When Eyewitness Identification Defeats an Alibi in a Murder Case

Positive eyewitness identification defeated alibi in a murder appeal, with the Court upholding conviction despite minor inconsistencies and procedural objections. A person accused of murder cannot rely on alibi when eyewitnesses place him at the scene, know him personally, and describe his participation in the attack with enough clarity to leave no reasonable doubt. For […]

When Inconsistent Conduct Creates Reasonable Doubt in a Criminal Trial

The Court acquitted an accused where uncorroborated testimony and surrounding facts created reasonable doubt, reaffirming the presumption of innocence. Criminal convictions cannot rest on testimony that leaves the court with serious, reasonable doubt. Even in a prosecution involving a grave accusation, the constitutional presumption of innocence prevails when the complainant’s account is uncorroborated and the […]

When a Credible Victim’s Testimony Defeats Alibi: What Dadag Teaches About Criminal Appeals

The Court affirmed a rape conviction, stressing that credible victim testimony can overcome weak alibi and that neither sperm findings nor hymenal rupture is required. A conviction for rape may stand on the credible, straightforward testimony of the offended party even when the accused presents an alibi, points to alleged inconsistencies, or argues that medical […]

Poor Litigants Can Appeal Without Paying for a Printed Record

Pauper litigants allowed to appeal need not file a printed record on appeal; procedural reforms may apply retroactively to protect appellate review. Litigants who are allowed to appeal as paupers are not required to shoulder the cost of preparing and filing a printed record on appeal. For taxpayers, property owners, and ordinary litigants who may […]

Positive Identification Beats Alibi: Why Eyewitness Credibility Still Decides Criminal Cases

A murder conviction was affirmed because credible eyewitness identification prevailed over alibi, with the Court increasing civil indemnity to P30,000. A criminal accused cannot defeat a direct, credible eyewitness identification merely by saying he was somewhere else, especially when his alleged location does not make it physically impossible for him to be at the crime […]

When Doubt Defeats a Rape Conviction: Why Testimony Must Still Prove Guilt Beyond Reasonable Doubt

The Supreme Court acquitted an accused in a rape case after finding that weak and improbable testimony failed to overcome reasonable doubt. Even in the most serious criminal accusations, conviction cannot rest on sympathy, suspicion, or an accusation that leaves material doubts unresolved. The doctrine from People v. Bania is simple but powerful: when the […]