Bank Complaints Dismissed by BSP Can Be Refiled, Not Immediately Elevated to Certiorari

BSP complaints dismissed without prejudice for lack of prima facie evidence should generally be refiled with stronger proof, not elevated by certiorari. A dismissed BSP administrative complaint does not always end the dispute. When the Office of the Special Investigation dismisses a bank complaint for lack of a prima facie case, the complainant’s immediate remedy […]

Proven Tolerance Rule: Why Ejectment Failed in a Property Dispute

Unlawful detainer fails when tolerance is unproven and the one-year period has lapsed; property owners may need a full civil action. The Proven Tolerance Rule warns property owners that an ejectment case cannot rest on bare claims that an occupant was merely allowed to stay out of kindness. In Philippine property litigation, a party who […]

Tax Mootness Rule: Repealed VAT Rules Can End Tax Litigation

A tax challenge becomes moot when a later regulation restores the exemption, leaving no live controversy or injunction issue for courts to decide. The Tax Mootness Rule matters because even a major tax controversy may disappear once the government later changes the regulation being challenged. For taxpayers, trade groups, and businesses questioning a BIR rule, […]

Holding Company Tax Rule: Passive Dividends Are Not Local Business Tax

Holding companies are not taxable as financial institutions on passive dividends unless they regularly perform financial intermediary functions. Holding companies are not automatically financial institutions just because they earn dividends or interest. For Philippine businesses, the Holding Company Tax Rule means that a city cannot impose local business tax on passive investment income unless the […]

Tax Compliance Cannot Save a Defective Incorporation from SEC Correction

Tax payments and reportorial compliance do not cure defective incorporation, but a deceased incorporator does not always justify corporate revocation. A corporation that keeps tax filings current and pays government dues cannot use tax compliance as a shield against defects in its corporate birth. In AZ 17/31 Realty, the Supreme Court drew an important line: […]

Builder in Bad Faith Rule: When Landowners Must Reimburse Improvements

Landowners who knowingly allow construction may owe reimbursement despite title; silence can trigger Civil Code builder rights. The builder in bad faith rule now has an important exception: a landowner who knowingly allows a relative or occupant to build permanent improvements on titled property, without timely objection, may still be required to reimburse the builder […]

Government Instrumentality Tax Immunity: LRTA Real Property Tax Rule

National government instrumentalities like LRTA are exempt from local real property tax, except portions beneficially used by taxable private parties. Government Instrumentality Tax Immunity now gives national government agencies with corporate powers a stronger shield against local real property tax assessments when their properties are devoted to public use. For cities, assessors, treasurers, public authorities, […]

When City Hall Cannot Tax Public Transport Property: The LRTA Real Property Tax Exemption Rule

LRTA railways and terminals are exempt from Pasay real property tax as public-use property of a government instrumentality, except portions leased to taxable private users. Local governments cannot impose real property tax on railways, terminals, and related public transport properties owned through a national government instrumentality, unless the beneficial use of a specific portion has […]

Land Registration Renewal Rule: When a Failed Title Case Can Be Refiled

Failed land registration cases may be refiled when no final ownership ruling exists and RA 11573 cures prior proof defects. The Land Registration Renewal Rule means that a failed land registration case does not automatically end a property owner’s chance to secure title forever. When an earlier application was dismissed for insufficient evidence, and no […]