A void land transfer may be challenged when the deed was not properly proven and the Register of Deeds annotation was unsigned, defeating prescription defenses.

A land title traceable to an unsigned Register of Deeds annotation may be declared void even decades later, especially when the alleged deed of sale was never properly offered in evidence and the original owner remained in possession through persons occupying the property with permission.

Why This Case Matters to Property Owners and Heirs

Land disputes often turn on documents that appear old, official, and difficult to challenge. This decision is significant because it reminds titleholders, heirs, buyers, and property managers that the face of the certificate of title still matters. A transfer annotation that lacks the signature of the Register of Deeds is not a harmless clerical detail. It can be treated as a serious defect going to the authenticity of the transfer itself.

For families dealing with inherited land, long-standing occupancy, or suspicious title transfers, the ruling provides an important caution: the mere existence of a later title does not automatically defeat the claim of the earlier registered owner. Courts must still examine whether the transfer was supported by competent evidence, whether the supposed deed was properly introduced at trial, and whether the registry entries complied with the requirements of land registration law.

Background: A Disputed Sale and a Cancelled Title

Adelfa Alcantara Asico and Annierose Alcantara Asico filed a complaint to nullify titles issued over a parcel of land in Himamaylan, Negros Occidental. Adelfa and her husband Roberto Asico had been registered owners under TCT No. T-139808. The title was later cancelled after an annotation referring to a deed of sale in favor of Ernesto See, resulting in the issuance of TCT No. T-139809 in Ernesto’s name and, later, a derivative title in the names of his heirs.

The petitioners claimed that Adelfa never signed any deed of sale, never appeared before a notary public for such sale, and never authorized the transfer of the property. They also pointed to a critical defect: the annotation on the cancelled title, Entry No. 317077, was not signed by the Register of Deeds. The trial court dismissed the complaint through a demurrer to evidence, and the Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the action had prescribed and that the petitioners had failed to prove fraud. The case reached the Supreme Court in Asico v. Heirs of See (G.R. No. 271635, August 27, 2025).

The Doctrine: A Document Attached to a Pleading Is Not Automatically Evidence

The Court rejected the Court of Appeals’ reliance on the alleged deed of sale attached to the respondents’ answer. The deed was never formally offered in evidence, was not identified by testimony, and was not marked or admitted as an exhibit. Under the Rules on Evidence, a court shall consider no evidence that has not been formally offered.

This point is crucial in property litigation. A party cannot simply attach a deed to a pleading and expect the court to treat it as proof of ownership. If the defense rests on a deed of sale, the party relying on it must properly authenticate it, identify it through testimony, and formally offer it in evidence. Because the respondents chose to file a demurrer to evidence instead of presenting their own evidence, the alleged deed of sale was not given probative value.

Unsigned Register of Deeds Annotations Are Not Presumed Regular

The Court also held that the unsigned annotation could not enjoy the presumption of regularity. The annotation was the registry entry that supposedly explained why Adelfa’s title was cancelled and why a new title was issued in Ernesto’s name. But because it did not bear the signature of the Register of Deeds, it was irregular on its face.

By analogy to prior doctrine on unsigned certificates of title, the Court treated the unsigned memorandum as spurious. The signature of the Register of Deeds is not a mere formality when the entry is relied upon to justify the cancellation of an owner’s title and the issuance of a new one. Without that signature, the entry fails to carry the usual presumption that official duties were regularly performed.

Why the Action Did Not Prescribe

The Court also rejected the conclusion that the complaint was barred because it was filed around 30 years after the questioned transfer. The petitioners argued that the supposed sale was inexistent, and an action to declare the inexistence of a contract does not prescribe under Article 1410 of the Civil Code.

Even assuming the case were treated as one for reconveyance based on implied or constructive trust, the Court recognized the exception where the claimant remains in possession of the property. Here, the occupants of the land were not strangers holding against Adelfa. They reported to her when the heirs of Ernesto See allegedly bothered them, supporting the conclusion that they occupied the property with her consent and that possession remained with the petitioners through them.

The Demurrer Backfired

The procedural lesson is equally important. A demurrer to evidence is a calculated litigation risk. When defendants file it, they argue that the plaintiff’s evidence is legally insufficient and ask for dismissal without presenting their own case. If the demurrer is granted but later reversed on appeal, the defendants are deemed to have waived the right to present evidence.

That is what happened here. Because the demurrer was ultimately found improper, the respondents could no longer present evidence to prove the alleged sale, authenticate the disputed deed, or explain the unsigned registry entry. The petitioners’ evidence stood uncontested.

Practical Impact for Landowners, Buyers, and Heirs

For landowners, the ruling underscores the importance of examining not only the current title, but also the chain of title and the annotations that caused prior cancellations. If the transfer entry is unsigned, inconsistent, or unsupported by a properly registered instrument, the later title may be vulnerable.

For buyers and lenders, due diligence should go beyond confirming that a title exists. The history of cancellation, the deed supporting the transfer, the notarial details, and the Register of Deeds entries should be checked carefully. A title derived from a void or fraudulent transfer may itself be declared void, even if it appears clean at first glance.

For heirs, this decision is a reminder that inherited titles may carry the defects of the predecessor’s title. If the predecessor acquired the property through a transfer unsupported by competent evidence or founded on a spurious registry entry, the heirs may not be able to rely on the later title to defeat the original owner.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises clients in land title disputes, cancellation of title cases, reconveyance actions, adverse claims, estate-related property conflicts, and litigation involving forged or irregular deeds of sale. If your property title, inherited land, or registered deed is being challenged, or if you discovered an irregular annotation in the Register of Deeds, our litigation team can help assess the chain of title and identify the proper court remedy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our property litigation lawyers in Makati City.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *