Customs Officials Cannot Quietly Compromise Tax Credit Scam Cases Without Required Approval

The Supreme Court upheld dismissal of a customs official for compromising a tax credit scam collection case without required approvals and waiving recoverable public funds. Revenue officers who settle government tax or customs claims without the approvals required by law may be dismissed for grave misconduct, especially where the compromise waives penalties, surcharges, interest, litigation […]

RMC No. 83-2007: BIR Service Records for Retirement or Separation Require National Office and Ombudsman Clearances

RMC No. 83-2007 requires National Office and Ombudsman clearances before BIR service records are issued for retirement or separation purposes. BIR employees, retirees, and separating personnel cannot obtain service records for retirement or separation purposes unless the required National Office Clearance and Ombudsman Clearance are secured. RMC No. 83-2007 matters because service records are essential […]

Court Employees Can Be Disciplined for Private Conduct That Undermines Public Trust

Court employees may be suspended for private immoral conduct that undermines public trust, even without direct proof of sexual relations. Judiciary employees may be disciplined not only for misconduct committed inside the courthouse, but also for private conduct that creates a public appearance of impropriety and damages confidence in the courts. In Licardo, the Supreme […]

National Government Instrumentality Tax Doctrine: PFDA and Real Property Taxes

The SC ruled that PFDA, as a national government instrumentality, pays real property taxes only on leased portions to private entities, while IFPC remains exempt as public dominion. National government instrumentalities are generally exempt from local taxation, but this exemption does not shield them from real property taxes on portions leased to private parties. The […]

Universal Charge Police Power Rule: Why EPIRA Fees Survived

Regulatory charges are not taxes when police power is the main purpose; EPIRA’s Universal Charge and ERC authority were upheld. The Universal Charge Police Power Rule protects energy-sector regulatory charges from being struck down as unconstitutional taxes when their primary purpose is regulation, not revenue generation. For electricity consumers, utilities, and power-sector participants, the practical […]

Water Districts Cannot Block Competitors by Invoking Exclusive Service Rights

Water districts cannot use exclusive franchise rights to block qualified competitors because public utility authorizations cannot be exclusive under the Constitution. Public utility operators cannot rely on an exclusive franchise to keep competitors out when the Constitution itself prohibits exclusive public utility authorizations. For water districts, this means that service areas are not automatic monopolies: […]

When Workplace Feuds Reach the Court: Substantial Evidence Still Controls Administrative Discipline

Administrative complaints survive withdrawal, but discipline still requires substantial evidence. Unfounded workplace accusations may expose supervisors to sanctions. A court employee, government worker, or professional facing an administrative complaint cannot be punished on suspicion, office gossip, or an unresolved workplace feud alone. Even when public service demands courtesy, restraint, and professionalism, liability still requires substantial […]

State Universities Cannot Convert Academic Freedom Into Employee Allowance Authority

State universities cannot use academic freedom or fiscal powers to grant unauthorized allowances, but good-faith employee recipients may avoid refund. State universities and colleges may enjoy academic freedom and limited fiscal autonomy, but those powers do not automatically allow them to create employee allowances outside the Salary Standardization Law. The ruling teaches a practical rule […]

Court Staff Misconduct: When Shouting and Retaliation Inside Court Become Disciplinary Offenses

Court employees may be fined for shouting, cursing, or retaliatory work assignments inside court premises because such acts erode trust in the judiciary. Litigants and court users are entitled to a courthouse where public business is handled with civility, restraint, and basic professionalism. In De Vera v. Rimando, the Supreme Court made clear that even […]