Managers cannot be fired on suspicion alone. Loss of confidence requires proof and due process, while corporate officers are not personally liable absent bad faith.
Employers cannot dismiss even high-trust managers on suspicion alone: loss of confidence must rest on substantial evidence, and the employee must receive notice and a real chance to answer before termination. Just as importantly for business owners, corporate officers are not automatically personally liable for labor awards unless they acted with malice or bad faith.
The Practical Rule: Trust Is Not a Substitute for Evidence
The doctrine from Midas Touch Food Corporation is simple but powerful: an employer may invoke loss of confidence as a just cause for dismissal, but it cannot use the phrase as a shortcut for an unproven accusation. The employee’s position may involve discretion, money, operations, or access to company property; still, the employer must show a real, factual basis for the loss of trust. Bare suspicion, internal frustration, or hearsay gathered after the fact will not do.
This matters to both sides of a labor dispute. For employers, the ruling is a warning that management prerogative must be exercised through documented investigation and lawful procedure. For employees, especially managers and officers accused of disloyalty or misuse of company assets, the case confirms that security of tenure does not disappear merely because the employer says it has lost confidence.
Background: A Fast-Food Operations Manager Accused of Conflict of Interest
The dispute involved Iris Fe Isaac, who worked for Midas Touch Food Corporation, operator of several fast-food branches and a centralized commissary. She was promoted to Operations Manager and given authority over branch operations, commissary functions, personnel, and supplies. The company later terminated her services, accusing her of acts allegedly showing conflict of interest and breach of trust.
The accusations included alleged participation in a competing food venture with another employee, supposed use of company property, and alleged involvement in transactions benefiting a canteen operation. In Midas Touch Food Corporation v. NLRC (G.R. No. 111639, July 29, 1996), the Labor Arbiter initially dismissed the illegal dismissal complaint but awarded proportionate benefits. The NLRC reversed, found the dismissal illegal, ordered reinstatement, backwages, and proportionate thirteenth month pay, and the controversy reached the Court.
Why the Dismissal Failed
The Court sustained the NLRC. It emphasized two separate requirements for a valid dismissal: there must be a just or authorized cause, and the employer must observe procedural due process. Article 282 of the Labor Code, now renumbered, allowed dismissal for fraud or willful breach of trust, but that cause must be shown by evidence. The employer’s constitutional and statutory obligation to accord due process also remains, regardless of whether the employee is rank-and-file or managerial.
On procedure, the company failed the two-notice requirement. An employee must first be informed of the specific acts or omissions for which dismissal is sought and must then be given an opportunity to explain. Only after that process may the employer issue a second notice communicating the decision to dismiss. The letter sent to Isaac merely informed her that her services were terminated immediately. It did not operate as a prior notice of charges, did not invite her explanation, and did not create a meaningful chance to defend herself.
On substance, the Court found that the allegations against Isaac were not established by fair and impartial evidence. The employer relied on claims and affidavits that were not tested through proper presentation before the Labor Arbiter. The Court noted that affidavits are generally hearsay when the persons who executed them are not placed on the witness stand and made available for cross-examination. The company also failed to conduct a thorough investigation to determine who was actually liable for the allegedly irregular business dealings.
The Loss of Confidence Doctrine Has Limits
Loss of confidence is a recognized just cause, but the Court restated the controlling safeguards. First, it should not be simulated. Second, it should not be used as a subterfuge for an illegal or unjustified cause. Third, it may not be arbitrarily asserted in the face of overwhelming contrary evidence. Fourth, it must be genuine and not a mere afterthought designed to justify an earlier action taken in bad faith.
Those limits are especially important because loss of confidence can be tempting for employers to invoke when proof is incomplete. The doctrine accepts that employers need trust in employees who handle sensitive business functions, but it also prevents employers from converting suspicion into termination. Substantial evidence is not proof beyond reasonable doubt, but it still requires relevant evidence that a reasonable mind may accept as adequate to support the conclusion.
Corporate Officers Are Not Automatically Personally Liable
The ruling also provides a significant protection for corporate directors and officers. The NLRC itself recognized that the company, not the individual petitioners Wilson Chu and Ramon Luy, was the employer. The Court agreed that a corporate officer is not personally liable for the money claims of dismissed corporate employees merely because of office or participation in management.
Personal liability may attach only when the officer acts in bad faith or with malice, or when circumstances justify piercing the corporate veil. Section 31 of the Corporation Code, as discussed in the decision, makes directors, trustees, or officers solidarily liable only when they willfully and knowingly vote for or assent to patently unlawful corporate acts, are guilty of gross negligence or bad faith in directing corporate affairs, or acquire personal or pecuniary interest in conflict with their duty.
Because the record did not show that Chu and Luy acted with bad faith or malice, and because they were not Isaac’s employers in their personal capacities, only the corporation was held liable for the monetary awards.
What This Means for Employees and Employers
For employees accused of conflict of interest, misuse of property, or breach of trust, the ruling confirms that a termination letter is not enough. The employer must specify the charges before dismissal, allow the employee to respond, and support the decision with substantial evidence. A manager can still contest dismissal even when the employer claims that the position is confidential or trust-based.
For employers, the case is a compliance roadmap. Before dismissing an employee for loss of confidence, the company should issue a proper notice to explain, identify the acts complained of, allow a meaningful opportunity to answer, evaluate evidence from witnesses who can be presented and examined, and issue a separate decision notice. Internal belief is not a substitute for investigation. A hastily prepared record may convert a defensible management decision into an illegal dismissal award.
For corporate officers, the ruling draws a boundary between corporate liability and personal exposure. Officers should still act carefully and in good faith, but they are not insurers of every labor award against the corporation. Personal liability requires more than title, signature, or participation in corporate decision-making.
Need Help With Illegal Dismissal, Loss of Confidence, or Labor Claims?
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employers, HR teams, executives, and employees in illegal dismissal cases, NLRC proceedings, preventive suspension issues, loss of confidence disputes, and corporate officer liability questions. If your company is preparing a termination decision, or if you received a termination letter without a proper hearing or notice, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult a Makati-based litigation and labor law team.