Torrens Title Reliance Rule: Why Registered Land Buyers Prevail

Good-faith buyers of registered land prevail over prior unregistered claims absent actual knowledge; possession cannot defeat Torrens title. The Torrens Title Reliance Rule protects a buyer who purchases registered land in good faith: an earlier unregistered claim, even if valid between the original parties, will not defeat a later buyer who relied on the clean […]

Assessed Value Jurisdiction Rule in Property Recovery Cases

Property recovery suits must allege assessed value; without it, RTC jurisdiction fails and all proceedings may be void under Philippine law. The Assessed Value Jurisdiction Rule means that a property owner can lose years of litigation if the complaint fails to allege the assessed value of the land. In Philippine property disputes, especially actions for […]

Asset Buyers Are Not Automatically Liable for a Seller’s Labor Judgment

A labor judgment cannot be enforced against non-parties added only at execution; corporate veil piercing requires jurisdiction and clear proof of wrongdoing. A winning employee cannot collect a final labor judgment from a company’s president or from a related asset buyer by simply adding them at the execution stage. The Supreme Court drew a hard […]

PAGCOR Tax Split Doctrine: Gaming Income Gets Franchise Tax Only

Gaming income covered by PAGCOR’s charter pays only 5% franchise tax, but related-service income and taxable fringe benefits remain assessable. The PAGCOR Tax Split Doctrine matters because it prevents the government from treating all income of a gaming franchise holder as if it were taxed the same way. For PAGCOR, income from gaming operations is […]

Clear Proof Rule: Reconstituting Lost Land Titles in the Philippines

Lost Torrens titles require clear proof; tax declarations, plans, and uncertified photocopies cannot justify title reconstitution in court. Property owners seeking to restore a lost or destroyed Torrens title must do more than show tax declarations, sketch plans, or photocopies. Under the Clear Proof Rule for title reconstitution, courts may order the reissuance of a […]

Security Guards Cannot Be Forced to Drop Labor Claims Before Getting Reassigned

Security agencies may reassign guards, but not to force withdrawal of labor claims. The Court upheld illegal dismissal while absolving the president absent bad faith. Security agencies may transfer or place guards on floating status for legitimate business reasons, but they cross the line into illegal dismissal when reassignment is used as leverage to force […]

Unregistered Land Buyer Peril Rule: Banks Lose Bad Mortgages

Buyers of unregistered land act at their peril; banks may lose mortgages if the borrower had no ownership and prior possession proves another claim. The Unregistered Land Buyer Peril Rule means that a bank, buyer, or creditor who accepts unregistered land as security cannot rely on good faith if the supposed owner had no real […]

When Insurance Contracts Point to Arbitration, Courts Must Send the Right Parties There

The Supreme Court enforced an incorporated arbitration clause and held that courts must refer bound parties to arbitration even in multi-party disputes. Businesses that accept insurance, membership, or commercial contracts incorporating separate rules may be bound by arbitration clauses found outside the signed main document. The Supreme Court made clear that when a valid arbitration […]

Due Process Tax Sale Rule: When Property Auctions Can Be Reopened

Tax sale buyers cannot rely on title cancellation alone when the owner claims lack of notice; due process may reopen the property dispute. The Due Process Tax Sale Rule protects property owners from losing land through a delinquency auction when they were allegedly denied meaningful notice of the levy and sale. Even if a buyer […]