Pre-need plan claims belong to the Insurance Commission, but the Court may resolve long-litigated disputes and enforce tuition guarantees despite ambiguous maturity dates.

Pre-need planholders seeking payment, reimbursement, or enforcement of educational plan benefits must ordinarily file their claims with the Insurance Commission, not the regular courts, because claims involving pre-need plans fall within the Commission’s primary and exclusive jurisdiction. But when a case has already been fully tried and litigated for years, the Supreme Court may still decide the merits to avoid wasteful duplication and finally resolve what the planholder is owed.

Why This Case Matters to Pre-Need Planholders and Providers

The ruling is important for anyone holding an old educational plan, memorial plan, pension plan, or other pre-need product. Many disputes arise when a plan provider pays only a limited amount and the planholder insists that the contract guaranteed full benefits despite later price increases. The first practical lesson is jurisdictional: even if the dispute sounds like a civil case for specific performance or breach of contract, the claim may still belong before the Insurance Commission if the relief sought is payment under a pre-need plan.

The second lesson is contractual. A pre-need company cannot simply rely on a date printed on the face of the plan if the full terms of the policy show that a different maturity date applies after transfer of the plan or change of scholar. Where the wording is ambiguous, courts will construe the contract against the company that prepared it.

Background: A Transferred Educational Plan and a Dispute Over Tuition Coverage

Charmel Kintanar acquired an educational pre-need plan from a friend who bought it in 1990. The plan had a stated maturity date of August 2, 2006, a gross price of PHP 12,820.00, and installment payments of PHP 461.00. After the transfer, Kintanar continued paying until the plan was fully paid.

In 2010, Kintanar demanded that Eternal Education Plans, Inc. cover the full amount of her daughter’s college tuition. The company paid only the rate applicable to non-exclusive schools as of 2006, the maturity date written on the face of the plan. Kintanar then filed a complaint for specific performance before the Regional Trial Court in Makati City. The RTC dismissed the complaint on the merits, while the Court of Appeals later ruled that the RTC had no jurisdiction because the matter belonged to the Insurance Commission. The Supreme Court reviewed the dispute in Eternal Education Plans, Inc. v. Kintanar (G.R. No. 262112, May 19, 2025).

The Jurisdiction Rule: Pre-Need Claims Belong to the Insurance Commission

The Supreme Court held that a demand for full payment or reimbursement under an educational pre-need plan is a claim involving a pre-need plan. Under Section 55 of the Pre-need Code, the Insurance Commission has the primary and exclusive power to adjudicate such claims.

The plan provider argued that the case was really one for specific performance, which regular courts may hear. The Court rejected that framing. Although the complaint used the language of specific performance, the performance sought was payment of money allegedly due under the pre-need plan. In substance, it was a pre-need claim.

The Court also rejected the argument that Section 59 of the Pre-need Code preserved the jurisdiction of regular courts over the same kind of dispute. Section 59 states that rights and remedies under the Pre-need Code are in addition to other rights and remedies under existing laws. But the Court harmonized that provision with Section 55 by explaining that other remedies remain available only when they do not displace the Commission’s primary and exclusive jurisdiction over claims involving pre-need plans.

Damages and Attorney’s Fees Can Also Be Heard by the Insurance Commission

A key practical point is that the Insurance Commission’s jurisdiction is not defeated just because the claimant also asks for moral damages, exemplary damages, or attorney’s fees. The Supreme Court applied the principle that administrative agencies exercising quasi-judicial functions may resolve incidental claims connected with the principal controversy within their specialized jurisdiction.

This avoids split jurisdiction. A planholder need not file one case before the Insurance Commission for the benefits and another case in court for related damages. When the damages are incidental to the pre-need claim, the Commission may address them as part of the dispute.

Judicial Economy: Why the Supreme Court Still Decided the Merits

Ordinarily, because the RTC had no jurisdiction, its decision would have no legal effect and the complaint would have to be refiled before the Insurance Commission. That was the path taken by the Court of Appeals. However, the Supreme Court recognized that the parties had already been litigating since 2010. The record had been elevated, the evidence had been presented, and the issues were fully ventilated.

