When a Bank’s Small Encoding Error Becomes a Damages Case

Banks may owe moral damages when negligent account handling causes checks to be dishonored, but exemplary damages require malice or bad faith. Banks may be held liable for moral damages when a seemingly small clerical mistake causes a depositor’s checks to be wrongfully dishonored. The rule is practical and client-facing: because banking depends on trust, […]

Resident Foreign Corporation Rule: Foreign Banks May File Insolvency Cases

Foreign banks doing business in the Philippines may be resident creditors allowed to file involuntary insolvency cases against local debtors. The Resident Foreign Corporation Rule means that a foreign corporation licensed and actually doing business in the Philippines may be treated as a Philippine resident for purposes of invoking remedies available to resident creditors. For […]

When Land Reform Bonds Pay Off a Mortgage: What Borrowers and Banks Need to Know

Land Bank agrarian reform bonds may pay a mortgage at face value, but borrowers cannot demand partial release while the secured debt remains unpaid. Borrowers whose mortgaged land is taken under agrarian reform may insist that Land Bank compensation bonds be applied to their existing mortgage debt, but they cannot demand that the bank release […]

Foreclosure Buyers May Take Possession Even Before Redemption Ends

Foreclosure buyers may obtain possession even during redemption if Act No. 3135 requirements are met; borrowers must challenge defects separately. A buyer at an extrajudicial foreclosure sale may obtain possession of the foreclosed property even during the redemption period, so long as the statutory requirements are met. For banks, lenders, and auction purchasers, the ruling […]

Buying One Share Does Not Open a Bank’s Books: Good Faith Limits on Stockholder Inspection Rights

A one-share stockholder cannot inspect bank records without good faith, legitimate purpose, and compliance with special charter confidentiality limits. A stockholder’s right to inspect corporate records is powerful, but it is not a license to buy a token share merely to investigate past transactions, gather litigation material, or pry into confidential bank affairs unrelated to […]

A Preliminary Injunction Requires a Clear Legal Right, Not Just Suspicion of Fraud

A party cannot enjoin payment under a letter of credit without showing its own clear legal right against the bank or beneficiary. A court cannot stop a bank from honoring a letter of credit merely because another party claims fraud in a separate transaction. A preliminary injunction is an extraordinary remedy: the party asking for […]

Bank Secrecy Cannot Defeat a Court-Ordered Garnishment of Deposits

Bank secrecy does not bar court-ordered garnishment of deposits when disclosure is incidental to enforcing a final judgment against a debtor. A judgment debtor cannot hide money in a bank account to avoid paying a final court judgment. Bank secrecy protects deposits from unauthorized examination, but it does not place those deposits beyond the reach […]