First-level courts cannot issue hold departure orders in criminal cases; only RTCs had authority under the cited circular, leading to a judge’s reprimand.
A hold departure order in a criminal case is not valid merely because a judge signs it. Under the Supreme Court’s ruling in the Abalos hold departure order case, lower first-level courts such as Municipal Trial Courts in Cities have no authority to issue hold departure orders in criminal cases; that power was limited to Regional Trial Courts under the controlling Supreme Court circular. For accused persons, business owners facing bouncing check complaints, and litigants with travel needs, the lesson is immediate: the validity of a travel restraint depends not only on the case, but on the court that issued it.
Why This Ruling Matters to People Facing Criminal Complaints
Few court orders are as disruptive as a hold departure order. It can prevent a person from boarding an international flight, derail work travel, affect overseas employment, and create serious reputational and business consequences. For many individuals accused in criminal cases, particularly commercial disputes that have become criminal complaints such as bouncing check cases, the risk is not theoretical. A travel restriction may be requested or issued while the criminal case is still pending.
The Supreme Court’s resolution is important because it reminds litigants that the power to restrict travel is not a general power shared by all courts. It is a specific authority that must come from law, rule, or Supreme Court issuance. A judge’s good faith, or even the existence of a pending criminal case, does not cure the absence of jurisdictional authority to issue a hold departure order.
Background: A Bouncing Check Case Led to a Hold Departure Order
The case arose after Judge Felipe M. Abalos, then Acting Presiding Judge of the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Dapitan and Dipolog, issued an order dated November 20, 1998 directing the Bureau of Immigration to include a certain Fe Cagtan in the hold departure list. Fe Cagtan was an accused in a bouncing checks case pending before his court. The matter was later referred to the Court Administrator by the Justice Secretary, who cited a Supreme Court circular stating that hold departure orders may be issued only by Regional Trial Courts in criminal cases within their exclusive jurisdiction (A.M. No. 99-141-MTCC, November 25, 1999).
Judge Abalos explained that the issuance was an honest inadvertence. He said he was busy with his case docket, which may have caused confusion. The Court Administrator recommended that he be reprimanded and advised to keep abreast of court issuances.
The Supreme Court’s Holding: First-Level Courts Have No HDO Power in Criminal Cases
The Supreme Court held that the recommendation was well taken. It emphasized that Supreme Court Circular 39-97, dated June 19, 1997, limits the authority to issue hold departure orders to Regional Trial Courts in criminal cases within their exclusive jurisdiction.
The Court then applied the familiar interpretive rule that the express mention of one thing excludes others not mentioned. Because the circular mentioned only the Regional Trial Court, the Court concluded that courts lower than the RTC, including Metropolitan Trial Courts, Municipal Trial Courts, Municipal Trial Courts in Cities, and Municipal Circuit Trial Courts, have no authority to issue hold departure orders in criminal cases.
This point is the core doctrine of the ruling: when a Supreme Court circular grants HDO authority only to Regional Trial Courts, first-level courts cannot infer that they share the same power. Silence is not permission. In matters affecting the constitutional right to travel, the court must point to clear authority.
The Doctrine: Travel Restrictions Require the Correct Court
The most practical way to understand the ruling is this: the legality of a hold departure order is not determined only by whether there is a pending criminal case. It also depends on whether the issuing court had authority to issue that kind of order in that kind of case.
That matters especially in cases filed before first-level courts. Bouncing check cases, certain light offenses, and other criminal proceedings may be pending before lower courts. A complainant may feel that an accused might leave the country, and the court may be asked to prevent departure. But the Supreme Court made clear that a first-level court cannot simply issue an HDO because the case is pending before it. The proper source of authority must be observed.
For accused persons, this ruling provides a basis to question a travel restriction issued by the wrong court. For complainants, it is a warning to pursue remedies only through legally authorized channels. For judges and court personnel, it reinforces that even well-intentioned measures can become administrative violations when they exceed the court’s authority.
Judicial Accountability: Good Faith Is Not a Complete Excuse
The Supreme Court did not treat Judge Abalos’ explanation as a complete defense. While the Court did not impose a severe penalty, it found that the excuse contradicted the standard imposed by the Code of Judicial Conduct. Judges are required to be faithful to the law and to maintain professional competence. They must keep abreast of developments in law and jurisprudence.
The Court therefore reprimanded Judge Abalos with a warning that repetition of the same or similar acts would be dealt with more severely. The sanction is modest, but the principle is significant. Judicial mistakes about jurisdiction and authority can affect real liberties. A person may be stopped at the airport because of an order the issuing court had no power to make. That is why the Court treated the matter as one of judicial discipline, not merely harmless error.
Practical Impact for Accused Persons, Employers, and Business Owners
Anyone facing a criminal case who is concerned about travel should first identify the court where the case is pending and the nature of the order issued. If the order came from a first-level court, the Abalos ruling supports the position that the order may be vulnerable for lack of authority. This is especially relevant for people who discover their travel restriction only when arranging overseas work, business travel, family travel, or immigration plans.
Business owners and HR managers should also understand the limits of this remedy. A criminal complaint, by itself, does not automatically justify preventing someone from leaving the Philippines. The proper court and proper procedure matter. Employers or creditors who use criminal complaints as pressure in commercial disputes must be careful not to assume that every court can issue travel restraints.
The ruling also gives defense counsel a concrete procedural issue to examine. Instead of arguing only the merits of the criminal charge, counsel should review whether the hold departure order was issued by a court with authority. If not, the accused may have grounds to move for relief from the travel restriction and to prevent its continued enforcement.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Travel restrictions in criminal cases require urgent and careful legal action. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists individuals, business owners, and companies in criminal litigation, bouncing check cases, immigration-related court restrictions, motions to lift hold departure orders, and defense strategy for pending criminal proceedings. If you are facing a criminal case and need to travel, or if you discovered that a court order may affect your departure from the Philippines, consult our litigation team through MakatiLawFirm.com.