When a Resignation Letter Defeats an Illegal Dismissal Claim

The Supreme Court ruled that signed resignation letters, settlement benefits, and quitclaims can defeat constructive dismissal claims absent concrete proof of coercion. Employees who sign resignation letters, accept separation benefits, and execute quitclaims may later lose an illegal dismissal case if they cannot prove that their resignation was forced. In Saudi Arabian Airlines v. Castells […]

Golf Clubs With Shares May Still Be Non-Stock Corporations If They Cannot Pay Dividends

Golf clubs with shares may still be non-stock corporations if they lack authority to pay dividends, affecting SEC compliance, voting rights, and tax analysis. A corporation does not become a stock corporation simply because it issues shares, certificates, or transferable club interests. For corporate, tax, and governance purposes, the decisive test remains whether the corporation […]

When a Donation of Land Fails, Possession and Good Intentions Cannot Defeat a Torrens Title

A void donation of land creates no equitable title. The Supreme Court upheld dismissal of a schoolโ€™s quieting of title case against a Torrens-title holder. A school, charity, church, foundation, or family corporation that occupies land for decades cannot quiet title unless it can first prove legal or equitable ownership. In Santos Ventura Hocorma Foundation, […]

Court Personnel Cannot Take Money From Litigantsโ€”Even If They Call It a Loan

Court employees may be dismissed for receiving money from litigants, even if called a loan, when it suggests influence over a pending case. Court employees who receive money from litigants, accused persons, or people seeking help in pending cases face dismissal even when they later claim the payment was merely a personal loan. The Supreme […]

When a Lawyer Misses Appeals, Withdraws Without Consent, and Lets a Clientโ€™s Case Die

The Supreme Court disbarred a lawyer for missed appeals, improper withdrawal, and failure to report misconduct, clarifying client remedies for gross negligence. Clients whose cases are lost because their lawyer failed to present evidence, missed appeal deadlines, or withdrew without proper notice are not limited to private complaints for damages. They may seek professional discipline, […]

Assignees Beware: Taking Over a Lease Can Mean Taking Over Old Rental Debts

Assignees of commercial leases may inherit old rental arrears when the assignment broadly transfers all leasehold rights and obligations without clear exclusions. A business that takes over another personโ€™s lease may inherit more than the right to occupy the premises. When the assignment says the assignee assumes all responsibilities and obligations under the lease, old […]

How Importers Can Redeem Seized Shipments Without Fraud Liability

The CTA ruled that Globe Telecom could redeem its seized shipment as no fraud was attributable, clarifying importer rights under CMTA and CAO rules for misdeclaration cases. Importers now have a clear precedent for redeeming seized shipments when no fraud is attributable, ensuring compliance with customs regulations while protecting their rights to recover goods. Businesses […]

Ninja Van Reaccredited for Court Filings: What Taxpayers and Lawyers Should Know Before Serving CTA Pleadings

Ninja Van remains accredited for nationwide court filings, including CTA-related submissions, but taxpayers must still preserve proof of timely service and filing. Taxpayers, litigants, and lawyers may continue using Ninja Van for nationwide service and filing of pleadings, motions, notices, orders, judgments, and other court submissions, including matters involving the Court of Tax Appeals, during […]

Pre-Need Planholders Must Bring Claims to the Insurance Commission, But Courts May Still End Long Litigation When Justice Requires It

Pre-need plan claims belong to the Insurance Commission, but the Court may resolve long-litigated disputes and enforce tuition guarantees despite ambiguous maturity dates. Pre-need planholders seeking payment, reimbursement, or enforcement of educational plan benefits must ordinarily file their claims with the Insurance Commission, not the regular courts, because claims involving pre-need plans fall within the […]

Shareholder Derivative Suits Can Be Dismissed When Investors Skip Internal Corporate Remedies

Minority shareholders must plead specific exhausted corporate remedies before filing a derivative suit; letters and meetings alone may not be enough. Minority stockholders cannot use a derivative suit as a first resort when they have not pleaded, with particularity, the internal corporate remedies they tried and failed to exhaust. For business owners, directors, corporate secretaries, […]