Judicial Clemency Is Not a Shortcut Back to the Bench

Judicial clemency requires independent proof of remorse and reformation; a former judgeโ€™s unsupported promise to reform was not enough. A judge who seeks to return to public service after being disciplined must do more than promise to do better. Judicial clemency requires independent proof of remorse, reformation, potential for public service, and circumstances showing that […]

Clear Tax Exemption Rule: Why Franchise Assets Still Face Realty Tax

Tax exemptions must be clear; franchise real properties remain taxable unless the law plainly exempts them from local real property tax. Tax exemptions must be written in clear and unmistakable language; a franchise holder cannot stop a real property tax levy simply by relying on an implied exemption or an earlier judgment against different local […]

Military Reservation Land Rule: Void Titles Revert to the State

Military reservation land is inalienable; titles issued without proof of private rights may be cancelled and reverted to the State. The military reservation land rule is a warning to private claimants and property buyers: even a final Torrens title may be cancelled if the land was inalienable public land and the registration court had no […]

Principal Relief Jurisdiction: When Land Cases Belong in the RTC

Annulment of deeds involving land belongs in the RTC when document nullity is the main relief, even if the property has low assessed value. Property owners cannot defeat a case for annulment of documents simply by pointing to the low assessed value of the land. Under the principal relief jurisdiction rule, when the real dispute […]

When a Lawyer Suspects Client Evidence Is False, Neglect Is Still Not an Option

A lawyer who suspects false client evidence must withdraw properly, not neglect the case. The Court suspended counsel for missed filings and disobedience. A lawyer who believes a client is trying to use false evidence cannot quietly sabotage the case. The proper remedy is withdrawal for good cause, not deliberate neglect that causes the clientโ€™s […]

Lawyers Can Fight Hard for Clients, But Court Orders and Courtroom Decorum Still Control

A lawyer was fined for ignoring court orders on MCLE compliance and using offensive pleadings, clarifying the limits of zealous advocacy. Zealous advocacy does not authorize a lawyer to ignore court orders, insult the court, or use pleadings as a vehicle for personal attacks. A lawyer may defend a client with firmness, but that duty […]

Asset Sale Non-Merger Rule: Tax Liability After Bank Acquisitions

Asset buyers are not liable for seller tax debts when the deal is an asset sale, not merger, and only identified liabilities were assumed. The asset sale non-merger rule protects an acquiring corporation from being made liable for another corporationโ€™s tax debts when the transaction is, by its clear terms, only a sale of identified […]

Judges Who Overstay Approved Travel Abroad Risk Salary Deduction and Discipline

Judges who overstay approved travel abroad without timely extension risk unauthorized absence, salary deduction, and administrative discipline. Judges and court employees cannot treat approved travel authority as flexible permission to remain abroad beyond the authorized dates. When an official knows, or should know, that travel plans will extend beyond the approved period, the proper remedy […]

Condominium Dues Disputes Belong in Special Commercial Court, Not Ordinary Civil Court

Condominium dues and voting-rights disputes are intra-corporate cases for Special Commercial Courts, not ordinary civil courts or HLURB. Condominium unit owners who dispute association dues, delinquency status, or voting rights in a condominium corporation must bring the case before the proper Special Commercial Court, even if the complaint is styled as a damages case. The […]