Baseless Court Employee Complaints Can Backfire: Why Evidence Matters in Administrative Charges

Administrative complaints need proof. The Court dismissed baseless charges against a deputy clerk and reprimanded the complainant for unfounded accusations. A person who files an administrative complaint against a court employee must be prepared to prove it with competent evidence; otherwise, the complaint may not only be dismissed, but the complainant may also be reprimanded […]

When a Government Employer Misses the Appeal Deadline, a Compensation Award Becomes Final

A government employer lost its challenge to a disability award after missing the appeal deadline, confirming that final compensation awards bind public agencies. A government employer cannot defeat an employeeโ€™s compensation award by filing a late petition for relief after the award has already become final. The decisive rule is simple but powerful: once the […]

No Notice, No Compensation Award: Due Process Still Controls Labor Claims

A compensation award was set aside because the record failed to show service, notice, or hearing, preserving due process while allowing the claim to proceed. Employers may challenge a labor compensation award when the record does not show that they were served with the claim, notified of the proceedings, and given a real opportunity to […]

When One Judge Is Not Enough: Why Reconsideration Must Be Decided by the Proper Tribunal

A single judge cannot deny reconsideration when the law requires en banc action. The ruling warns taxpayers and businesses to verify proper tribunal authority. A motion for reconsideration is not a mere formality when the law requires a collegial body to act. If a court or administrative tribunal must decide en banc, a ruling issued […]

Caught Red-Handed: When Public Officers Can Be Summarily Dismissed Without a Full Formal Investigation

Public officers caught in serious corruption may be summarily dismissed when evidence is strong, protecting audit integrity, contractors, and public funds. Public officers caught in a serious act of corruption may be removed through summary proceedings when the evidence of guilt is strong, even without the usual full-dress administrative investigation. For taxpayers and regulated businesses, […]

When a Government Employeeโ€™s Work Illness Claim Cannot Be Defeated by a Filing Technicality

A government employeeโ€™s work-illness claim survived a wrong-forum appeal because the employer admitted work connection and failed to controvert compensation. A workerโ€™s compensation claim should not be thrown out simply because an appeal was filed in the wrong office when no party was prejudiced, especially where the employer did not controvert the illness and even […]

When a Fight Over a Local Treasurer Becomes Too Late for the Courts to Decide

A local treasurer appointment dispute was dismissed as moot after the officers moved on, showing why public finance challenges must remain live. A court case over who should occupy a public finance office can disappear before judgment when the office, the officers, and the controversy itself have already moved on. The doctrine is simple but […]

When Tax Declarations Are Wrong, Good-Faith Judicial Reliance May Still Defeat Misconduct Claims

Wrong tax declarations used in bail bonds did not prove judicial misconduct where sureties swore to property sufficiency and the judge acted on facial compliance. Judges are not automatically administratively liable when property tax declarations used for bail bonds later turn out to be inaccurate, especially where the sureties personally appeared, swore to their qualifications, […]

When a Court Hearing Becomes Void: Why Notice to Counsel Is Essential Due Process

The Supreme Court voided an ex parte hearing where counsel lacked meaningful notice of the correct venue, reaffirming due process in litigation. A party can lose a case not because the facts are weak, but because the court proceeds without giving its lawyer meaningful notice of when and where the hearing will occur. In Insular […]