POGO Tax Statutory Basis Rule: When BIR Tax Issuances Fail

BIR issuances cannot create POGO taxes without statutory basis; offshore licensees were not liable before RA 11590 took effect. The POGO Tax Statutory Basis Rule protects taxpayers from being taxed by administrative issuance alone: before a tax can be collected, Congress must clearly impose it by law, and the BIR cannot create the tax by […]

Leviable Equitable Interest Rule: When Labor Awards Reach Property

Labor awards may reach equitable property interests; a registered levy defeated Belle’s prior unregistered sale in a Philippine labor execution dispute. The Leviable Equitable Interest Rule gives judgment creditors a practical enforcement remedy: a final labor award may reach not only property titled in the debtor’s name, but also valuable equitable interests held through liquidation, […]

Tax Regulation Ultra Vires Rule: When BIR Rules Go Too Far

BIR tax rules are void when they expand the Tax Code, restrict deductions, or impose accounting methods without legal basis. Taxpayers may challenge a revenue regulation when the BIR or Department of Finance uses rulemaking to impose burdens that Congress itself did not authorize. The Tax Regulation Ultra Vires Rule confirms that administrative agencies may […]

Constructive Delivery of Land: When Sale Documents Prove Ownership

Constructive delivery can transfer land ownership when deeds, survey, possession, and conduct prove a completed real property sale. Constructive delivery of land can transfer ownership even when the buyer never personally occupies the property, so long as the parties’ documents, conduct, possession arrangement, and payment show that the land was already placed under the buyer’s […]

When Can a City Council Remove an SK Official? The Supreme Court Draws the Line Between SK Chairperson and Federation President

City councils may remove SK chairpersons under the SK Reform Act, but not directly remove SK federation presidents whose cases go to the Office of the President. City councils may remove an elected Sangguniang Kabataan chairperson for statutory grounds under the SK Reform Act without first going to court, but they cannot directly remove an […]

A Notarized Document Can Still Collapse When the Signers Never Personally Appeared

The Supreme Court penalized a lawyer-notary for notarizing property documents without proper identity checks or personal appearance, exposing fraud involving deceased signers. Notarization is not a rubber stamp: when a notary fails to confirm the personal appearance and competent identity of the signers, the lawyer may lose the notarial commission, be barred from notarizing documents, […]

Title-Specific Tax Exemption Rule: When Refund Claims Fail

Income tax exemptions do not cover stock transaction tax unless the NIRC clearly extends them; refund claims are strictly construed. The Title-Specific Tax Exemption Rule matters because a taxpayer exempt from one kind of tax is not automatically exempt from another. For investors, funds, foreign financial institutions, and companies trading listed shares in the Philippines, […]

Redundancy Is Not a Shortcut: Employers Must Prove the Business Need Before Ending a Job

Redundancy requires substantial proof. A BPO employee’s dismissal was illegal where the employer failed to prove business need and imposed a prejudicial transfer. Employees dismissed for redundancy may challenge the termination when the employer cannot prove, with real business evidence, that their work has become excessive or unnecessary. A company cannot rely on management discretion […]

Legal Education Balance: Limits on LEB Power Over Law Schools

LEB may regulate legal education, but compulsory PhiLSAT and control over admissions, faculty, and internships violates law schools’ academic freedom. The Legal Education Balance Doctrine now draws a clear constitutional line for Philippine law schools: the State may regulate legal education to improve standards, but it cannot take over a school’s academic judgment on who […]

Banks Must Personally Notify Borrowers Before Foreclosing Mortgaged Property

Banks must personally notify borrowers before extrajudicial foreclosure; failure can void the auction sale, certificate of sale, and bank’s title. Banks that foreclose real estate mortgages without personally notifying the borrower risk losing the foreclosure sale, the certificate of sale, and even the new title issued in their favor. The doctrine is simple but consequential: […]