Government lawyers need written authority from the proper department head before notarizing documents or doing private legal work while in public service.
Government lawyers who want to notarize documents or perform any private legal work cannot rely on office practice, verbal permission, or approval from an immediate superior. The controlling rule is written authority from the proper department head, and without it, even a duly commissioned notary public may be administratively sanctioned for unauthorized private practice.
Why This Ruling Matters to Clients and Public Officers
Many government lawyers, accountants, engineers, and other licensed professionals assume that professional work done after office hours, or work done to help the public, is harmless if their immediate supervisor knows about it. Abella v. Cruzabra is a reminder that public office is governed by a stricter rule. When a government employee’s outside professional activity is regulated by law or civil service rules, informal approval is not enough.
The case is especially important for notarial practice. In ordinary commercial life, notarization is treated as a routine requirement for deeds, affidavits, loan documents, real estate papers, corporate documents, and government submissions. But for a lawyer employed in government, notarizing documents is not merely a clerical function. It is part of the practice of law. Because of that, it may fall within the prohibition against private practice unless properly authorized.
Background: A Deputy Register of Deeds Served as Notary Public
The complainant charged Atty. Asteria E. Cruzabra with violating Canon 1 of the Code of Professional Responsibility and Section 7(b)(2) of Republic Act No. 6713, the Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees. Cruzabra had been admitted to the Philippine Bar in 1986 and later became Deputy Register of Deeds of General Santos City. While holding that government post, she applied for and obtained a commission as notary public on February 29, 1988.
The complaint alleged that she did so without prior authority from the Secretary of the Department of Justice, and that she notarized thousands of documents. Cruzabra admitted that she served as a notary public from February 29, 1988 to December 31, 1989, but maintained that she had been authorized by her superior, the Register of Deeds. She also argued that her notarial work complemented her official functions because registrants could have documents notarized immediately, and she claimed she did not charge fees for documents required by the office to be under oath. The case reached the Supreme Court as an administrative matter against a lawyer (A.C. No. 5688).
The Supreme Court’s Rule: Permission Must Come From the Department Head
The Court held that Cruzabra engaged in notarial practice without the required written authority from the Secretary of the Department of Justice. Section 7(b)(2) of Republic Act No. 6713 prohibits public officials and employees from engaging in the private practice of their profession during incumbency unless authorized by the Constitution or law, and provided the practice will not conflict or tend to conflict with their official functions.
The Court also relied on Memorandum Circular No. 17 of the Executive Department, which allows government employees to engage directly in the private practice of their profession only with written permission from the department head. For employees in the Department of Justice, the relevant approving authority was not the immediate superior or the Register of Deeds. It was the Secretary of Justice.
This distinction was decisive. Even assuming the Register of Deeds had allowed Cruzabra to apply as notary public, that official was not the head of the department. The Court also noted that Cruzabra failed to present proof of written permission. Her reliance on alleged superior approval therefore could not cure the defect.
Notarial Practice Is Treated as Private Practice of Law
The ruling reinforces a practical point often overlooked by government lawyers: notarization is within the ambit of legal practice. A lawyer may be commissioned by a court as notary public, but that commission does not automatically override civil service restrictions or the statutory limits imposed on public officers.
The Court cited prior rulings involving lawyers in government service who performed notarial or private legal work without proper written authority. In those cases, the Court treated the required approval from the government office as separate from the notarial commission issued by the court. In other words, a notarial commission answers the question of whether the lawyer may act as a notary under notarial rules. It does not answer the separate question of whether a government lawyer may engage in that activity while holding public office.
Good Faith and Public Service Did Not Excuse the Violation
Cruzabra argued that she acted in good faith, relied on her superior, and had no corrupt motive. She also presented the work as a service to the public. The Court was not persuaded. It emphasized that Memorandum Circular No. 17 had already been issued in 1986, before Cruzabra filed her petition for commission as notary public in 1988. She therefore could not successfully claim ignorance or good faith as a complete defense.
For ordinary clients, this part of the ruling has a direct lesson. A professional license and a government position can create overlapping duties. A public officer cannot simply say that the outside work was useful, convenient, or unpaid. The legal question is whether the outside professional activity was authorized by the correct authority and whether it conflicted, or tended to conflict, with official functions.
The Penalty: Reprimand, But With a Warning
The Supreme Court found Cruzabra guilty of engaging in notarial practice without written authority from the Secretary of Justice. However, it imposed only a reprimand. The Court explained that under the Uniform Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service, unauthorized private practice of profession is classified as a light offense punishable by reprimand.
This does not mean the violation was trivial. The warning attached to the penalty matters. Cruzabra was expressly warned that repetition of the same or similar act would merit a more severe sanction. For government professionals, a first offense may be treated as light under the applicable civil service rules, but repeated or aggravated conduct can expose the officer to harsher administrative consequences.
Practical Impact for Government Employees and Those Dealing With Them
For government lawyers, the safest rule is simple: before accepting any notarial commission, private legal engagement, consultancy, or professional work outside government service, secure written authority from the proper department head. Approval from an immediate supervisor, office head, or colleague may not be enough unless that person is legally authorized to grant the permission required by law.
For private clients, the ruling is also a reminder to be careful when relying on notarized documents involving public officers. The validity of the notarization may raise separate questions from the administrative liability of the lawyer, but unauthorized notarial practice can still create complications, especially in disputes involving real estate, public registries, affidavits, and corporate documentation.
For HR and compliance officers in government-related entities, this decision supports the need for written policies on outside employment, consultancy, professional practice, and notarization. Agencies should make clear who may approve outside professional activity, what documents are required, and whether the activity may create a conflict with official duties.
Legal Assistance for Professional Responsibility, Government Ethics, and Document Disputes
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises clients on professional responsibility, administrative liability, notarization issues, civil litigation, and disputes involving public documents, property records, and government-regulated transactions. If you are facing a complaint involving unauthorized practice, defective notarization, public officer accountability, or a dispute over notarized documents, our Makati-based litigation team can help assess the risks and prepare a practical legal strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with Ablola, Saribong & Gueco.