Signed and Notarized Loan Documents Are Hard to Undo: When Courts Will Enforce Bank Mortgages Despite Claims of Fraud

Business borrowers challenging signed bank loan and mortgage documents must overcome presumptions of regularity with clear and convincing evidence. Borrowers, corporate officers, and property owners who sign notarized loan, mortgage, pledge, or surety documents cannot later defeat foreclosure by relying on bare allegations that the papers were simulated, coerced, or unsupported by consideration. The Supreme […]

When a Corporate By-Law Is Fixed, the Court May Refuse to Decide the Fight

A corrected corporate by-law can moot a governance case, leaving courts unable to issue advisory rulings on SEC powers or board election disputes. A corporate governance case can disappear before judgment when the corporation corrects the challenged by-law and no practical relief remains for the parties. For companies, stockholders, and directors, the ruling teaches a […]

Assurance Fund Claims: When Risky Land Deals Lose Protection

Assurance Fund claims fail when land buyers knowingly accept lis pendens risk or lose property through later contractual assumptions. The Assurance Fund Claims Rule protects innocent land buyers only when their loss is truly caused by Torrens registration fraud or registry error, not when they knowingly enter a later transaction despite notices of lis pendens […]

Local Machinery Tax Rule: Utility Assets Need Valid Assessment

Business machinery may be taxed as real property, but assessments lacking factual detail violate due process and can be voided. The Local Machinery Tax Rule matters because business equipment may be treated as taxable real property even when it is movable, but local governments must still issue a lawful, specific, and fact-based assessment before collecting […]

Tax Waiver Prescription Rule: When BIR Assessments Become Void

Defective BIR waivers do not extend tax assessment periods; prescribed deficiency assessments are void despite partial payment. Taxpayers may defeat a tax assessment when the Bureau of Internal Revenue relies on a defective waiver to extend the assessment period. The Tax Waiver Prescription Rule confirms that a waiver of the statute of limitations is not […]

Judiciary Workers Can Be Suspended for Private Immoral Conduct Even When It Happens Outside the Office

Court personnel may be suspended for private immoral conduct, even outside work, when it undermines judiciary standards and public trust. Court employees may face serious administrative discipline for private conduct that violates basic standards of morality and decency, even if the conduct happens outside the workplace and even if job performance is not directly affected. […]

Stockholders Can Prove Ownership Without a Stock Certificate

The Court held that stock ownership may be proven without a stock certificate, allowing shareholders to pursue inspection and corporate record claims. Corporate shareholders are not automatically stripped of inspection rights merely because they cannot produce a stock certificate in their own name. When a person can show subscriptions, payments, corporate records, SEC filings, minutes, […]

When a Corporate Control Dispute Can Stop a Criminal Case

A corporate faction cannot rush criminal charges while its authority to act for the company is still under litigation. The criminal case may be suspended. A criminal complaint filed in the corporation’s name may be suspended when the authority of the supposed corporate officers is still being litigated in a separate intra-corporate case. For business […]

Corporate Officers Are Not Personal Guarantors of Company Debts Without Clear Proof of Bad Faith

Corporate officers are not personally liable for company debts absent clear proof of bad faith, gross negligence, or patently unlawful corporate acts. A corporate officer who signs a company transaction does not automatically become personally liable when the corporation later fails to perform. The doctrine is practical and protective: creditors may pursue the corporation that […]