviewed the dispute in Reyes v. RCPI Employees Credit Union, Inc. (G.R. No. 146535).
Why the Promissory Note Did Not Bind the Credit Union
The Supreme Court held that the credit union was not liable under the promissory note because Reyes failed to prove that the officers who signed it had authority to bind the corporation. As a corporate entity, the credit union could exercise its powers only through its board of directors or through officers properly authorized by that board. There was no board resolution, power of attorney, or other competent proof showing that the president and other signatories had authority to borrow money from Reyes for the credit union.
The Court emphasized that apparent authority cannot rest on assumption alone. While corporate officers may sometimes bind a corporation through repeated and recognized business conduct, there must still be evidence showing that the corporation knowingly permitted the officer to act in that manner or held the officer out as authorized. Here, the record did not establish that the credit unionâs board knew of, approved, or benefited from the loan. Even the fact that some officers signed postdated checks did not, by itself, prove board authority or corporate ratification.
Ratification Requires More Than Silence or Suspicion
Reyes argued that the credit union should be deemed to have ratified the loan because its president remained in office and because the credit union did not sue him in relation to the note. The Court rejected that theory. Ratification requires proof that the corporation, with knowledge of the material facts, accepted or adopted the unauthorized act. It cannot be inferred merely from the continued employment or position of an officer, especially where the corporation consistently denied that the officer had authority to borrow.
For businesses, this is the practical lesson: ratification is not a magic word. It must be anchored in corporate conduct that clearly shows adoption of the unauthorized act. Payment, board acknowledgment, acceptance of benefits, accounting treatment, or a later resolution may support ratification. Mere inaction, internal confusion, or failure to immediately sue an officer may not be enough.
Why the Counterclaim Also Failed
The Supreme Court also ruled that Reyes should not be held liable for the credit unionâs counterclaim for alleged misappropriation. The credit union relied on audit findings and alleged irregularities involving checks and accounting records. However, the Court found that the evidence did not sufficiently establish Reyesâ personal liability for the amounts claimed.
The Court noted that the financial examination report itself acknowledged limitations in the records, the absence of certain supporting documents, and uncertainty in attributing responsibility. It was not enough to say that Reyes, as treasurer or custodian of records, should automatically bear civil liability for the alleged deficiency. A counterclaim for a specific sum of money requires competent proof of the obligation, the amount, and the claimantâs right to recover from the person sued.
Requests for Admission Cannot Replace Proof
The Court also addressed Reyesâ argument involving a request for admission. She claimed that certain allegations should be deemed admitted because the credit union did not properly deny them. The Court disagreed. The matters sought to be admitted had already been denied in the credit unionâs answer. A request for admission is not designed to force a party to make a second denial of facts it has already disputed in its pleadings.
This is important in litigation strategy. Requests for admission are useful to narrow issues and remove uncontested facts from trial. They are not a substitute for proving contested allegations, nor can they be used merely to trap a party into repeating denials already made in the answer.
Practical Impact for Business Owners, Lenders, and Cooperatives
The Reyes ruling is a cautionary case for anyone dealing with corporations, cooperatives, associations, and employee credit unions. When money is loaned, goods are supplied, or services are extended on credit, the safest practice is to require documentary proof that the person signing has authority. This usually means a board resolution, secretaryâs certificate, specific delegation, or written approval from the governing body.
For corporations and cooperatives, the ruling also reinforces the importance of clear internal controls. If officers can sign checks, borrow money, or issue undertakings, their authority should be precisely documented. If they cannot, counterparties should be informed and corporate forms should make the limits clear. Ambiguity invites litigation.
For individuals accused of financial liability, the decision shows that courts will not impose civil liability based on position alone. A treasurer, custodian, officer, or employee may face serious allegations, but the claimant still bears the burden of proving the actual obligation and the factual basis for recovery.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Disputes involving promissory notes, unauthorized corporate acts, officer liability, cooperative obligations, and counterclaims often turn on documents, authority, and proof. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in evaluating whether a corporation is bound by a contract, whether officers may be held personally liable, and whether claims or counterclaims are supported by admissible evidence.
For advice on corporate litigation, collection cases, credit agreements, board authority disputes, or defense against counterclaims, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco.