Tax treaty refunds require proof that royalty payments meet the most favored nation clause; a BIR ruling alone cannot secure the lower rate.
The Most Favored Nation Proof Rule makes clear that a taxpayer claiming a lower treaty tax rate cannot rely on a favorable BIR ruling alone; it must prove that the same kind of income was taxed under similar tax circumstances in the relevant treaty states. For companies paying cross-border royalties, the practical consequence is serious: a refund claim may fail even when the Bureau of Internal Revenue previously confirmed the preferential rate.
Background: The Dispute
Cargill Philippines, Inc., a domestic corporation engaged in commodity trading and the manufacture of animal feeds and coconut oil, entered into an intellectual property license agreement with CAN Technologies, Inc., a United States company. Cargill paid royalties for the right to use CAN Technologies’ patents, technology, and copyrights in the Philippines, and withheld final taxes at the 15% rate.
Cargill later sought a refund or tax credit of overpaid withholding taxes, arguing that the royalties should have been taxed at 10% under the most favored nation clause of the RP-US Tax Treaty, in relation to the RP-Czech Tax Treaty. The BIR had issued a ruling confirming the 10% rate, but the Court of Tax Appeals denied the refund, and the dispute reached the Supreme Court in Cargill Philippines, Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (G.R. No. 203346, September 9, 2020).
The Supreme Court’s Ruling
The Supreme Court denied Cargill’s petition and sustained the denial of the refund. It held that two requirements must be satisfied before a taxpayer may invoke the most favored nation clause in the RP-US Tax Treaty. First, the royalties paid to the United States resident and the royalties paid to the third-state resident must be of the same kind. Second, the tax consequences must arise under similar circumstances, meaning the mechanisms used to eliminate or mitigate double taxation must be the same.
The Court accepted that the first requirement was met because the payments involved royalties for the use of patents, technology, and copyrights. The problem was the second requirement. Cargill failed to prove that the tax relief mechanism under United States law and the RP-US Tax Treaty was sufficiently similar to the tax relief mechanism under the RP-Czech Tax Treaty. Since the RP-US Tax Treaty referred to limitations under United States domestic law, Cargill had to present the relevant United States law. Its failure to do so was fatal.
The Court also held that the Court of Tax Appeals had jurisdiction to review and nullify the BIR ruling relied upon by Cargill. The CTA was not bound by the BIR’s treaty interpretation when that interpretation was found to be legally erroneous.
Key Legal Principles Established
The Most Favored Nation Proof Rule has two parts. A taxpayer must prove similarity in subject matter and similarity in tax circumstances. It is not enough to show that another treaty provides a lower rate. The taxpayer must also show that the residence state grants comparable relief from double taxation, whether through exemption, credit, matching credit, tax sparing, or another treaty-based mechanism.
The ruling also confirms the CTA’s broad power in tax cases. When a refund or assessment dispute depends on the validity of a BIR ruling, revenue issuance, or administrative interpretation, the CTA may examine whether that ruling correctly applies the law. A taxpayer cannot shield a refund claim from judicial review merely by invoking a favorable BIR ruling.
Finally, the Court rejected Cargill’s attempt to use processual presumption to avoid proving United States law. In tax treaty refund litigation, foreign law may be central evidence. When the taxpayer’s claim depends on how a foreign jurisdiction treats the same income, the taxpayer must prove that law rather than ask the court to presume it.
What This Means for Businesses and Individuals
Businesses making royalty, licensing, technology, trademark, software, or intellectual property payments to foreign affiliates should treat tax treaty relief as an evidentiary claim, not a mere filing position. A BIR ruling may help, but it will not replace proof of treaty eligibility if the matter reaches the CTA.
For finance teams and tax managers, this decision means refund claims must be built before payment and withholding positions are taken. Companies should preserve the license agreement, proof of beneficial ownership, residency documents, treaty provisions, foreign tax rules, and expert-supported explanations of how double taxation is relieved in the residence state.
For multinational groups, the ruling is a warning against assuming that most favored nation clauses automatically import the lowest rate from another treaty. The taxpayer must prove that the comparison is legally and economically fair under the treaty language.
Need a Philippine Tax Lawyer? Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
A company that relies on an unsupported treaty position may lose a refund claim, face deficiency tax exposure, or be forced to defend a withholding position years after the transaction. Cross-border royalty payments, intellectual property licensing, and treaty-based tax refunds require careful documentation from the start.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses in tax disputes, refund claims, BIR controversies, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation involving treaty relief and withholding taxes. Speak with a Philippine tax lawyer at our Makati office or visit MakatiLawFirm.com for guidance on tax litigation and treaty-based refund claims.