A spouse who signed a notarized cohabitation affidavit failed to void the marriage or prove psychological incapacity under Philippine family law.

A spouse who signed a notarized affidavit of five-year cohabitation cannot later defeat the marriage by simply saying the affidavit was false, unread, or misunderstood. The ruling reinforces a practical doctrine for annulment and nullity cases: Philippine courts will preserve a marriage unless the party attacking it proves invalidity by clear, convincing, and credible evidence.

The Doctrine: The Cohabitation Affidavit Presumption

The central lesson of Laguda v. Manguardia-Laguda is that a notarized affidavit of cohabitation carries real legal weight. When parties marry without a marriage license under Article 34 of the Family Code, they must state under oath that they have lived together as husband and wife for at least five years and that they have no legal impediment to marry. Once that sworn statement is executed and notarized, the spouse who later challenges it bears a heavy burden.

That burden is not satisfied by regret, general denial, or the assertion that one signed documents without reading them. The Court treated the affidavit as a solemn legal act. A person who voluntarily signs a document is presumed to have read, understood, and accepted its contents. To defeat that presumption, the challenging spouse must present clear, convincing, and credible evidence that the affidavit was false, fraudulently prepared, or signed through deception or coercion.

Background: A Marriage Challenged Almost Two Decades Later

Edgardo and Johnna were married on November 12, 1998. Instead of obtaining a marriage license, they relied on the exemption for couples who had lived together as husband and wife for at least five years. They executed a joint affidavit of cohabitation, and their marriage was solemnized and registered. The couple later had two children.

In 2015, Edgardo filed a petition to declare the marriage void. He argued that he and Johnna could not have lived together for five years before the wedding because, according to him, they met only in the late 1990s and he had been assigned in Maguindanao as a member of the Armed Forces of the Philippines. He also claimed that he was pressured to marry and that he did not truly understand that one of the documents he signed was an affidavit of cohabitation. The case reached the Supreme Court after the trial court and the Court of Appeals rejected his petition (G.R. No. 279718, January 29, 2026).

Why the Court Refused to Void the Marriage

The Supreme Court denied the petition and affirmed the validity of the marriage. It emphasized that marriage is an inviolable social institution protected by the Constitution and by law. Because of that policy, every intendment favors the validity and preservation of marriage, not its dissolution.

On the marriage license issue, the Court found that Edgardo failed to overcome the legal effect of the notarized affidavit of cohabitation. He did not prove that the affidavit was fraudulently prepared, that he was coerced into signing it, or that he was deceived as to its contents. His statement that he did not read or understand the document was insufficient. The Court also noted inconsistencies in his own account of when he met Johnna, and his witness had no personal knowledge of the couple’s relationship before the marriage.

The Court further explained that the five-year cohabitation requirement under Article 34 does not demand daily physical proximity. What matters is continuity and exclusivity. Temporary separation caused by employment, military assignment, or similar circumstances does not automatically interrupt cohabitation if the relationship remains exclusive and the parties continue to live as husband and wife whenever circumstances allow. Johnna’s account that Edgardo regularly returned home supported the finding that their relationship could have remained continuous despite his military assignment.

Delay Matters When Attacking a Marriage

One of the most consequential points for ordinary litigants is the Court’s treatment of delay. Edgardo challenged the affidavit nearly two decades after the marriage and after the couple had built a family with two children. The Court treated that delay as a circumstance that weakened his claim. While delay alone may not validate an otherwise void marriage, it may strongly undermine a party’s credibility when the attack rests on alleged falsity of a sworn affidavit signed long ago.

For spouses considering a declaration of nullity case based on lack of a marriage license, the ruling is a warning: courts will ask for hard proof. Evidence may include reliable records, competent witnesses with personal knowledge, and circumstances clearly showing that the statutory requirements for the license exemption were absent. A bare claim that the affidavit was false will not be enough.

Psychological Incapacity Requires More Than Marital Conflict

Edgardo also argued that Johnna was psychologically incapacitated under Article 36 of the Family Code. He described her as deceitful, disrespectful, manipulative, and financially demanding. He alleged that she deceived him about a loan, communicated with him only when she needed money, and used harsh language against him.

The Court held that these allegations did not meet the legal standard for psychological incapacity. Following Tan-Andal, psychological incapacity must be rooted in the spouse’s personality structure, must exist at the time of marriage, must be grave, and must be incurable in the juridical sense. It is not the same as immaturity, incompatibility, nagging, quarrels, refusal, or difficulty in performing marital obligations.

The evidence showed, at most, a strained marriage marked by ordinary human failings. Edgardo’s witness knew Johnna only after the wedding and could recount only an isolated argument. That was not enough to prove a deep-rooted condition existing at the time of the marriage. Edgardo also failed to identify the specific essential marital obligations that Johnna was supposedly incapable of performing.

Practical Impact for Annulment and Nullity Cases

For spouses asking whether a marriage without a license is void, the answer after Laguda is more careful than a simple yes or no. A marriage celebrated without a license may still be valid if the parties properly invoked the Article 34 exemption through a sworn affidavit of five-year cohabitation. To defeat that marriage later, the challenger must prove the falsity of the affidavit with clear and convincing evidence.

For annulment and nullity clients, the ruling also underscores the need to distinguish legal incapacity from ordinary marital breakdown. Courts do not dissolve marriages merely because the relationship became painful, toxic, financially difficult, or emotionally hostile. Article 36 requires proof of a serious psychological condition that made the spouse truly incapable of assuming essential marital obligations from the beginning.

For lawyers and litigants, the decision highlights the importance of evidence planning before filing. A petition for declaration of nullity should not rely on conclusions. It must present a coherent factual theory, competent witnesses, documentary proof, and a clear connection between the facts and the specific legal ground invoked.

Talk to a Makati Family Law and Litigation Lawyer

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in annulment, declaration of nullity, family law disputes, property consequences of marriage, and related civil litigation. If you are considering challenging a marriage, defending its validity, or assessing whether psychological incapacity or lack of a marriage license applies to your situation, our litigation team can help evaluate the evidence before a case is filed.

For legal consultation and representation, visit MakatiLawFirm.com and contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco, a full-service law firm based in Makati City.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *