Mutual Insurance Tax Exemption: When CDA Registration Is Not Required

Mutual insurers may claim DST exemption without CDA registration when Section 199 itself does not require it and operations meet cooperative standards. Mutual life insurance companies may claim documentary stamp tax exemption when they function as cooperative companies under the Tax Code, even without registration with the Cooperative Development Authority, if the statute itself does […]

When Withholding Corporate Books Becomes a Criminal Case

Refusal to inspect a stock and transfer book may be criminal, but only if the accused acted for the corporation in denying statutory inspection rights. Stockholders and directors have a legally enforceable right to inspect a corporation’s records, minutes, and stock and transfer book, but a criminal prosecution for denial of that right will prosper […]

Dissolved Corporations Cannot Sue After the Three-Year Winding-Up Period

A revoked corporation cannot file a new lawsuit after the three-year winding-up period, even if it claims to be protecting or liquidating assets. A corporation whose registration has been revoked cannot simply return to court years later and file a new case in its own name. Once the three-year statutory winding-up period has expired, the […]

Torrens Title Collateral Attack Rule in Property Disputes

Torrens titles cannot be defeated through specific performance; claimants must file the proper direct action such as reconveyance. Property claimants cannot cancel or defeat a Torrens title by filing a case for specific performance when the real objective is to invalidate the registered owner’s title. The Torrens Title Collateral Attack Rule means that a person […]

Asset Purchases Are Not Mergers: When a Buyer Avoids the Seller’s Judgment Debts

Asset buyers do not automatically inherit seller debts; the Court rejected merger and successor liability claims in a BSP-approved bank asset sale. A company that buys another company’s assets does not automatically inherit the seller’s lawsuits, judgment debts, or execution liabilities. The practical lesson is direct: creditors cannot simply rename the buyer as the judgment […]

Possession Follows Ownership: SC Rule on Land Execution

Ownership rulings may include possession: losing a land claim can justify execution placing the winning owner in control without a new ejectment case. The Possession Follows Ownership Rule matters because a winning land claimant may be placed in possession even when the final decision does not expressly say so, if possession is necessarily included in […]

When Court Records Are Altered, Procedure Becomes a Due Process Problem

Court personnel committed grave misconduct by allowing an already-filed notice of appeal to be altered, prompting fines and possible lawyer discipline. Litigants are entitled to rely on the integrity of the court record. When a pleading is later altered to make it appear compliant with procedural rules, the issue is no longer a mere clerical […]

Patrimonial Land Rule: Why Possession Alone May Not Secure Title

Possession of public land cannot secure title unless the land was first declared patrimonial; alienable status alone is insufficient. The patrimonial land rule means that long possession of public land does not automatically ripen into ownership unless the land was first expressly converted into patrimonial property of the State. For property owners, developers, and buyers […]

Free Patent Redemption Rule: RTC Jurisdiction Over Land Repurchase

Free patent land repurchase suits belong in RTC because they enforce a statutory redemption right, not merely a low-value property claim. Free patent landowners and their heirs who timely seek to repurchase land sold within the five-year statutory period may file in the Regional Trial Court, even when the land’s stated value appears small. The […]

When a Lawyer Takes Your Money but Does Not File Your Case

A lawyer who accepted fees but failed for five years to file a client’s titling case was suspended for violating duties of fidelity and diligence. Clients who pay a lawyer to handle a legal matter are entitled to more than promises, vague updates, and years of inaction. When a lawyer accepts a case and receives […]