When Aggravating Circumstances Fail, Death Penalty Must Fall: The Proof Rule in Murder Cases

Supreme Court reduced a murder death sentence to reclusion perpetua after ruling that most alleged aggravating circumstances were not proved. A person convicted of murder cannot receive the harshest possible penalty unless every alleged aggravating circumstance is proved with the same discipline required for the crime itself. In People v. Cortes, the Supreme Court held […]

Missed Appeal Fees Can Kill Your Case Even When Notice Was Timely

A timely notice of appeal is not enough; failure to pay appellate docket fees within the appeal period can make judgment final and executable. A timely notice of appeal is not enough to keep a losing party’s case alive. When the Rules require appellate docket and lawful fees to be paid within the same period […]

When One Credible Witness Can Defeat an Alibi in a Criminal Trial

A lone credible witness may sustain conviction despite alibi, denial, and lack of motive when identity is clearly established and testimony matches physical evidence. A conviction can stand on the testimony of a single witness when that testimony is positive, credible, and consistent with the physical evidence. For accused persons, victims’ families, and trial lawyers, […]

When Drug Possession Is Absorbed in Sale: A Criminal Defense Lesson on Double Charging and Buy-Bust Evidence

The Court affirmed a marijuana sale conviction but set aside separate possession liability, holding possession was absorbed in the same sale transaction. A person accused of selling prohibited drugs should not automatically face a separate conviction for possession when the possession is merely part of the same sale transaction. In People v. De Jesus, the […]

When a Victim’s Clear Testimony Is Enough to Convict in a Philippine Criminal Case

Credible victim testimony can sustain a rape conviction despite inconclusive medical findings, delayed reporting, and claims that the location made the crime improbable. A conviction for rape may rest on the credible, clear, and candid testimony of the complainant, even when medical findings are inconclusive and even when the attack occurred in a place that […]

Weak Alibi Is Not Enough: Why Criminal Convictions Still Require a Coherent Prosecution Story

A rape conviction was reversed because a weak alibi cannot cure gaps in the prosecution’s evidence. Criminal guilt must still be proved beyond reasonable doubt. A criminal accused may be acquitted even when his defense looks weak, if the prosecution’s own evidence leaves serious unanswered questions. People v. Tempongko, Jr. is a stark reminder that […]

When a Confession Becomes Evidence: Why Conspiracy Can Defeat Alibi and Fear Defenses in Criminal Cases

The Court affirmed robbery with homicide, holding that voluntary confessions, coordinated acts, and weak alibi can prove conspiracy beyond reasonable doubt. People accused of a serious crime cannot defeat conviction by simply saying their confession was forced, that they were only afraid of a co-accused, or that they were somewhere nearby. The Petenia ruling reinforces […]

One Credible Eyewitness Can Convict: Why Alibi Fails Without Physical Impossibility

A single credible eyewitness can sustain conviction, while alibi fails unless it proves physical impossibility; murder was reduced to homicide. A criminal conviction may stand on the testimony of a single credible eyewitness, even if that witness is young and even if minor inconsistencies appear in the story. For an accused person relying on alibi, […]

When Credible Victim Testimony Is Enough to Sustain a Rape Conviction

Credible victim testimony may sustain a rape conviction even without spermatozoa, extensive injuries, or clothing evidence, but aggravating circumstances must be proven. A rape conviction may rest on the testimony of the offended party when her account is clear, credible, and consistent with the physical and surrounding evidence. For accused persons, victims, and families, the […]

When a Rape Victim’s Testimony Is Enough to Convict: Why Alibi Must Make Presence Impossible

Rape conviction affirmed where credible victim testimony and medical findings outweighed denial and a weak alibi that did not make presence impossible. A rape conviction may rest on the victim’s credible testimony, especially when medical findings support her account and the accused’s alibi does not make it physically impossible for him to be at the […]