Real Action Valuation Rule: Property Cases Need Correct Court

Real actions over land require proper property valuation; filing in the wrong court can void proceedings and cause dismissal. The Real Action Valuation Rule means that a lawsuit cannot avoid jurisdictional limits and docket fee requirements by calling itself specific performance when its real objective is to recover land, cancel a title, or secure ownership. […]

When a Hybrid Public-Private Institution Can Face Civil Service Discipline

The Red Cross may face Civil Service Commission review in disciplinary cases, allowing the CSC to increase penalties where public accountability rules apply. A worker in a legally unique institution cannot always escape public-sector discipline by arguing that the organization is not a government corporation. Where the institution performs a public humanitarian function and the […]

PPP Bid Deference Rule: Courts Won’t Rebid Airport Projects

Courts defer to PPP bid agencies absent grave abuse; unsupported attacks on bidder capacity will not void awards or justify injunctions in Philippines. The PPP Bid Deference Rule means that courts will not redo a public bidding evaluation simply because critics believe another bidder was safer, richer, or better qualified. For businesses joining public-private partnership […]

No Consideration, No Sale: Void Property Deals in the Philippines

A deed of sale without actual consideration is void from the start, so unpaid buyers acquire no ownership despite notarization. No consideration, no sale: a notarized deed of sale will not transfer ownership if the buyer never paid the price and the supposed contract lacked cause from the beginning. For property owners, heirs, and buyers […]

When a Club Enforces Its Rules, Hurt Feelings Alone Do Not Create a Damages Case

A valid club suspension caused no compensable injury where members violated rules and failed to prove bad faith, fault, or negligence by the board. Private clubs, associations, and corporations may discipline members who violate valid internal rules, and a suspended member cannot recover millions in moral or exemplary damages merely by showing embarrassment, inconvenience, or […]

Offline Carrier Tax Treaty Rule: Air Canada Refund Denied

Foreign airlines selling tickets locally may avoid GPB tax, but treaty-limited income tax can still defeat a Philippine tax refund claim. The Offline Carrier Tax Treaty Rule means that a foreign airline selling tickets in the Philippines may escape Gross Philippine Billings tax if it has no Philippine-originating flights, but it can still be treated […]

FTAA Contract Jurisdiction Rule: Why Forum Matters in Mining Disputes

FTAA cancellations are contractual administrative acts, not Rule 43 judgments; parties must use the proper court remedy to challenge mining contract validity. Government resource contracts cannot be attacked, appealed, or defended as if every executive action were a court judgment. The FTAA Contract Jurisdiction Rule teaches a practical lesson for companies dealing with mining rights, […]

Inherited Shares Do Not Give Voting Control Until Recorded in the Stock and Transfer Book

Heirs of corporate shares cannot vote or seize control until transfers are recorded in the Stock and Transfer Book; a GIS is not controlling proof. Heirs and buyers of corporate shares cannot use those shares to seize board control, call stockholders’ meetings, or elect officers until the transfer is recorded in the corporation’s Stock and […]

When a Court Has Already Decided Corporate Membership, a Board Cannot Relitigate It by Passing a New Resolution

A final ruling on corporate membership bars relitigation; a later board resolution cannot revive issues already decided between the same parties. A corporation cannot defeat a final court ruling on membership rights by issuing a new board resolution that merely repeats the same rejected position. Once a court has necessarily decided that a person remains […]

Workers Can Choose Mutual Aid Over Collective Bargaining: The Hanjin Ruling on Self-Organization

Workers with definite employers may form a workers’ association for mutual aid, but must avoid misleading use of an employer’s name. Workers with definite employers are not forced to organize only as a labor union for collective bargaining. They may instead form a workers’ association for mutual aid and protection, and an employer cannot cancel […]