Dismissal From Public Office Does Not Always Mean Total Loss of Retirement Benefits

Dismissal from public office may still allow heirs to claim accrued leave credits and part of retirement benefits when rules permit partial forfeiture. A dismissed judge or public officer may still leave behind recoverable accrued leave credits and a portion of retirement benefits when the governing disciplinary rules allow partial forfeiture and the equities of […]

Court Employees Can Be Suspended for Abusive Conduct Inside the Courthouse

Court personnel may be suspended for abusive or violent courthouse conduct that undermines public trust, even when the incident begins as an office dispute. People who deal with the courts are entitled to more than correct orders and timely hearings; they are entitled to be treated with dignity by every court employee, from the judge […]

Judges Who Miss the 90-Day Decision Deadline Can Still Be Fined After Retirement

Judges who fail to decide submitted cases within the 90-day period may be fined for gross inefficiency, even after retirement. Courts do not treat delayed decisions as a mere internal scheduling problem: a judge who fails to decide submitted cases within the constitutional period may be held administratively liable and fined, even when the audit […]

Drinking on Duty Can Cost Court Employees Six Months’ Pay β€” But Judges Cannot Suspend Staff on Their Own

Court employees may face six-month suspension for drinking on duty and defying discipline, but judges must refer preventive suspension to the Supreme Court. Court employees who drink during office hours, sleep at work, or openly defy lawful workplace discipline may be suspended even for a first offense; but a judge who wants to preventively suspend […]

When a Sheriff Refuses to Enforce a Judgment, Delay Becomes Misconduct

Sheriffs must promptly enforce writs of execution. The Court held that heavy workload does not excuse years of delay and imposed administrative liability. A winning party does not truly win until the judgment is enforced. In Aquino v. Lavadia, the Supreme Court made clear that a sheriff cannot let writs of execution sit unimplemented for […]

A Licensed Firearm Is Not a License to Intimidate Co-Workers

A firearm permit does not excuse workplace intimidation. The Court fined a court employee for misconduct but dismissed claims against another for lack of proof. Public employees who bring firearms into the workplace may still face administrative discipline when the weapon is used, displayed, or carried in a manner that intimidates co-workers. A permit to […]

Courts Cannot Use Replevin to Pull Seized Forest Products Away From DENR Control

DENR has primary jurisdiction over seized forest products, making replevin improper when courts would preempt environmental enforcement and agency custody. Businesses, vessel owners, consignees, and property claimants cannot simply run to court for replevin when forest products or their conveyances have been seized by environmental authorities. Where the controversy concerns timber or forest products allegedly […]

When a Public Officer Is Wrongly Dismissed, Back Pay May Still Be Due

A wrongly dismissed court officer may recover back pay and benefits when dismissal is reduced to a fine, despite negligence in supervising sheriff’s sale proceeds. A government employee who is thrown out of office under an excessive or legally mistaken penalty may be entitled to reinstatement, back salaries, and other economic benefits even if the […]

A Bad Court Decision Is Usually Appealed, Not Turned Into a Case Against the Judge

Judicial error is generally corrected by appeal, not discipline. A judge is liable only upon proof of bad faith, corruption, fraud, or deliberate injustice. Parties who believe a judge made a wrong decision generally must use the ordinary judicial remedies first, such as reconsideration or appeal, instead of immediately filing an administrative case against the […]