Instead of forcing the parties to start over before the Insurance Commission and possibly return through another appeal years later, the Court invoked judicial economy. It decided the merits to avoid duplication of effort, minimize delay, and bring finality to a dispute involving a relatively modest amount compared with the cost of further litigation.

The Contract Rule: Ambiguities in Pre-Need Plans Are Construed Against the Provider

On the merits, the Court ruled for Kintanar on the tuition balance. The educational plan contained an acceptance and guarantee clause under which the company guaranteed payment of college tuition and standard school fees irrespective of future cost. The provider insisted that liability should be limited to the 2006 prevailing rate because that was the date written on the face of the plan.

The Supreme Court disagreed. Kintanar was a transferee of the plan and had designated her daughter as the new scholar. The plan’s own provisions allowed a change of scholar and provided rules for determining maturity. Since Kintanar’s daughter was below 11 years old when the plan was transferred and designated for her benefit, the applicable maturity date was when she became eligible to enter college, enrolled in a post-high school vocational course, or reached her 17th birthday, whichever came first. She turned 17 on July 8, 2010, which the Court treated as the relevant maturity date.

The Court held that this was not a deferred availment requiring written approval. The deferred availment clause applied when a sponsor sought to delay use of benefits for reasons such as illness. Here, the later date arose from the transfer of the plan and designation of a new scholar, not from a request to postpone benefits.

Because the written maturity date on the face of the plan conflicted with the policy provisions governing a new scholar, the Court found an ambiguity. Since pre-need and insurance-type contracts are contracts of adhesion prepared by the provider, any ambiguity must be construed against the provider and in favor of the planholder.

What the Planholder Recovered

The Court found that Kintanar proved the school fees through assessments issued by the University of San Carlos. Those assessments showed that the fees had become due, which was enough under the plan’s guarantee. The Court also noted that the assessments spanning 2010 to 2013 showed no unpaid balance for the previous semester, supporting the conclusion that the fees had been paid, partly by the provider and partly by Kintanar.

The total college education fees amounted to PHP 263,550.00. Eternal Education Plans had paid PHP 111,016.08, while Kintanar paid PHP 192,067.45. The Supreme Court ordered the company to pay Kintanar PHP 192,067.45, with legal interest of 6% per annum from finality of the decision until full payment.

Why Moral Damages, Exemplary Damages, and Attorney’s Fees Were Denied

The Court did not treat every breach of a pre-need plan as bad faith. Although the company was wrong, the Court found no evidence that its refusal to pay the full amount was wanton, malicious, oppressive, reckless, or in bad faith. The breach appeared to have arisen from a mistaken interpretation of the maturity date and the extent of the company’s obligation.

Because moral damages were not justified, exemplary damages were likewise denied. The Court also found no basis to award attorney’s fees under Article 2208 of the Civil Code.

Practical Impact for Clients

For planholders, the ruling confirms that educational pre-need guarantees may still be enforced even when the provider relies on restrictive interpretations of maturity dates or benefit rates. Planholders should examine the entire contract, especially provisions on transfer, change of scholar, maturity, deferred availment, and guarantee of benefits.

For pre-need companies, the ruling is a reminder that jurisdictional objections should be raised consistently and that ambiguous contract terms may be construed against the company. Providers should also be cautious in limiting payouts based on printed dates when other clauses may adjust maturity or benefit entitlement.

For litigants generally, the decision shows that filing in the wrong forum can derail a case. Claims involving pre-need plans should usually begin before the Insurance Commission. However, when the record is complete and remand would only prolong the controversy, the Supreme Court may apply judicial economy to finally resolve the dispute.

Need Help With a Pre-Need, Insurance, or Contract Dispute?

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in pre-need, insurance, contract enforcement, civil litigation, and regulatory disputes before courts and administrative agencies. If you are a planholder seeking benefits, a company responding to claims, or a business facing a jurisdictional issue, our litigation team can help assess the proper forum, available remedies, evidentiary requirements, and settlement or litigation strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our lawyers.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *