When Circumstantial Evidence Proves Killing but Not Murder

The Supreme Court upheld Pañosa’s liability for killing but reduced murder to homicide because treachery and abuse of superior strength were not proved. A homicide conviction may rest on circumstantial evidence when the facts form an unbroken chain pointing to the accused, but that same evidence will not automatically prove murder unless treachery, abuse of […]

When Alcohol and Self-Defense Fail: The Supreme Court Clarifies Homicide Liability

The Supreme Court affirmed a homicide conviction, rejecting self-defense and clarifying that mere drinking does not prove mitigating intoxication. A person who admits stabbing another in claimed self-defense carries the burden of proving unlawful aggression, and mere drinking before the incident will not reduce criminal liability unless actual intoxication is clearly shown. The ruling is […]

When Child Trafficking Becomes Qualified Trafficking: Why a Broker Cannot Escape Liability by Calling Himself a Mere Escort

Child trafficking broker liability affirmed: arranging, escorting, and collecting payment for a minor’s exploitation can sustain qualified trafficking conviction. A person who arranges, accompanies, collects payment for, or otherwise brokers the sexual exploitation of a child may be convicted of qualified trafficking even if he claims he did not personally commit the sexual acts. For […]

When Minor Inconsistencies Cannot Defeat a Child Trafficking Conviction

The Supreme Court affirmed a qualified trafficking conviction, holding that transporting, offering, and arranging a child for sexual exploitation is punishable. A person who arranges, transports, introduces, or offers a child to clients for sexual services may be convicted of qualified trafficking even if the child was first introduced by someone else, even if payment […]

Grenade Evidence Must Survive Chain of Custody: Why a Valid Arrest Still Does Not Guarantee Conviction

A valid hot-pursuit arrest did not save an explosives conviction where police failed to prove chain of custody, but robbery was affirmed on credible eyewitness testimony. A criminal conviction can survive a warrantless hot-pursuit arrest and still fail if the prosecution cannot prove that the seized physical evidence was preserved, identified, and accounted for from […]

Just Compensation Objection Waiver: Why Delay Can Defeat Expropriation Appeals

In expropriation cases, parties waive attacks on commissioners and valuation reports by failing to object within Rule 67 deadlines. Property owners and expropriating agencies cannot sleep on procedural objections in just compensation cases. The Just Compensation Objection Waiver doctrine means that a party who fails to timely object to the appointment of commissioners or to […]

Late Appeals Can Kill Even High-Value Refund Claims: When Procedural Neglect Becomes Final

A missed appellant’s brief can end an appeal. The Supreme Court held that ordinary counsel negligence and repeated neglect do not justify appellate leniency. Missing the deadline to file an appellant’s brief can end a case, even when the losing party believes the trial court made serious factual or legal errors. The Supreme Court made […]

Small Inconsistencies Do Not Destroy a Rape Conviction When the Core Testimony Remains Credible

Credible victim testimony can sustain a rape conviction despite minor inconsistencies, but penalty-increasing facts must be properly alleged in the information. Minor inconsistencies in a rape victim’s narration will not automatically defeat a criminal case when the essential story remains clear: that force, intimidation, and sexual assault occurred. For accused persons, complainants, and families involved […]