Blank ballots count as valid abstentions in SEBA elections, and dismissed employees must contest termination before the Labor Arbiter to vote.
A union can lose a certification election even when it receives more votes than the no-union option, if blank ballots and voter eligibility rules keep it from securing the required majority of valid votes cast. For employers, unions, and rank-and-file employees, the ruling confirms a strict certification-election doctrine: abstentions are valid ballots for computing majority, and a dismissed employee remains eligible to vote only if the dismissal was timely contested before the proper labor forum.
The Practical Doctrine: Certification Elections Require a True Double Majority
The ruling is best understood as a double-majority and valid-ballot doctrine in labor representation cases. A certification election is not merely a head-to-head contest between the union and the no-union choice. It is a statutory process for determining whether employees actually chose a sole and exclusive bargaining agent, or SEBA, by the majority required by labor law.
The Supreme Court emphasized that two separate thresholds matter. First, a majority of all eligible voters in the bargaining unit must cast their ballots for the certification election to be valid. Second, the winning union must obtain a majority of the valid votes cast. This distinction is critical because blank or unfilled ballots, now treated as abstentions under the applicable DOLE rules, are still counted in determining the number of valid votes cast. They are not negative votes, but they increase the total from which the required majority is computed.
Background: A One-Vote Union Lead Was Not Enough
The dispute arose from a certification election among regular rank-and-file employees at Mercury Drug Corporation’s distribution center in Libis, Quezon City. The union sought to be certified as the sole and exclusive bargaining agent of the employees. In the June 11, 2018 certification election, the union received 45 votes, while the no-union choice received 44 votes. Four ballots were treated as spoiled, and one ballot was segregated because it belonged to the union president, Bernabe Valencia Jr., who had been dismissed from employment shortly before the election.
The case, Mercury Drug Corporation (Distribution Center) Employees Union-FFW v. Mercury Drug Corporation (G.R. No. 263812), reached the Supreme Court after conflicting administrative and appellate rulings on whether Valencia’s segregated ballot should be opened and whether blank ballots should affect the majority threshold.
The union argued that Valencia should be allowed to vote because he had filed a notice of strike with the National Conciliation and Mediation Board after his dismissal. It also argued that two blank ballots should not be counted in computing the majority needed for SEBA certification. Mercury Drug opposed these positions, insisting that Valencia had not properly contested his dismissal before the forum with jurisdiction over termination disputes, and that abstentions had to be counted as valid ballots.
Why the Dismissed Union President Could Not Vote
The Court held that Valencia was not an eligible voter in the certification election. Under DOLE Department Order No. 40-03, a dismissed employee may remain qualified to vote only if, at the relevant time, the employee has contested the legality of the dismissal before a forum of appropriate jurisdiction.
For termination disputes, that forum is the Labor Arbiter in the Arbitration Branch of the NLRC. Article 224 of the Labor Code gives Labor Arbiters original and exclusive jurisdiction over termination disputes, unfair labor practice cases, and related labor claims within their statutory authority. Because Valencia’s dismissal arose from alleged violations of company rules and regulations, any challenge to that dismissal had to be brought before the Labor Arbiter.
The notice of strike filed with the NCMB did not satisfy this requirement. A notice of strike serves a different purpose: it notifies the NCMB that a union intends to strike due to alleged unfair labor practice or bargaining deadlock. It is not, by itself, the proper legal contest of an individual termination dispute. The Court also noted that dismissal for alleged violation of company rules does not automatically constitute unfair labor practice unless it has a proximate and causal connection to self-organization, collective bargaining, or the observance of a collective bargaining agreement.
Why Blank Ballots Counted Against Certification
The more consequential point for many labor elections is the treatment of blank ballots. The Court affirmed that blank or unfilled ballots are treated as abstentions under the amended DOLE rules. An abstention is a blank or unfilled ballot validly cast by an eligible voter. It is not a negative vote, but it is included in the count for determining a valid election.
The union’s proposed interpretation would have counted blank ballots for validating the election, but excluded them when computing whether the union received a majority of valid votes cast. The Court rejected that approach as unreasonable. Once a ballot is recognized as a valid expression of participation, logic and fairness require that it remain part of the denominator when determining whether any choice obtained the required majority.
On the numbers, the result was unavoidable. Excluding Valencia’s segregated ballot, the remaining valid ballots included 45 votes for the union, 44 votes for no union, and two abstentions. That produced 91 valid ballots. A union needed more than 45 votes to be certified. With only 45 votes, the union fell short. Even assuming Valencia’s ballot were counted for the union, the total valid ballots would rise to 92, making the required majority 47. The union would then have only 46 votes, still insufficient for SEBA certification.
Forum Shopping Issue: Disclosure Still Matters
The Court also addressed the union’s failure to disclose a related Court of Appeals case arising from the same certification-election dispute. The Court reiterated that parties must disclose similar or related pending actions in their certification against forum shopping. Although the omission did not appear to be willful, it still involved overlapping facts and issues, including Valencia’s eligibility to vote and the treatment of abstentions.
The Court ultimately proceeded to decide the case on the merits to settle the legal issues affecting the certification process. Still, the ruling is a warning to litigants: procedural certifications are not technical ornaments. In labor cases, as in civil and corporate disputes, failure to disclose related proceedings can jeopardize an otherwise substantive appeal.
What This Means for Employers, Unions, and Employees
For employers, the decision confirms that certification-election results should be reviewed not only by comparing votes for the union against votes against unionization, but also by checking the exact number of valid votes cast and the majority threshold. A union lead of one vote may still be legally insufficient if abstentions increase the denominator.
For unions, the ruling underscores the importance of election mathematics and timely legal action. If a dismissed officer or member is expected to vote, the dismissal must be contested in the proper forum before the relevant certification-election deadline. Filing the wrong pleading before the wrong office may not preserve voting eligibility.
For employees, the decision protects the integrity of their collective choice. A certification election is not designed simply to reward the side with the most votes in a close contest. It is designed to determine whether a legally sufficient majority of the bargaining unit’s valid votes supports representation by a particular union.
Labor Representation Disputes Require Precise Strategy
Certification elections often turn on details that appear procedural but determine the final legal outcome: voter eligibility, segregated ballots, abstentions, spoiled ballots, protest deadlines, and the correct computation of majority. Employers and unions should treat these issues as litigation-sensitive from the start, not only after an unfavorable tally.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employers, unions, business owners, and employees in labor disputes, certification-election controversies, NLRC proceedings, and Court of Appeals or Supreme Court labor litigation. For representation or legal strategy in labor relations and employment disputes, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.