Corporate Fiduciary Breach Is Not Automatically a Crime: When Bank Directors Face Civil, Not Penal, Liability

Corporate fiduciary breach under Section 31 creates civil liability, not automatic criminal prosecution; UCPB’s claim also prescribed after four years. Corporate officers and directors accused of bad faith, gross negligence, or conflicts of interest do not automatically face criminal prosecution under the old Corporation Code merely because their conduct caused financial damage to the company. […]

Mandatory Commissioners in Expropriation: Just Compensation Must Be Tried

Expropriation valuation requires commissioners; temporary construction use is not full taking, and just compensation needs evidence. Property owners and government agencies cannot shortcut the valuation stage in expropriation cases. Under the mandatory commissioners in expropriation doctrine, courts must appoint competent and disinterested commissioners to receive evidence and help determine just compensation, especially where consequential damages, […]

Agrarian Homelot Compensation Finality: When SC Rulings Must Be Paid

Final agrarian reform rulings on homelot compensation must be implemented, and DAR/Land Bank must validate and pay just compensation. Agrarian homelot compensation finality means that once the Supreme Court has definitively recognized a landowner’s right to just compensation, government agencies and opposing parties cannot keep reopening settled issues to delay payment. For landowners, farmer-beneficiaries, banks, […]

LGU Boundary Charter Rule: When Local Borders Control Tax and Power

Municipal boundaries follow the creating law, not later markers or tax records; LGUs cannot expand jurisdiction without legal authority. The LGU Boundary Charter Rule gives municipalities a hard lesson in territorial power: a local government cannot expand its jurisdiction by installing markers, collecting taxes, or relying on residents’ statements when the law creating the municipality […]

PAGCOR Licensee Tax Exemption Limits: Casino Income Remains Taxable

PAGCOR licensees operating private casinos are not automatically tax-exempt; casino revenues may remain subject to income tax, surcharge, and interest. The PAGCOR Licensee Tax Exemption Limits doctrine warns casino operators and freeport enterprises that a PAGCOR license does not automatically carry PAGCOR’s tax shield. A private entity licensed to operate its own casino cannot avoid […]

PAGCOR Licensee Tax Exemption Rule: Casino Operators Still Pay Tax

PAGCOR licensees operating their own casinos are not automatically tax-exempt and may face income tax, withholding tax, surcharge, and interest. The PAGCOR Licensee Tax Exemption Rule warns casino operators that a license from PAGCOR is not the same as sharing PAGCOR’s tax immunity. A private gaming operator that runs its own casino cannot avoid income […]

Expired Lease, No Injunction: Why Courts Cannot Stop Eviction Without a Clear Legal Right

Courts cannot issue injunctions over expired leases without a clear legal right; procedural shortcuts in summary cases may expose judges to discipline. Businesses, property owners, and government corporations defending possession of leased premises gain an important reminder from this ruling: a court cannot use a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction to protect a tenant […]

IPO Separate Computation Rule: Tax Due on Each Share Sale

IPO share taxes must be computed separately for primary and secondary offerings; joint computation cannot support a Philippine tax refund claim. The IPO Separate Computation Rule means that a corporation and its selling shareholders cannot blend primary and secondary offering shares to obtain a lower percentage tax rate. For companies planning a public listing, and […]

LOA Revalidation Rule: When a BIR Audit Stands Despite Delay

A BIR audit LOA must be validly served, but a 120-day delay does not automatically void assessments absent proof of due process violation. The LOA Revalidation Rule protects taxpayers from unauthorized BIR audits, but it does not automatically erase a tax assessment every time an audit takes longer than 120 days. For businesses facing a […]

Congress Can Restructure GOCC Offices Without Violating Security of Tenure

Congress may validly shorten GOCC officials’ terms and centralize compensation reform when done in good faith for fiscal discipline and public accountability. Congress may shorten the terms, restructure the offices, and rationalize the compensation of government-owned or controlled corporation officials when the changes are made in good faith, supported by a clear public policy, and […]