Landowners in inverse condemnation may demand provisional pay based on current BIR zonal value for national infrastructure takings in the Philippines.

Landowners whose property was already taken for a national infrastructure project may still demand provisional compensation based on current BIR zonal value when they file inverse condemnation after the Right-of-Way Act took effect. The inverse condemnation deposit rule prevents government agencies from benefiting from a past failure to promptly file expropriation and pay affected owners. This Philippine property dispute Supreme Court ruling confirms that the timing of the court action can determine whether compensation starts from assessed value or the generally higher zonal value.

Background: The Dispute

The case involved parcels of land in Tanauan City, Batangas owned by the spouses Manalo and the Pedrajas. In 1998, the predecessor of National Transmission Corporation constructed a 500-kilovolt transmission line traversing portions of their properties, but no expropriation case was filed at the time.

The landowners later filed an inverse condemnation complaint asking the court to determine compensation for the affected portions of their lots. They also moved to require TRANSCO to deposit provisional compensation under Republic Act No. 10752, based on current BIR zonal valuation rather than the lower assessed value under Rule 67 (G.R. No. 266921, January 22, 2024).

NATIONAL TRANSMISSION CORPORATIโ€ฆ

The Supreme Court’s Ruling

The Court denied TRANSCO’s petition and affirmed the rulings requiring application of Republic Act No. 10752. It held that the provisional deposit for the affected land should be equivalent to 100% of the value of the land based on the current relevant BIR zonal valuation, not merely the assessed value used under Rule 67.

The reason was both procedural and substantive. Although the physical taking occurred in 1998, the landowners’ claim for provisional compensation was brought to court only in 2020, when Republic Act No. 10752 was already the controlling law. The Court followed the Felisa doctrine, which recognized that inverse condemnation proceedings initiated after the effectivity of the right-of-way law are governed by that law.

The Court also distinguished cases where the government itself had filed expropriation before taking. Here, the owners sued because the government had already entered the land without first filing the proper expropriation case.

Key Legal Principles Established

This ruling confirms the inverse condemnation deposit rule: when a landowner files inverse condemnation after Republic Act No. 10752 has taken effect, provisional compensation for a national government infrastructure project is governed by that statute, even if the actual taking happened years earlier.

The decision also clarifies why inverse condemnation is different from ordinary expropriation. In ordinary expropriation, the government initiates the case before or in connection with taking property. In inverse condemnation, the owner sues because the government has already taken or burdened the property without proper court proceedings. That distinction affects which compensation rule applies.

Finally, the Court treated the amount of provisional compensation as a factual issue. Because the trial court’s factual findings were affirmed by the Court of Appeals, the Supreme Court would not reexamine the computation in a Rule 45 petition.

What This Means for Businesses and Individuals

Property owners should not assume that an old government taking is beyond meaningful recovery. If a transmission line, road, public utility facility, or other national infrastructure project occupies private land without a proper expropriation case, the owner may have a claim for inverse condemnation and provisional compensation under the current right-of-way framework.

Government agencies should treat old infrastructure encroachments as live legal risks. A project built decades ago without expropriation may still expose the agency to substantial provisional deposits if the landowner later sues under present law. Developers, buyers, lenders, and landholding companies should also conduct diligence on properties crossed by power lines or infrastructure easements.

Need a Makati Property Lawyer? Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Property owners who accept informal arrangements may lose leverage, while government agencies and private buyers may face unexpected exposure from unresolved right-of-way issues. The losing position in this case shows the financial consequence of assuming that an old taking will automatically be governed by older, lower valuation rules.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises clients in property litigation, expropriation, inverse condemnation, land valuation disputes, and infrastructure-related claims in the Philippines. Consult a Makati property lawyer through MakatiLawFirm.com or visit our Makati office for focused advice on Philippine property and real estate litigation.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *