Corporate presidents may sign court certifications and send lease demand letters within ordinary duties, allowing ejectment despite missing initial board papers.
A corporation may recover possession of its leased property even if its president, not the board itself, signed the demand letter and the court papers, so long as the act falls within the president’s usual authority or is later ratified by the board. For landlords, corporate officers, and tenants, the ruling is a practical warning: an ejectment case will not necessarily fail just because the corporation did not attach a board resolution at the very first step.
The Practical Rule: Corporate Authority Is Not Always a Technical Trap
Businesses often act through officers before a formal board paper is located, attached, or presented in court. In property disputes, this can become decisive. A tenant resisting eviction may argue that the demand to pay rentals and vacate was void because the corporate president had no board resolution authorizing him to send it. If that argument succeeds, an unlawful detainer case may be dismissed because a valid written demand is one of the requisites of ejectment.
In Colegio Medico-Farmaceutico de Filipinas, Inc. v. Lim, the Supreme Court rejected an overly technical approach. It recognized that while corporations generally act through their boards, a corporate president is presumed to have authority to act within the general objectives of the corporation and within the scope of ordinary duties, especially where the act involves managing corporate affairs, collecting receivables, and protecting corporate property.
Background: A School Lease, Unpaid Rentals, and a Disputed Demand Letter
Colegio Medico-Farmaceutico de Filipinas, Inc. owned a building in Sampaloc, Manila. It leased the premises to St. John Berchman School of Manila Foundation, with respondent Lily Lim later claiming rights over the lease. The corporation alleged that the lease had expired or been terminated, that rentals and utility bills remained unpaid, and that Lim continued occupying the premises despite demand.
The corporation’s president, Dr. Virgilio C. Del Castillo, sent a letter dated March 5, 2008 demanding payment of unpaid rentals and utility bills and requiring the occupant to vacate. The corporation later filed an ejectment case. The Metropolitan Trial Court dismissed the complaint, treating the demand letter as legally ineffective because there was supposedly no board authority shown for the president to send it. The Regional Trial Court reversed, but the Court of Appeals again dismissed the complaint on the theory that the absence of an attached board resolution was fatal. The Supreme Court reviewed the case in Colegio Medico-Farmaceutico de Filipinas, Inc. v. Lim (G.R. No. 212034, July 2, 2018).
The Supreme Court’s Ruling: The President Could Act for the Corporation
The Supreme Court granted the corporation’s petition and reinstated the RTC ruling, with modification on the amount of reasonable compensation. The Court held that the president of a corporation may sign the verification and certification of non-forum shopping even without a board resolution because the president is presumed to have sufficient knowledge to swear to the truth of the allegations in the complaint or petition.
The Court also held that the demand letter was valid. Although the general rule is that corporate powers are exercised by the board of directors or trustees, the Court applied the recognized exception that a corporate president may bind the corporation in acts within the scope of the president’s usual duties. Here, sending a demand letter to collect unpaid rentals and recover possession of corporate property was part of the ordinary management of the corporation’s affairs.
The corporation’s by-laws also supported that conclusion. The president had general supervision, control, and direction over the business and affairs of the Colegio, and had authority to execute contracts and perform duties incident to the office. The demand letter was therefore not an unauthorized act requiring dismissal of the ejectment case.
Unlawful Detainer: What a Landlord Must Still Prove
The decision did not eliminate the requirements for unlawful detainer. The Court repeated the essential elements: there must be a lease, the lessee’s right to possess must have expired or been terminated, possession must be withheld after that expiration or termination, there must be written demand to pay or comply with the lease and vacate, and the action must be filed within one year from the last demand.
On the facts found by the courts, the Supreme Court held that these requisites were present. There was a lease; the lease rights had been assigned to Lim; unpaid rentals constituted a ground for termination; possession continued despite termination; and the case was filed within one year from the demand letter. The only serious issue was whether the written demand was valid, and the Court answered yes.
Ratification Can Cure a Possible Defect
The ruling is also important because the Supreme Court stated that even assuming the president had acted beyond his authority, the later board resolution authorizing the filing of the case cured any possible defect. The later board action showed that the board agreed to, consented to, acquiesced in, or ratified the president’s earlier act of sending the demand letter.
This matters in litigation because corporate disputes often involve timing gaps between the officer’s act and the formal board documentation. The ruling does not mean board approvals are unnecessary as a matter of good governance. It means that courts should not automatically dismiss a case when the president’s act falls within ordinary corporate functions or is later ratified by the board.
Damages, Rentals, and Legal Interest
The Supreme Court also modified the monetary award. Instead of the P50,000.00 monthly reasonable compensation awarded by the RTC, the Court fixed the amount at P55,000.00 per month, consistent with the Contract of Lease. It also awarded legal interest on actual damages: 12% per annum from the date of extrajudicial demand on March 5, 2008 until June 30, 2013, and 6% per annum from July 1, 2013 until full satisfaction.
For property owners, this part of the ruling underscores the importance of clearly documenting rent, utility charges, and demand dates. The amount stated in the contract may control the reasonable compensation for continued use and occupancy, while the date of demand may affect the computation of interest.
What This Means for Corporate Landlords and Tenants
For corporate landlords, the decision provides a practical litigation safeguard. A demand letter signed by the president may be sufficient when it involves the ordinary business of collecting rentals and recovering corporate property. A corporation should still secure board authority, but failure to attach it at the outset is not always fatal.
For tenants, the ruling limits technical defenses based solely on internal corporate authorization. A tenant facing ejectment cannot assume that a demand letter is void merely because it was signed by the president without an attached board resolution. The better defense must address the lease term, payment history, validity of termination, sufficiency of demand, or compliance with the one-year filing period.
For corporate officers, the case reinforces the importance of by-laws and board practice. A president’s authority is strongest when the act is tied to ordinary management, when the by-laws support general supervision over corporate affairs, and when the board later confirms or ratifies the action.
Why the Doctrine Matters
The doctrine may be called the ordinary-course presidential authority rule. It recognizes that corporations must act through human officers and that the president’s usual management functions may include acts necessary to protect corporate assets. Courts should not convert every missing attachment or delayed board resolution into an automatic dismissal when the substance shows corporate authorization or ratification.
At the same time, the ruling is not a license for officers to ignore board authority. Extraordinary transactions, unusual obligations, or acts outside the corporation’s ordinary business may still require express board approval. The safer practice remains clear: pass the board resolution, identify the authorized officer, attach the authority when filing suit, and make sure all demand letters are properly addressed and served.
Need Help With Ejectment, Lease Enforcement, or Corporate Litigation?
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporate landlords, property owners, business tenants, and companies involved in ejectment, lease enforcement, collection, board authority, and civil litigation. If your company needs to recover possession of leased property, respond to a demand to vacate, or assess whether a corporate officer had authority to sue or send notices, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our litigation team.