After Proclamation, Election Challenges Must Move to the Right Case

Pre-proclamation cases cannot continue after proclamation; losing candidates must use election protest or quo warranto to challenge the result. A candidate who questions the validity of an election cannot keep a pre-proclamation case alive after the winner has already been proclaimed. Once proclamation takes place, the dispute generally shifts to an election protest or quo […]

Court Delays Can Become Personal Liability for Court Personnel

Court personnel and supervisors may be fined for delayed docketing and raffle of a criminal case, confirming accountability for courthouse delays. When a criminal case is delayed before it even reaches the raffle stage, responsibility may fall not only on the person directly holding the docket stamp or records, but also on the supervising court […]

Judges Cannot Plead Ignorance When They Act Beyond Their Jurisdiction

Judges may be suspended for taking action outside clear statutory jurisdiction; ignorance or reliance on outdated law is no defense to judicial misconduct. Judges who take action in cases plainly outside their jurisdiction may be administratively disciplined, even if they claim they merely overlooked the law. For litigants, taxpayers, complainants, and businesses dealing with court […]

Court Delay Is Judicial Misconduct: The 90-Day Duty That Protects Every Litigant

Judges must decide submitted matters within the legal period. Unexplained delay and improper ex officio notarization can lead to discipline. A judge who allows a submitted motion or case to sit unresolved for months or years may face administrative discipline, even when the underlying case has already moved on appeal. The practical lesson is direct: […]

When Sheriff Misconduct Complaints Fail: The Supreme Court Requires Proof, Participation, and a Real Administrative Case

Sheriff misconduct charges may be dismissed when the complainant fails to prosecute and later confirms the dispute arose from misunderstanding, not extortion. Administrative complaints against sheriffs do not survive on accusation alone: when the complainant fails to prosecute the case and later confirms that the incident arose from misunderstanding rather than extortion, the Supreme Court […]

Complaints Against Sheriffs Can Fail When the Complainant Cannot Prosecute the Case

A sheriff misconduct complaint was dismissed after the complainant could not attend the hearing, showing that administrative charges require active prosecution and proof. Administrative complaints against sheriffs and other court personnel do not succeed on accusations alone. Even where the allegation is serious, such as a sheriff allegedly forcing entry into a home while serving […]

Family Problems Do Not Excuse Unauthorized Absences in Public Service

Personal hardship does not excuse repeated unauthorized absences in public service; mitigation may reduce the penalty but not erase administrative liability. Government employees who repeatedly fail to report for work cannot avoid discipline by invoking personal hardship, illness, or family emergencies when their absences are unauthorized, prolonged, and disruptive to public service. The ruling in […]

Mining Contract Disputes Must First Go to the Mines Bureau, Not the Trial Court

Mining contract enforcement disputes must go to the Bureau of Mines, not regular courts, when the law gives the agency exclusive jurisdiction. Parties fighting over mining contracts cannot bypass the government agency given exclusive jurisdiction over those disputes by filing a civil case for declaratory relief and damages. When the controversy concerns the cancellation or […]

Court Employees Can Be Dismissed for Concealing a Criminal Conviction and Trying to Influence Cases

Court personnel may be dismissed for concealing a conviction, interfering in pending cases, and making false sworn statements about their record. Public officers and court employees can lose their government career not only for mishandling records or violating office rules, but also for lying about their criminal history and using their position to interfere with […]