Corporate officers appointed by the board must pursue removal disputes as intra-corporate controversies, not ordinary NLRC illegal dismissal cases.

A corporate officer removed by a board of directors cannot automatically frame the dispute as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the labor tribunals. When the position was created by the corporation’s charter or by-laws, and the appointment or removal is made by the board, the controversy is treated as an intra-corporate dispute, even if the officer also seeks unpaid salaries or other money claims.

Why This Jurisdiction Rule Matters

For employers, condominium corporations, associations, and corporate officers, Ongkingco is an important reminder that the forum can decide the case before the merits are ever reached. A dismissed administrator, superintendent, manager, treasurer, secretary, or other by-law officer may believe that the case should be filed as an illegal dismissal complaint with the National Labor Relations Commission. But if the officer’s position is part of the corporation’s governance structure and the removal was an act of the board, the dispute may fall under corporate jurisdiction rather than labor jurisdiction.

The practical consequence is significant. A labor arbiter may have authority over ordinary employer-employee controversies, but not every person who receives compensation from a corporation is merely an employee. Some officers occupy positions that derive from corporate law, not simply from labor law. When the case concerns the validity of appointment, non-reappointment, or removal from such a position, the dispute becomes corporate in character.

Background of the Dispute

Galeria de Magallanes Condominium Association, Inc. was a non-stock, non-profit corporation organized under the Condominium Act to hold title to the common areas of the condominium project and to manage them for the benefit and convenience of residents and owners. Bienvenido Ongkingco was president of the association when Federico Guilas filed his complaint.

Guilas had been appointed by the board of directors as Administrator or Superintendent on September 1, 1990. He received a monthly salary of P10,000, subject to review after five months and subsequently after the association’s finances improved. His work involved maintaining the performance and appearance of the common areas, both interior and exterior, for the convenience and comfort of the residents and to keep up the quality image and value of the project.

On March 17, 1992, the board passed a resolution not to reappoint him as Administrator. Guilas then filed a complaint for illegal dismissal and non-payment of salaries with the NLRC. The petitioners moved to dismiss, arguing that the case belonged to the Securities and Exchange Commission because the dispute involved a corporate officer and an intra-corporate controversy. The case reached the Supreme Court in Ongkingco v. National Labor Relations Commission (G.R. No. 119277, March 31, 1997).

The Corporate Officer Doctrine

The Court held that Guilas was not merely an ordinary employee. The by-laws of Galeria de Magallanes expressly included the Superintendent or Administrator among the corporation’s officers. The by-laws also authorized the board of directors to appoint a Superintendent or Administrator for the condominium project if the activities and financial condition of the association warranted it. If appointed, the Superintendent or Administrator would be the principal administrative officer of the association, would attend to the routine and day-to-day business and activities of the association, and would keep regular office hours.

Those provisions were decisive. The Court emphasized that the position was not just a job label or a convenient title. It was an office recognized by the association’s by-laws, filled directly by the board of directors, and attached to the association’s corporate governance structure. The Court distinguished corporate officers from ordinary employees by explaining that an office is created by the charter or by-laws of a corporation and the officer is elected by the directors or stockholders. An employee, by contrast, usually occupies no corporate office and is generally hired by the managing officer who determines compensation.

Why the NLRC Had No Jurisdiction

Because Guilas was appointed directly by the board and his salary was likewise set by the same board, the Court treated his non-reappointment as an intra-corporate matter. Under then applicable law, controversies involving the election or appointment of directors, trustees, officers, or managers of corporations were within the jurisdiction of the SEC, not the NLRC.

The Court rejected the argument that the case became a labor case merely because Guilas claimed illegal dismissal. A corporate officer’s dismissal is a corporate act and an intra-corporate controversy. That nature is not changed by the reason or wisdom behind the board’s action. The legal question was not simply whether the association complied with labor due process. The more basic question was whether the board’s act of not reappointing its own by-law officer was valid within the corporation’s internal governance framework.

Money Claims Do Not Automatically Create Labor Jurisdiction

The Court also addressed a common practical concern: what happens when the complaint includes unpaid salaries or compensation? Guilas argued that his money claims made the matter proper for the labor tribunals. The Court disagreed. Money claims do not automatically transform a corporate dispute into a labor case.

The Court drew from earlier rulings holding that claims which appear to involve salaries or compensation may still be part of a corporate controversy when they are closely tied to the person’s status as a stockholder, officer, or corporate appointee. In this case, the unpaid salary claim arose from and was intertwined with Guilas’s position as Administrator, a corporate office under the association’s by-laws. Because the compensation issue depended on the validity and consequences of his non-reappointment, it remained within the corporate dispute rather than becoming an independent labor claim.

What This Means for Condominium Associations and Corporations

For condominium corporations and associations, the ruling provides a useful governance lesson. Titles and by-law provisions matter. If a position is created by the by-laws and filled by the board, disputes over appointment, tenure, and removal may be treated differently from ordinary employment disputes. Associations should therefore review their by-laws carefully before taking action against administrators, superintendents, managers, or officers.

For corporate officers, the case is equally important. A person may receive compensation, maintain office hours, and perform administrative work, yet still be treated as a corporate officer for jurisdictional purposes. The right forum depends not only on the functions performed but also on how the position was created, who appointed the officer, and whether the dispute arises from corporate governance.

For litigants, the lesson is straightforward: before filing an illegal dismissal complaint, determine whether the position involved is an ordinary employment position or a corporate office. Filing in the wrong forum may cause delay, dismissal, and unnecessary expense. The forum issue should be analyzed at the start, not after years of litigation.

Practical Takeaway

Ongkingco teaches that corporate law can control even when a dispute looks like a labor case. The presence of salary, office hours, and administrative duties does not end the analysis. The decisive question is whether the person was appointed to a corporate office created by the charter or by-laws and whether the removal or non-reappointment was a board act. If so, the dispute is corporate in nature, and labor tribunals may have no authority to decide it.

Need Help With Officer Dismissal, NLRC, or Corporate Governance Disputes?

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, condominium associations, business owners, and executives on disputes involving corporate officers, employee classification, illegal dismissal claims, board authority, and intra-corporate controversies. If your case involves both labor and corporate law issues, early forum analysis can prevent costly procedural mistakes. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our litigation and corporate law team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *