When Age Is Not Proven, a Death Sentence for Rape Cannot Stand

The Court upheld a rape conviction but reduced the death penalty because the prosecution failed to prove the victim’s age with certainty. In rape prosecutions where the death penalty depends on the victim being below a statutory age, the prosecution must prove that age with the same certainty required to prove the crime itself. A […]

When a Child’s Testimony Is Enough to Convict: The Supreme Court’s Rule on Credibility, Alibi, and Qualified Rape

A child’s credible testimony can sustain a rape conviction, while denial and alibi fail unless presence at the crime scene was physically impossible. A rape conviction may stand principally on the testimony of a child victim when that testimony is categorical, consistent, and credible; the accused cannot defeat it with bare denial, family resentment theories, […]

When a Criminal Information Fails to Allege Relationship, the Death Penalty Cannot Stand

Rape conviction affirmed, but death penalty reduced because the information failed to allege the precise qualifying relationship required by law. A person charged with rape cannot be sentenced to the gravest qualifying penalty unless the facts that make the crime qualified are expressly alleged in the criminal information. Even where the evidence proves a close […]

A Missing Murder Weapon Does Not Defeat Eyewitness Testimony, But Uncharged Aggravating Facts Cannot Raise the Penalty

Eyewitness testimony can sustain a murder conviction even without the weapon, but uncharged aggravating facts cannot justify the death penalty. A murder conviction may stand even when the firearm is never recovered, if credible eyewitnesses positively identify the assailant and their testimony is consistent with the physical evidence. But the penalty cannot be pushed to […]

When Alibi Fails: Why Positive Eyewitness Identification Can Sustain a Rape-with-Homicide Conviction

Alibi failed against positive eyewitness identification in a rape-with-homicide conviction, with damages modified for civil indemnity, moral and temperate awards. In criminal cases, an alibi will not defeat a direct, categorical, and credible eyewitness account unless the accused proves that it was physically impossible for him to be at the crime scene. For persons facing […]

Child Rape, Delayed Disclosure, and the Rule That Fear Does Not Defeat Credibility

Child rape conviction affirmed despite delayed disclosure, but death penalty removed because the qualifying relationship was not properly alleged in the Information. A child’s silence after sexual abuse does not automatically weaken her case, especially where fear, intimidation, family pressure, or psychological trauma explains the delayed disclosure. In Negosa, the Court reaffirmed that rape prosecutions […]

Rape Convictions Cannot Rest on a Theory the Accused Was Never Required to Defend Against

Rape conviction reversed because the prosecution failed to prove the charged mode of force or intimidation and could not rely on an uncharged theory. A criminal conviction must stand or fall on the charge actually made, not on a different theory discovered only after trial. In People v. Mendigurin, the Supreme Court acquitted an accused […]

When the Charge Is Defective, the Penalty Cannot Be Upgraded After Trial

The Supreme Court affirmed murder and rape convictions but reduced penalties where homicide was not alleged in the rape information. A criminal conviction may stand even when the accused’s defense fails, but the penalty cannot be increased for a graver crime unless the charging document itself alleges the facts that make that graver crime punishable. […]

A Guilty Plea Is Not Enough in Death Penalty Cases: Why Courts Must Still Hear Evidence

A guilty plea in a capital case cannot support conviction alone; courts must conduct a searching inquiry and require prosecution evidence before judgment. An accused person who pleads guilty to a capital offense cannot be convicted on that plea alone. In the most serious criminal cases, the court must still conduct a searching inquiry, require […]